@knowles204@SirNotTomFarmer@crimlawuk Yes, I understand what the policy says. The original point in this thread was that Brand, like any other prisoner, is entitled to claim his innocence in public. There are controls - of course - but no blanket ban, as some have claimed. I am well aware of the rules...
@knowles204@SirNotTomFarmer@crimlawuk I agree, he does. I am not in any way trying to defend his behaviour. I dealt with plenty of people like him when I was a Governor. But the point is that the rules are not as simple and clear cut as some would like to claim
@knowles204@SirNotTomFarmer@crimlawuk That depends entirely on whether professing innocence counts as a serious representation about his conviction. That is certainly open to interpretation, at the very least
@SirNotTomFarmer@crimlawuk I am not sure that there is a significant difference between 6 million people watching a youtube video and 10 million (or whatever) watching a broadcast statement on TV news. But I agree that no prisoner should benefit financially from making such a statement
@SirNotTomFarmer@crimlawuk If protesting your innocence is enough to cause distress to a prisoner's victims, it makes a nonsense of the rule that allows public statements on guilt.
@SirNotTomFarmer@crimlawuk Your guess is as good as mine. I am only speculating, but possibly because Brand dictated his statement over the phone, but I don't know for certain
@SirNotTomFarmer@crimlawuk Like any other prisoner, he is entitled to maintain his innocence publicly. He is entitled, like any other prisoner, to write letters for publication broadcast or posting on the internet that make serious representations about his sentence or conviction
@katepoyser@UKHarvey@JayStill4 Read 2.1: "Prisoners requesting access to the media should be advised that in most cases letters will be the only appropriate form of contact, and is the only means of communication that does not need the permission of the Governor."
@smith_john37671@BenGunnEx Anyway, I can't remember now what we were disagreeing about. Suffice to say that HMPPS will undertake some kind of investigation, which will probably amount to a pile of not very much, but will be necessary for political reasons...
@smith_john37671@BenGunnEx That's only partly right. You are right that the Rules only allow communication "with the leave" of the S of S. But the basis on which the S of S exercises that discretion is through HMPPS instructions.
@katepoyser@UKHarvey@JayStill4 Of course. But there is no requirement for permission to write letters intended for publication, broadcast or posting on the internet
@raphaeldogg I hate to break it to you, but lots of people who arenβt elected attend Cabinet meetings. Civil servants, the CDS, in fact anyone from whom the Cabinet might want expert advice.