@iamdshagz This is better news than you know. You will be shocked how much money you spend on diapers. If you invest the savings now you’ll probably have enough for one year of college tuition in 18 years.
Here's an interesting case--a trademark plaintiff sued, won, but the court refused to award damages, defendant's profits, or an injunction.
Why? The plaintiff failed to establish a sufficient connection between the infringement and its alleged financial losses. And the circumstances no longer warranted injunctive relief.
Proving infringement is only half the battle.
Clients being charged hourly by their lawyers will eventually demand that their bills reflect the savings generated by AI. It's already starting to happen.
I think it will hit biglaw the hardest.
I know an associate in Biglaw who is a top 5 power user of AI at his firm. He’s not just making AI slop, he checks everything that the AI produces and verifies the all citations with actual sources, even though AI gets it correct most of the time these days.
Recently he’s been told by his partner that, he’s “over confident”, that he’s working too fast and that he needs to check his work more, even though the partner could not pick out substantive issues in his drafts.
I told him it’s likely code for: you’re running up a bunch of tokens and costing the firm while affecting my top line since I could normally bill the client twice for this work.
As such, he is now forced to take longer on his work with little substantive impact on the work product while the client gets his bills multiplied.
That’s probably part of the reason why despite the billions that have been invested in legal AI for Biglaw, there is barely any productivity increase and clients don’t see their bills go down by one cent.
@RobertFreundLaw I have a Claude Team account for work and a free account for personal. The Team account is mostly fantastic. For fun I switched to free and I was shocked at how bad it was.
When something that used to take 10 hours now takes 1 hour, and you charge by the hour, AI will not bring additional profit unless you make up for it by 10x volume of cases, which isn’t plausible.
Flat fees. Subscriptions. That’s the way lawyers used to charge prior to 50 years ago. That is the model we should return to.
The first federal appellate court to address fair use in AI training has sided with the copyright owner.
The Third Circuit affirmed Thomson Reuters’ copyright victory against ROSS Intelligence, holding that ROSS’s use of Westlaw headnotes to train its AI-powered legal research tool was not fair use.
The court found ROSS’s use “minimally transformative, at best.” ROSS used the headnotes to build a commercial legal research platform that directly competed with Westlaw.
But the court expressly distinguished generative AI.
It noted that generative AI models can “generate original responses,” while ROSS’s system could not generate original expression. And unlike the generative AI cases, ROSS trained its system specifically to create a commercial substitute for Westlaw.
The court also found market harm because ROSS’s unauthorized use deprived Thomson Reuters of the opportunity to license its headnotes as AI training data.
So the first appellate decision on AI training is a significant win for copyright owners, but the Third Circuit went out of its way to explain why the generative AI cases may be different.
@NerdJey The earlier you get good legal advice, the better.
But bad legal advice is WAY more expensive than no legal advice.
Lots of law firms have negative incentives. They want you to be billed more.
The long-running lawsuit between YugaLabs and Ryder Ripps/Jeremy Cahen is finally (almost) at an end. The parties notified the court that they settled, and the court just needs to enter the order.
Unclear if there were monetary terms, but Ryder and Jeremy agreed to an injunction:
- Prohibited from using the BAYC marks in any way
- Yuga retains control of rr/bayc smart contract, domain, and other related collateral
- Must transfer to Yuga any BAYC and rr/BAYC NFTs still in their possession