Perhaps my favorite part of the 1958 onion futures debate is when proponents of the ban said "Don't worry, it's not a precedent," and then other members of Congress *immediately* treated it as a precedent to ban other things.
This raises significant First Amendment concerns. SCOTUS made clear government cannot purge its ranks of members of the opposition party unless political affiliation is relevant to the job. Plus, under fed law, personnel decisions on career State employees must be “merit” based.
We sent a letter urging South Florida State College to reinstate Professor Vinita Prabhakar, who was terminated after she assigned an award-winning short story in her Freshman English II course.
Prabhakar had used Ottessa Moshfegh’s “Bettering Myself” for nearly a decade to teach narrative voice and characterization. After one student expressed discomfort, College President Fred Hawkins overrode the support of Prabhakar’s department chair, dean, and vice president and ordered her to stop teaching the story. She was then fired.
Our letter calls this out as a violation of the college's First Amendment obligations and its own policies. It concludes: "These types of egregious actions break the college’s own stated commitment to academic freedom and send a chilling message to other members of the faculty who must discuss difficult and controversial material as part of their teaching duties.”
Full letter here: https://t.co/99r5XhTL9A
Very funny that a lot of folks spent weeks arguing that the professoriate isn’t a political monoculture only for the AAUP to say “yeah so we are doing this endorsement because our members are super liberal and we gotta represent their super liberal views which are a monoculture.”
Here's why the attacks on the Court from the right matter. Because (1) the right's attacks are dumb, (2) the DSA/progressive wing hates the Court BECAUSE it's defending the Constitution, and (3) the right is feeding the DSA/progressive narrative that the Court needs fixing. Stop giving your opponents talking points. Especially when you're not even right. https://t.co/m556zEMBwn
New episode of Academic Freedom Podcast out. Conversation with lead attorney from @TheFIREorg who argued the Stop WOKE Act case at the 11th circuit
On the Pernell Decision: Stopping the Stop WOKE Act https://t.co/byDHaTmEuv
NEW PODCAST out now on the Pernell decision: Keith Whittington @kewhittington is joined by Greg Greubel, a senior attorney at @TheFIREorg and one of the lead attorneys who argued against Florida’s Stop W.O.K.E. Act. The 11th Circuit just handed down an opinion in that case, Pernell v. Florida Board of Governors, one of the most consequential academic freedom cases of recent years. They discuss the case, the constitutional doctrine relating to academic freedom, and the implications of the opinion for the future. https://t.co/zg02BpTA5p
If all academic work is 'political,' then it is--by definition--at the mercy of politicians. Astonishing that they can't grasp this.
https://t.co/yTSKrPSrcj
But hard to uphold w/o gutting any meaningful academic freedom protections. And even striking down is going to leave space for a policy response, which is often true of judicial review 16/16
After a long wait, circuit court rejects Florida’s defense of barring profs at public universities from espousing disfavored ideas in the classroom 1/
https://t.co/VcE27XUC2k
This dissent isn’t only way to do it but does indicate that this case is on the frontier of existing law & not hard to see how courts could talk themselves into upholding. 15/