@srp723@liliap_@TheRealBwithnoS@RealCandaceO I didn't have time to lay in bed and curl up in a ball I still had a small child at home to raise my oldest son wasn't my only child when I lost my mother I still have my father to take care of couldn't curl up in a ball then either. Don't make me a bad person. I grieve every day
@liliap_@srp723@TheRealBwithnoS@RealCandaceO Your comment didn't State that this was your opinion I lost my dog, my mother, stepdaughter,my own son when I lost my son I packed a bag and I left town when I came back I enrolled in a class to keep myself busy does that make me a bad, everybody has their own process.
☮️🎶 Give Jihad a Chance 🎸🕊️
Has America learnt anything from 9/11?
Zohran Mamdani, Abdul El-Sayed, Macklemore, Ed Sheeran, Cenk Uygur, Hasan Piker, Sneako and the Cardboard Ayatollah Khamenei join John Lennon and Yoko Ono for their famous Bed-In for World Peace—or pieces. ☮️🎤🕊️
@mtgreenee@RealCandaceO Candice posted this picture herself on X when she tried to Swindle her landlord illegally, it's okay for Candice to be evil and post rotten things about people all over social media come on Marjorie what's good for the goose is good for the gander.
@mtgreenee@RealCandaceO Oh Marjorie don't get your panties in a wad she posted this picture herself on her X account. This is a picture she took when she tried to fake sick and swindle a landlord you can look it up it's public record don't try to blame Trump for Candice's shortcomings.
@mtgreenee And you're a liar, I see what you did there, I see how you edited his post, You have definitely walked onto the other side, You are a traitor I see that you are no longer a republican or a conservative. I hope the liberals are paying you well. This is what he actually wrote..
@mtgreenee You have lost your ever living mind lady no one is giving in to the democrats agenda Especially supporting transing minors, you are sick and delusional, for even listening to these lies who in the world are you listening to lady?Have you skipped over to the other side?
Note: The original version of this was posted on 10 JAN26. This new version has been lightly edited to fix some formatting issues, clarify a key point, add one more recommendation, and remove some less-than-neutral characterizations of persons and events. Thanks to @ZPoet for her editorial suggestions.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
We all need to turn down the temperature re the shooting death of Renee Good by ICE officer Jon Ross. First off, we need to stop denigrating and/or assigning evil intent to either of them -- and stop using those assignations to score political points.
Ms. Good and Officer Ross both made mistakes; as a result, she died for it and his life will never be the same. That means this is a tragedy, NOT a crime.
Second, to better understand what happened, we need to look at both the technical details of the actual 3-second event AND some of the background details that gave rise to the event and influenced its outcome.
Before we can do that, however, we must: a) Get our emotions under control;
b) Recognize that we must all stop using postmodern "thought" to twist what we see and hear into what fits our weltanschauung, not objective reality (for example, Officer Ross did NOT commit "murder" and Ms. Good did NOT commit "an act of domestic terrorism"); and
c) Understand that the loudest voices trying to make political hay from this tragedy are either painfully ignorant about the physics and law -- or don't care about objective reality .
Please read what follows with an open mind. It is a detailed technical analysis of what happened. I will conclude it with some perspective and my personal view thereof.
DISCUSSION
Here are primary problems with current assertions:
1. Disregard/dismissal of the actions that led to the shooting.
2. No understanding of "dynamic environments" and "life-threatening situations."
3. No awareness that "Monday Morning Quarterbacking" is a pejorative term for a reason.
1. Disregard/dismissal of the actions that led to the shooting.
There is a term the military uses called "preparing the battlespace." It means creating an environment which increases your chances of success. In this situation, there were multiple "battlespace preparation" factors that directly led to Ms. Good's death.
a) Ms. Good had gone through training on how to block, impede, and/or otherwise interfere with ICE operations.
b) Her partner egged her on to interfere with ICE operations so she could video it (which she did).
c) Ms. Good and her partner had both been egged on by the repeated anti-ICE comments of Minnesota governor Tim Walz, Minneapolis mayor Jacob Frey, and other anti-immigration-enforcement voices.
d) Because both Governor Walz and Mayor Frey had stood down the police during the 2020 George Floyd riots and let the rioters go hog wild with no consequences, Ms. Good and her partner thought they could do whatever they wanted and there would be no consequences.
e) As a result, Ms. Good thought she was free to disobey the commands of an armed federal agent and flee the scene.
2. No understanding of "dynamic environments" and "life-threatening situations."
I've watched all known videos multiple times. There are multiple elements that are either not understood or willfully ignored.
a) Icy conditions. The road surface was very slick; the videos clearly show both Officer Ross and Ms. Good's SUV slipping and sliding on the surface before and after shots were fired.
b) Those icy conditions led to miscalculations by both Officer Ross and Ms. Good that contributed to her death.
-- Ms. Good's vehicle was running when she disobeyed the command to get out of her vehicle and instead put it in Reverse.
-- At that point, Officer Ross moved from the right side of the SUV to the front. He also drew his weapon to make it clear she needed to stop.
-- At essentially this same moment, Ms. Good put her SUV into Drive and started forward. Because the road was icy, her engine revved up as the tires slipped.
-- Because the road was icy, Officer Ross could not quickly get out of the way. Now he was faced with a 5,000-pound weapon coming at him from ~5 feet away, so he fired.
-- Lots of comments been made about her wheels being turned away from Officer Ross, but this is irrelevant for two reasons:
i) the wheels were not in his sight line given his position; and
ii) he heard a revving engine that in the moment could not be deciphered (caused by inadvertent spinning or deliberate acceleration toward him?) -- so he fired one round through the windshield.
-- Ms. Good's SUV did in fact hit Officer Ross hard enough to cause death or serious bodily harm -- except that it didn't because, again, as some videos clearly show, on impact his feet slipped on the ice so he slid clear of the SUV instead of either absorbing its force or being run over.
-- At some point during that moment, he fired one or two more rounds (the possible third round sounds different than the first two and may actually have been the SUV making contact with some part of Officer Ross' gear). It is unknown if the second and/or possible third round hit Ms. Good, but the position of the windshield hole and Officer Ross' position when he fired that shot make it likely that the first shot was incapacitating and probably mortal. Given that he fired the other round(s) as he was being hit, the other round(s) may have been impact-triggered, not deliberately fired.
-- Ms. Good's SUV then rolled away, accelerating, and crashed into a parked car. Most likely, she was either already dead or did not consciously step further on the accelerator.
The other part of this is legal. It is well-established at all levels of law enforcement that officers may use deadly force to protect themselves and others from someone driving a vehicle in a way that threatens their lives or that of others. Thus Officer Ross was in fact within his legal rights to defend himself with deadly force from a threat to his life.
3. No awareness that "Monday Morning Quarterbacking" is a pejorative term for a reason.
The loudest voices sounding off on Ms. Good's death display zero awareness of split-second decisionmaking in a dynamic and potentially lethal environment, which this was.
First, from the moment one agent told Ms. Good to get out of the car until the collision and shots are fired was less than 3 seconds; from the moment she initiated her movement until the collision and fired shots? LESS THAN 2 SECONDS.
Think about that:
-- Officer Ross had less than 2 seconds to observe, orient, decide, and act in a life-threatening situation that literally came out of nowhere.
-- At the same time, Ms. Good was oblivious to how her actions turned a mostly cheerful, casual moment into a life-or-death situation. Check out THIS video, which is the bodycam of Officer Ross:
https://t.co/c5O6BOyJxF
You will see that, while Ms. Good's partner was condescending, obnoxious, and verbally combative, Ms. Good was polite and even friendly to Officer Ross as he passed by her side of the SUV. You will also see the 3-second/2-second timeframe from his perspective, and how little time he had to deal with a 5,000-pound weapon coming straight at him... and how unexpected it was given Ms. Good's friendly and non-combative behavior literally seconds before.
Mix all of these elements together and you have a recipe for disaster, tragedy, and wholly unnecessary loss of life because split-second decisionmaking in a dynamic and potentially lethal environment regularly results in decisions that, in hindsight and upon reflection, could have been better.
CONCLUSIONS
In this case, both Ms. Good and Officer Ross made decisions that, in hindsight and upon reflection, could have been better. Leaving aside for the moment the decision to fuck with ICE in the first place, let's start with the decisions Ms. Good and Officer Ross made after she was ordered to get out of her vehicle.
1. Ms. Good should have either complied with the order to get out of her vehicle or, at minimum, turned off the engine.
That she did not represents a training failure; whoever trained her on how to interfere with ICE clearly had no clue about how the rules of engagement change instantly when a moving vehicle becomes part of the equation.
Because Ms. Good was not briefed on this, she was oblivious to the fact that her friendly, non-combative behavior meant nothing the instant she put her SUV in gear and stepped on the gas.
Note: In situations such as this, it does not matter whether or not the ICE agent had the legal right to order her out of her vehicle; when guys with guns tell you to do something, you best obey them and sort out the legalities later.
Again, this is a training failure; she was obviously not advised by her "trainers" that when you disobey a command from law enforcement, you instantly escalate the situation and "prepare the battlespace" for a bad outcome.
2. Officer Ross should have either stayed on the passenger side of the vehicle or positioned himself much farther away from its front end.
He knew the street was icy and mobility/reaction-limiting, and he knew her engine was running; both factors made it far riskier for him to move in front of the vehicle at a distance of 5-6 feet. This too is either a training failure or a learning failure:
Unlike in the movies, where people point guns at people from 1-3 feet away, you keep your distance when you have a firearm because you don't need to be close. Being "movie close" means the person you're pointing your gun at has a chance to take it from you; in this case, being movie close meant Officer Ross couldn't get out of the way when Ms. Good started forward.
3. Ms. Good and Officer Ross should have put themselves in the other's shoes.
a) Ms. Good was clearly oblivious to the lethal threat she created the moment she disobeyed the order to get out of the car and started moving. Given only what I see in the Facebook video, I am sure that, had she lived, she would have been horrified that she hit Officer Ross. I am equally sure that she had no intent to hurt anyone; she just wanted to leave -- and in focusing on getting away she didn't even think about the fact that she turned herself into a lethal threat for Officer Ross and the other ICE agents around her.
b) Officer Ross seemed to be similarly oblivious to the fact that Ms. Good could become a lethal threat if she decided to put her vehicle in gear and step on the gas. He had a "duty of care" as the armed, better-trained, and far more experienced party to make sure the situation didn't escalate to the point that lethal force was necessary and he failed to do his duty.
BOTTOM LINE There is a saying in aviation that there are 5 to 6 causal links that lead to almost all fatalities -- and that by removing any single link from that causal chain, the fatality would have been prevented.
Same case here. Let's look at the chain (again, setting aside the decision to fuck with ICE in the first place).
Link 1: The interfere-with-ICE training that did not include a briefing on how law enforcement officers react to: a) disobeying their orders; and b) putting them at potential risk when you abruptly move your motor vehicle.
Link 2: Ms. Good's resulting lack of situational awareness regarding the effect of her disobedience on the armed men around her.
Link 3: Ms. Good's resulting lack of situational awareness regarding the effect of her abrupt motor vehicle handling on the armed men around her.
Link 4: Officer Ross' lack of situational awareness regarding the icy road and its effect on his mobility.
Link 5: Officer Ross' lack of situational awareness regarding Ms. Good's obliviousness to the lethal threat she represented by just sitting in her vehicle with the motor running, much less abruptly putting it in gear and stepping on the gas.
Link 6: Officer Ross' disregard of Firearm Employment 101 -- keep your distance from any potential threat. Try it yourself: Remove any one of the above links from the causal chain and you'll see how, by removing any one of them, the probability that Ms. Good would still be above room temperature increases exponentially.
Anyway, it is sad Ms. Good got killed, both for her personally, for her son, and for the country at large, but shit happens when you're stirring shit -- especially when you don't understand the potential consequences of your shit stirring.
As I often say, the reason I'm still above room temperature after a lifetime of doing extreme sports is that I (almost) always followed these two operating principles:
1. Don't push it when doing it at all is pushing it.
2. Think instead of laugh when you hear "what could possibly go wrong?"
Neither Ms. Good nor Officer Ross put those principles front and center. Ms. Good paid for that omission with her life. Officer Ross is going to pay for that omission for the rest of his life, too. Finally, there's more to this story regarding the roles and responsibilities of those who created the conditions that led to Ms. Good's death, but that's outside the scope of this discussion. A couple of things I will say, though:
1. Ms. Good's actions were NOT "domestic terrorism." They were clueless in regard to the effect her actions had on law enforcement, and that cluelessness resulted in her death, but it's clear she was trying to get away, not run Officer Ross over.
2. Officer Ross' actions were NOT "murder." He was legally justified in defending himself from what became a deadly threat in less than 2 seconds.
3. Providing "training" on how to protest/interfere with ICE operations is fine, but the anti-ICE "trainers" are close to criminally negligent for not schooling Ms. Good and other activists on the dangers of:
a) disobeying Law Enforcement Officer (LEO) commands; and/or
b) stepping on the gas when they're near your vehicle.
As any instructor of extreme sports or other dangerous activities knows, the very first thing you teach your students is how to minimize the chances of killing themselves and you do that by first making sure they know what the risks are.
In this case, it is as clear as Ms. Good's non-evil intent that she had absolutely no idea of the jeopardy in which she placed herself by:
a) ignoring an LEO command; and then
b) putting her vehicle in gear and stepping on the gas while surrounded by LEOs.
That is a monumental failure of the anti-ICE training and, going forward, that training needs to include a module on the RULES OF ENGAGEMENT as they relate to:
-- disobeying LEO commands
-- stepping on the gas when there are LEO around your vehicle
-- moving vehicles and LEO use of deadly force related thereto
My recommendation here is that the anti-ICE trainers meet with both ICE and/or local LEO to make sure everyone's on the same page re the above three points so that the chances of another such tragedy are minimized.
Similarly, I recommend remedial training for all ICE agents re the use of force when motor vehicles are involved; as the anti-ICE operations and Officer Ross' mistakes on this score show. ICE agents need to be crystal clear on the rules of engagement when operating in such a dynamic environment.
In conclusion, I'll end this the way I started it: We all need to turn down the temperature re the shooting death of Renee Good by ICE officer Jon Ross. What happened was a tragedy, not a crime, and neither Ms. Good nor Officer Ross should be savaged for their parts in it.
@megynkelly When Candace is attacking a widow and the wife of Charlie kirk and the mother of his children , who also happens to be your friend , you just sit idly by and allow it to happen, Why don't you call her out Megan, Is one of your friends more important than the other? Shame on you.