Our Wisconsin museum has purchased 1000 True Fans #479 on Verse from Leander Herzog @lennyjpg Wonderful project from August 2023 that we look forward to sharing with visitors. You can play with it here: https://t.co/ScW8fQ5NoM
SITUATION UPDATED: The Riemann Hypothesis proof has passed the independent kernel check. MIT's Andrew Sutherland exported Alpöge and Claude's full proof and ran it through separately written kernels. nanoda (Rust) accepted it in about 28 minutes. con-leche accepted all 1.47 million declarations and confirmed the five theorems, including RH itself, match Mathlib-only statements. lean4lean passed all 175,187 modules, and Lean's own kernel replay passed with zero rejections. A Lean bug is now essentially ruled out, since every checker would have to share it. Two slower checks are still running, and nothing has failed. What's left is the human part: no readable proof exists yet, and the Clay prize needs publication plus two years of review. The Riemann Hypothesis is proven, but not yet understood.
Like most mathematicians, I believed the Riemann Hypothesis to be completely out of reach at present (even with the best AI tools), because I expected it to require substantial theory-building, probably in arithmetic geometry. The kind of new theory-building that fills entire books, and that AI isn't so good at yet.
Mathematicians have a notion of how deep a problem is. A sufficiently deep problem is generally intractable until enough of the theory is in place. If difficult problems are like valuable mineral reserves buried miles underground, you first need to build the infrastructure to reach them.
What Levent's proof seems to have done instead is something completely different. It takes an incredibly complicated tour through the infrastructure built for a hundred other mineral reserves, situated far from the destination, and somehow create a wormhole to the original destination.
This is not theory-building in the usual sense. It is something much weirder and more alien. The best human mathematicians know how to build theory, painstakingly, to reach a goal. But no human brain, on its own, is capable of creating a wormhole that requires a 25,000 page long tour through existing infrastructure with no obvious or realistic connection to the goal. But huge credit to Levent here: I think no current AI, on its own, is capable of this either.
I had never worked on or thought too much about the Riemann Hypothesis: it seemed very far removed from my own area of number theory.
But the astonishing thing about Levent's claimed proof of RH (which I think has a very good chance of being correct) is that it uses a huge number of precisely the things that are central to my own corner of number theory:
- Theta functions and other automorphic forms on unitary groups
- Gan–Gross–Prasad period formulas
- Relative trace formulas
Etc., etc.
A problem that I had always assumed would require new theories in arithmetic geometry may instead turn out to be tractable through an inhuman chain of existing (deep) results in higher-rank automorphic forms (and a lot else).
@tshddx@gerardsans@jessesingal Is it the AIs fault that humans are too limited to understand it? Do we expect cats to understand calculus? Why should we expect to understand what a greater intelligence does?
Like most mathematicians, I believed the Riemann Hypothesis to be completely out of reach at present (even with the best AI tools), because I expected it to require substantial theory-building, probably in arithmetic geometry. The kind of new theory-building that fills entire books, and that AI isn't so good at yet.
Mathematicians have a notion of how deep a problem is. A sufficiently deep problem is generally intractable until enough of the theory is in place. If difficult problems are like valuable mineral reserves buried miles underground, you first need to build the infrastructure to reach them.
What Levent's proof seems to have done instead is something completely different. It takes an incredibly complicated tour through the infrastructure built for a hundred other mineral reserves, situated far from the destination, and somehow create a wormhole to the original destination.
This is not theory-building in the usual sense. It is something much weirder and more alien. The best human mathematicians know how to build theory, painstakingly, to reach a goal. But no human brain, on its own, is capable of creating a wormhole that requires a 25,000 page long tour through existing infrastructure with no obvious or realistic connection to the goal. But huge credit to Levent here: I think no current AI, on its own, is capable of this either.
I had never worked on or thought too much about the Riemann Hypothesis: it seemed very far removed from my own area of number theory.
But the astonishing thing about Levent's claimed proof of RH (which I think has a very good chance of being correct) is that it uses a huge number of precisely the things that are central to my own corner of number theory:
- Theta functions and other automorphic forms on unitary groups
- Gan–Gross–Prasad period formulas
- Relative trace formulas
Etc., etc.
A problem that I had always assumed would require new theories in arithmetic geometry may instead turn out to be tractable through an inhuman chain of existing (deep) results in higher-rank automorphic forms (and a lot else).
Agree. Starting to see lots of different digital art installations popping up in many places. Feels like the beginning of a shift towards digital being a first class art collection focus.
The onchain digital art market has so far been inextricably connected to crypto markets.
My sense is that this is changing.
There are currently multiple major exhibitions of digital art happening at the most important traditional art institutions in the world.
At the same time, all of the major art fairs are expanding their focus on artists working with digital tools and blockchains.
The net effect of this is that brand new audiences are being exposed to these artists for the first time.
This will ultimately lead to a much more robust and diverse collector base for these artworks and artists.
Seeing lots of spiraling because AI is better than us at math (and many other things to come). Same thing happened when steam engines became faster and stronger than humans. Time to embrace reality and use the new tools to advance what we can achieve. No need to spiral.
@gerardsans@jessesingal If a computer beats you every time in chess, but you can’t understand why it makes the moves it does (and no human can anymore), does that diminish the fact that it’s going to win every time? Does that mean that it’s wins are not historical when it crushes “grandmasters”?
@ModelJag@seanrcallaghan@sciam I still have fun and find meaning playing chess. But I am not upset that computers are way better at chess than any human can ever be. Same for math, physics, or programming. It turns out that human brains are pretty limited in many ways. That’s ok.
@djc2272@seanrcallaghan@sciam Missing the forest for the trees. They don’t need to be identical at the “cellular” level to have similar emergent properties. But you must know this.
@seanrcallaghan@sciam What’s the difference between a digital computer that runs a neural net and a protein and fat based computer that runs a neural net?