Catholic Claremonster PhD, mother of five. Raising beef, pork, poultry, veg and flowers on our ranch. My husband runs a USA manufacturing co and we build houses
The reason Christmas and holidays felt so special as a child was because of the effort adults, like parents, grandparents, teachers, put into making it festive. Then you grow up, and you realize it is now up to you to create intentionality and find your own ways to mark the seasons and celebrate milestones. It is your responsibility and also your freedom. And then you realize a lot of things about adulthood are this way. So much of what makes life magical is something someone once lovingly cultivated
@nealjclark1 Yes. And also, living near family is mostly for the kids, and to ease the trouble of raising them, and give them a culture and clan to belong to. Almost nothing in adult life is for the direct and obvious benefit of the adults. You're an adult. You should be a finished product.
"This choice to attend the TLM based on personal preferences such as demographic similarity or aesthetics reveals a fundamentally Protestant approach to religion. The Catholic Church traditionally operated on the geographical parish system, perhaps with national parishes based on language for immigrants. Protestants, particularly in the automobile era, have been more likely to choose churches based on affinity for the pastor or congregants, or stylistic preferences such as music."
I was a Protestant until I was 20 and TLM communities always reminded me of the Protestant churches of my youth that would follow personalities or groups around, then periodically there would be some big dust-up, and groups would break off. The main difference being that disaffected TLM attendees can't go start their own churches post-split like the Protestants often do. Maybe the proliferation of online or social media Rad Trads is a version of this; they can't start their own parish in town like the Protestants but they can attract an online following or "church" to their particular teachings.
One thing left out of this review, and maybe the book, too, is the huge role Catholic colleges have played in the incubation and development of enthusiasm for traditional liturgy among young Catholics. Many of the nation's best Catholic Liberal Arts colleges are near or are culturally influenced by these priestly societies. Notre Dame and the Land O' Lakes statement in 1967 played a big role in the Catholic higher education reaction to Vatican II.
This is the topic of my soon-to-be-completed dissertation. That so American desire to cram all of life's joys into the home, and its corollary: suspicion of civilization. The end of public life and public leisure. What others have called the move from front porch (social, facing the world) to back patio (secluded, private). The television. The smartphone. The home bar, home office, home gym, backyard pool, over the bar, office, gym, and neighborhood pool. Religious and club disaffiliation. Declines in number of friendships, events hosted and attended. Doordash. The suburbs. The family compound. Revulsion over townhomes and shared walls. Owning Land™️. FIRE. Fear of the public realm: first the threat of nuclear war, then crime. All the way back to the origins, ideas behind, and spirit of the country. The frontier. Walden. Huck Finn. On the Road. Into the Wild. The state of nature in Hobbes and Locke. The moral transition from Duties to Rights
I didn't say you'd want the honor of Joe Workingman. But you won't be able to find happiness without the friendship and honor of good men that you respect, and that's the piece of this whole life calculation you're missing.
You will also have to spend the majority of your time convincing your children of your life philosophy. That will be exhausting. There is no corner of the earth remote enough to remove the haves from your have not. I have very close friends who went this direction and decided to be Bohemians. Decided work wasn't for them, that everyone else was just infected with avarice and capitalistic greed and they were so excited in their 20s that they had cracked the code and would live differently.
It works until the first kid is about ten. Then it starts to fall apart. They did the back to the land thing, only taking "meaningful" jobs worth doing in themselves, all of it.
The saddest thing is my friend who thought he was so clever in deciding money was something he needn't concern himself with now spends all his time thinking about money.
He's one of those people who always knows just how much others seem to have. Deciding capitalism is for fools is no way to free yourself from the burden of thinking about money, I don't think. It's a laudable impulse but personally I have never seen it actually work. It's because we are social animals, I think. And because our kids have to marry someone.
This is real. Everyone should own sheep or at least deal with them to understand what the Bible is talking about. It's actually amazing how unlike dogs, cats, horses, birds, and just about every other animal sheep are. There is a reason Christ is the shepherd.
@policywishes Only just this year my mom demanded to do a full Thanksgiving and is excited about hosting. She was sort of all cared-out for a long time after my dad's decline. It's nice to see her come back and be ready to do things for people and energetic. It's nice for the grandkids too.
A documentary more than a skit for my family, right down to the sons-in-law caring for the ailing parent because they married the sisters. My dear husband and BIL, lifting my dad to and from the bathroom and helping to change him. . .
I will say that since my dad died in 2021, I've had not one bad dream, one bad thought, one regret whatsoever about his passing. We gave him a good and even happy death, in his own home, surrounded by people who made sure he was not abused or neglected. He was a difficult person and my brothers had their reasons for staying away. Lots of times men work very hard to alienate the other men in their lives when they decline. But of course are happy to have the women or unrelated men do the care work.
The upside to doing your duty is a peace about the whole affair. My mom spent years of her life being the primary caretaker, and my sister and I and our husbands and a few hired in-home nurses helped a lot at the very end.
It is very much the case that your life takes a "before and after" quality after you go through something like that. My mom is more herself now, five years later, but it took her a long time to come back. All of us went through the fog of carrying that heavy, sad burden. It changes you.
@MatteButShiny None at all. They both married really lovely women. My dad worked very hard to alienate my brothers. But they will get their care work in with their wives' parents so I think it's all a wash.
@CathyReisenwitz Because waking up with fleas is preferable to waking up with abortionists.
If feminists didn't insist on abortion as essential dogma, this wouldn't happen.
Most people do not want to start their own companies and work for themselves. Aside from the fear/investment/risk/ungodly hours, self-employment sooner or later = business management, whatever the product. The quickest way out of doing something you love is to start a business. You'll just be managing other people doing the thing you love, hiring and firing, and dealing with disability/workers' comp 24/7
Years ago, a friend of mine was always saying he hated his job and wanted to start his own company. I spent a lot of time talking through his ideas and connecting him with opportunities. He didn't take any of them. Learned a lesson. Some people don't actually want it.