When people are anxious about MNE, it's normally about (1) the Chinese loan (2) MNE is very small (3) Balkans/Russia issues. But while these concerns are not entirely baseless, the real red sign is something else. First, why ignore (1)-(3)? 2/n
Većinski izborni sistem, ako se kao izborne jedinice uzmu opštine ili nove izborne jedinice po jednakom broju stanovništva, će dovesti opet do istog rezultata kao i proporcionalni sistem - naprosto većina ljudi je nedovoljna zainteresovana da se bavi pojedničanim kandidatima, i kandidati velikih stranaka automatski imaju prednost, što vidimo u Vojvodini, kao i po rezultatima lokalnih izbora.
Jedini način da se ovo donekle promeni je da izborne jedinice imaju velika ovlašćenja, ali to je nemoguće bez velike decentralizacije zemlje, što bi povlačilo i veliku fiskalnu redistribuciju iz produktivnih ka neproduktivnim krajevima (jer su ovlašćenja bez obezbedjenih sredstava samo prazna priča).
Ako se ostane pri novim izbornim jedinicama sa jednakim brojem stanovništa, korist većinskog izbornog sistema bi se onda ogledala tek u nešto boljoj kadrovskoj politici stranaka, jer bi velike stranke nešto više nego sada pazile ko su joj kandidati na "lokalu", s tim što i sada imaju donekle slični podsticaj zbog lokalnih izbora.
I think it's fair to say his project is centered on securing Israel's safety and Israel's good repute in the world (the way he understands it of course). That being the nerve, we get at the same time:
1. Vindication of national life as such - Conservatism: A Rediscovery, The Virtue of Nationalism
2. Vindication of the Hebrew faith in the secular age - The Philosophy of Hebrew Scripture, and all the other works
3. NatCon - drawing bridges towards the American postliberals, as they are practically the only political option you have if you want to deal, broadly speaking, harshly with the Palestinian question and also want 1-2 above (if only the former is your goal, you for the neoncons obviosly)
The last point was obviously always going to backfire, as the God of the Old Testament isn't the only jealous God out there. And having recently finished the Philosophy of Hebrew Scripture, and as the whole thing reads as a long response to Strauss, I am beginning to think that what misled him in part to pursue the point 3, is this, entirely silly, Straussian idea that you can be subtle in politics in a demotic age.
Da, slažem se. Pitanje je da li se rezultati mogu ekstrapolirati od ovih kandidata čiji su politički stavovi poznati u javnosti na sve ostale kandidate sa liste (koji su, dakle, nevidljivi); dakle da li su reprezentativan uzorak ili postoji neki bias, i to tako da su kandidati levog centra, za razliku od desnog centra, imali više izjava u javnosti. Moja je pretpostavka da su levica i desnica jednako ostrašćeni, da je stoga uzorak reprezentativan i da je lista u celini uzev levi centar.
Zanimljiva je klasifikacija Studentske liste prema top 40 kandidata (Claude):
# Name Identification Placement
-- ----------------------- ------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------
1 Ilija Srdanović Cardiologist, Novi Sad Medical Faculty Not placeable
2 Katarina Stanković — Unidentified
3 Željko Hubač Dramaturg, writer; founder-signatory Centre
4 Aleksandar Cvetković — Unidentified
5 Katarina Šćepanović Gymnasium teacher, union activist; founder-signatory Centre-left
6 Adem Mavrić Political scientist, Novi Pazar Centre
7 Miloš Jevtić — Unidentified
8 Tihomir Stanić Actor Centre
9 Tatjana Paunović English professor, union president, Niš Centre-left
10 Milina Marić Pharmacist, Apoteka Beograd labour campaigner Centre-left
11 Vesna Srećković — Unidentified
12 Aleksandar N. Nešković Cardiologist, Belgrade Medical Faculty; strike leader Not placeable
13 Marija Bjelobrk Cardiologist, IKVB Vojvodina (probable) No record
14 Lidija Dimitrijević — Unidentified
15 Slobodan Vukosavić Electrical engineer, SANU energy committee Not placeable (technocrat)
16 Marija Vulović "Professor" per rally, otherwise unclear Unidentified
17 Zlatko Kokanović Ne damo Jadar activist Not placeable (eco-populist)
18 Sara Valentik — Unidentified
19 Dragana Đorđević — Unidentified
20 Predrag Mrđa Docent, Mechanical Engineering Belgrade (probable) No record
21 Oliver Tošković Psychology professor, UB (probable) No record
22 Mitar Krstić — Unidentified
23 Milana Pisarić Law professor, Novi Sad (probable) No record
24 Dejan Bodiroga Former basketball player No record
25 Maja Krstić — Unidentified
26 Saša Tomas "Ćapi" Farmer-activist; ex-DS/LSV local candidate Centre-left / regionalist
27 Dejan Šoškić Ex-NBS governor, economist Centre (econ. centre-right)
28 Gordana Stefanović — Unidentified
29 Milena Petrović Professor, Univ. of Priština in K. Mitrovica No record
30 Aleksandra Perkov — Unidentified
31 Živojin Milovanović — Unidentified
32 Dejan Ivanišević — Unidentified
33 Danijela Stošić Panić Economics professor, Niš (probable) No record
34 Aleksandra Štimac Pharmacist, protest activist Centre (civic)
35 Dragan Stojković — (not the football coach) Unidentified
36 Dušan Đurđević EE professor, FTN K. Mitrovica; founder-signatory No record
37 Slavica Filipović — Unidentified
38 Mirza Ramusović Lawyer, Novi Pazar; environmental activist No record
39 Aleksandar Milojković — Unidentified
40 Sanja Fric Docent, Civil Engineering Belgrade; founder-signatory No record
TALLY: Centre-left 4 | Centre 5 | Right 0 | Far-left 0 | Far-right 0 | Identified, no record 14 | Unidentified 17
@d_pavlovic@mladen_mrdalj@Aleksandar_Mi@HrnjazMilos@parkesha2@GajicMihailo@ivkovic_al@JelenaZarkovic5
@d_pavlovic Dobra analiza! Dodao bih da je reinvestirana dobit dobrim delim profit banaka (zbog visokih kamatnih stopa) i trgovačkih društava, i da se uglavnom radi o "domaćem" kapitalu u smislu da dobit nije generisana kroz izvoz.
1. "neprofitne" lokalne štedionice bi završile kao i neprofitne druge finansijske institucije u rukama džave, pardon, društva
2. dinar nije precenjen, dovoljno je pogledati platni bilans unazad 10 godina, pa videti da je NBS neto kupovala evra a prodavala dinare - dakle sprečavala JAČANJE dinara
Slažem se, ali treba dodati da su ovakve debate (da l' su isti, ko je gori) ustvari proxy u narodu za nacionalno nadmetanje, gde se ustaše vide kao prirodni produžetak hrvatske zloće (Starčević itd), a četnici kao prirodni produžetak srpske zloće (Garašanin itd) - zapravo su oba zaključak netačna, jer su ustaše pre svega posledica ino fašista i nacista, a četnici su pre svega posledica ustaškog nasilja (ovaj potonji zaključak je nepriznat u stranoj istoriografija, region da ne pominjem).
@jguipre@polanskydj Frankly, most attacks on LS, including the one above, are just weak sauce, in spite of the fact that Straussian's obnoxiousness today derives in no small part from their teacher's blind spots. But one would need a Stanley Rosen or Robert Pippin to tease those out ...
Agree, it does not teach "nationalism", but its overall story is deeply embedded in some such notion (as YH lays out in Conservatism). The spin the Hebrew Bible puts on "nationalism" is that it is only valid as an extension of obedience to God, and so that is how you get all sorts of constraints on "nationlism", in particular how you stop it from morphing into empire seeking (hence the story of the tower of Babel, or the warning in Samuel made by God about the kingship). Whether any of that is effective is of course an entirely different story, but my point is simply that drawing a sharp line between the Hebrew Bible (in fact the whole of the Bible) and those thinkers, is the intellectually correct move.
This is exactly right - the Achilles heel of his whole project is on full display in the war in Gaza. But it would be helpful if you could spell out in more detail the Biblical basis of Enlightenment, as I am not so sure he is wrong on that score. (ie the thinkers you mentioned above have, I think, misunderstood and misinterpreted the Bible, but the proper answer to that is - so what?)
@channon_yarrow ad 3. problem su sankcije na platni promet s Rusijom a ne sredstva za otkup, rekao bih. Jorgovanka će ili ići sa zlatom ili preko Kineza.
Osnovna potka eseja je nategnuta: da je rast dinarske mase (M1) preko otkupa evra povezan sa privrednim rastom (kreditima). Ali banke ili države ne daju kredite niti troše na temelju M1. Uticaj otkupa evra NBS prethodnih godina je bio samo da održava kurs dinara da ne ojača previše (što bi destimulisalo izvoz), dok je povećana masa dinara, zapravo električni novac na računu NBS (= central bank reserves), ponovo izvučen iz bankarskog sistema redovnim repo transakcijama sa NBS.
Slažem se, naravno, da je pad SDI, ukoliko se nastavi, problematičan za privredu, jer delom finansira deficit planog računa (doduše samo delom, jer se dobar deo priliva iste godine izvlači iz zemlje zbog potrošnje na opremanja ili izgradnju fabrika).