@byeliseam Thank your for all your reviewing!! Curious if you have found that non-perfect articles also get R&Rs at top journals? My over-edited, super-careful articles always get rejected at top journals and accepted easily everywhere else. Curious if its just that my topic isn't sexy...
@kemi_aa Frankly, changing my rubric this way made me realize that all my professors coming up graded me wrong - they gave me A's cause i could write a good paper - a skill i didn't even learn in their class. Grade them for what they learned in YOUR class, that's good pedagogy anyway 🙂
@kemi_aa It's all about the rubric! Give more points for strong, specific uses of class materials, fewer for demonstrating general knowledge. Add new category: "writing style cohesion" - if they generate AI and then edit it, this score is low
@tsmullaney The learning science shows that summarizing what you learned by writing a short paragraph raises retention by 30% (Lang 2016). Reading responses were evidence-based (if a bitch to grade). But yeah, this was the semester many students gave over fully to AI, so what now?
Going through and grading everyone's AI drivel. Catching myself giving credit just when I can tell someone actually did the reading, even when the answer's wrong.
How's your finals week going?
#AcademicTwitter#AcademicChatter
@TiffanyKWayne I start by telling my students about the time i got a consulting job when Round 2 of the interview process was a mini research project - with cites! Many still do it wrong, but at least i had their attention for that moment.
@Cassie_Boness My assignment: 3 options, 1 is an interview. "Interview someone connected to China. Record if they are comfortable." Student decides to interview his Chinese prof. Forwards me Chinese prof's email: "Please ask Dr. Lee if it is ok if we don't record." New rule next year: no profs.
Me: Can I move this table?
Microsoft Word: Yes. I've also altered your margins, converted all "a" to $, printed page 4, and hidden one of your shoes. Is there anything else I can help you with?
@kaitlinsm1th@AcademicChatter Love it! I want to try #2. Like, what happens if you say at work: "You're implying that "x." That hurts my feelings and I'm not sure it's true."
@thephdstory After 5 yrs on the job market, I served on my first committee. I learned so much (and had to do and re-do a lot of the work that I botched the first time). If you're not at a top-tier R-1, it's about fit, fit, and fit.
Writing an exam for a class that, if taught anytime in the 50 years leading up to 2022, would not have had an exam.
We all live in ChatGPTland now.
#AcademicTwitter