"We must act now," but who is "we"? My new @NoemaMag piece: tech leaders keep saying the public must have a voice in AI's future, then leave the public out of the room. Here's an actual plan: a 3-tier global consultation, starting now, using the AI platforms that already reach a billion people. https://t.co/gl65FqXySB
Interested in democratic reform, lottocracy, citizens’ assemblies, sortition, or feeling optimistic about politics for a minute?
If so, I highly recommend the new documentary, Goodbye Politicians, Hello Democracy. Great for teaching, too. Free to watch: https://t.co/GqAAvBvfw0
@jskdn Not yet, we have an internal memo but it's not public I think. All of this will come out in a few months along with academic publications on the assembly.
@jskdn We had an Stakeholders and Expert Subcommittee co-chaired by Cynthia Farrar and Oliver Hart working with the Connecticut Conference on Municipalities folks to come up with a list of experts and docs.
And last half of the final plenary was devoted to self-governance and voting on 5 motions. This one below failed by a few votes after an interesting back and forth weighing consideration for minorities, whether or not consensus is the point, and efficiency of decision-making ["CGC" stands for Citizen Governance Committee]
I was informed that 97 citizens made it today (remember 103 were expected the day before our first session). The incomparable Sulekha Kishore from @MIT and our AI-person on the Assembly just presented the public input we got since May through both online platforms (via @Make_org_Global and Ideas for Change (formerly https://t.co/HIk8RfA9rV).
@MayorElicker tackling another tough equity question in the breakout room on tax exemptions. 52% of the property in New Haven is tax-exempt. Who is actually paying to support the work of these non-profits, including @Yale ?
Excited for the third session of our Connecticut Citizens' Assembly on Property Taxes, a virtual 4-hour session that started off this morning at 9am with happy greetings from the 100 to each other and the team, warnings about pets and kids wandering on screen, and jokes about the cheap music background of our Zoom meeting. The mood is both playful and determined. After the 7-strong Citizen Governance Committee gave an account of the decisions they made on behalf of the larger group last time, we move on to a presentation on fiscal guardrails and state investment controls.
@bakkermichiel Congratulations @bakkermichiel ! Your work on the Habermas Machine and deliberative AI has been foundational. Excited for Europe to be able to poach such talent.
@MaxKronerDale@NoemaMag@B_I_Team Thank you @MaxKronerDale, and congrats on your pioneering work on the Community Forums. All of the pieces of the process I put forward in that piece have already been tried/piloted at scale. We just need will and money to make it happen.
"We must act now," but who is "we"? My new @NoemaMag piece: tech leaders keep saying the public must have a voice in AI's future, then leave the public out of the room. Here's an actual plan: a 3-tier global consultation, starting now, using the AI platforms that already reach a billion people. https://t.co/gl65FqXySB
Helene Landemore articulates an issue that I see as both urgent and imperative: AI decision-making frameworks desperately need public input to be durable or legitimate. She ends with a direct call to action for frontier AI lab leaders. I agree that labs need to be the first movers here, and we have the capacity to make significant, even if imperfect, moves right now in this direction.
Thanks @bakkermichiel! As I mention in the essay, tier 1 grew directly out of the idea you raised at the Superintelligence conference in March. Your point about institutional independence and lab entrenchment is exactly the next thing to work out. I would be keen to explore these questions with you, this group, and anyone willing to contribute.
An ambitious proposal (but one that we could make real progress on) for giving the public a say in how we govern AI. From one of my favorite political scientists @landemore!
Building on work from @saffronhuang@divyasiddarth@ThankYourNiceAI@collect_intel@Werdnamai@audreyt and many others.
Lots of open questions still around institutional independence, checks and balances, including the non-western ai ecosystem, and how to avoid entrenching the leading labs.
“The enormous question of what AI is for cannot be answered in Washington or Beijing alone. On issues of this scale & importance, we owe people a say in what they're being both protected from & disrupted for.”
—@landemore https://t.co/zKANPcxU7a
Je critique rarement mon pays d'adoption❤️🇫🇷 mais là, en effet ! Pour utiliser les transports dans d'autres villes européennes, il suffit de "swipe in/swipe out" avec sa carte de crédit en une seconde
A Paris, en revanche, quand on n'a pas le passe navigo mensuel, j'ai rarement vu quelque chose d'aussi impénétrable - et je parle en tant que quelqu'un qui a vécu 44 ans dans la ville et qui connait toutes les lignes du métro par coeur 🤡
Tickets, tarifs et forfaits différents pour bus, tram et métro, appli hermétique ! Cauchemar ! Et je ne parle même pas des queues de 20 minutes devant les automates dans les gares et aéroports grrrr
C'est en effet 𝐭𝐨𝐭𝐚𝐥𝐞𝐦𝐞𝐧𝐭 𝑡𝑜𝑢𝑟𝑖𝑠𝑡-𝑢𝑛𝑓𝑟𝑖𝑒𝑛𝑑𝑙𝑦
@vpecresse@IDFmobilites@transportsidf