@bbcnickrobinson just made an almighty pig’s ear of his Radio 4 Today programme interview with Dr Hilary Cass.
Firstly, he seemed confused about the difference between sex and gender identity. Then he failed to get to grips with the fundamental problem with the draft conversion practices bill.
The controversy centres on trans identity. Nobody is seriously arguing that people should be subjected to abusive conversion practices because they’re lesbian, gay or bisexual. The concern is that parents or therapists could find themselves confronted with a child who believes they were somehow ‘born in the wrong body’, yet risk falling foul of the law simply for questioning that belief or urging caution.
Hilary Cass managed to highlight some of the key issues, but Robinson, by using the term ‘LGBTQ+ community’, was doing what the BBC has done for years: lumping lesbian, gay and bisexual people together with those who identify as trans, as well as those who describe themselves as queer, which, in my view, is more a political movement than a sexual orientation. And what does the ‘+’ stand for Nick? Any ideas?
‘LGB’ and ‘TQ+’ are groups with different concerns, and treating them as a single, homogeneous community obscures the very issues that journalists should be examining.
The BBC has to do far better on this subject. But there’s precious little sign that it intends to.
What discussions are had with 11 year old boys on puberty blockers about these risks? Is even the lifelong need to dilate explained to them? What can they at 11 possibly make of all this?
At a Stonewall reception in parliament last night on the draft Bill on Conversion Practices a speaker said:
"Every day another middle aged lesbian is coming out against it. They are frightened their dating pool will get even smaller." Everyone laughed uproariously at this.
Is it funny Stonewall that a generation of young lesbians have been told that they are in fact trans and need to destroy their healthy bodies and minds? Is it funny that middle-aged lesbians want to warn against this?
When was it exactly that you lost your moral compass?Is there any lower for you to go? How dare you pretend this Bill would protect young homosexuals - all you want is to destroy them.
The first man who called himself a lesbian should have been the last. It’s time this became no debate. My contribution to #lesbianvisibilityweek
https://t.co/VIJGOA3XjC
As a mum whose family was dragged the the 2020 “gender dysphoria” trend by my then 11yo and the psychologist, we allowed the social stuff but no meds, were referred to a group of about 14 kids as a “social support” group. 13 of them, including my daughter are now back to identifying as their birth sex. The only outlier is an enormous autistic boy, 6ft2, who everyone is kind of terrified of, wears dresses and KISS make up and is now in a relationship with an autistic girl identifying as a boy/wolf. The two of them have complex pathologies, she uses a baby voice and they have no friends outside of internet fetish groups.
Most of the kids were not medicated, but 2 were, both detrans, one has arms full of horrible scars. The other is 19, balding, with facial hair and a gravelly voice. She’s furious at her parents for giving in to her 14yo tantrums and putting her on testosterone.
The kids are not ok. Thank the Gods mine is, now. But it was YEARS of hell, and tiptoeing around eggshells. Because of sick groomers like Tatchell.
@Doctor_Az_@PeterTatchell The mean age of respondents was 16 when they started treatment. They asked them when they were 20.
17% were no longer taking any medication, so weren't included.
The study is a bollocks.
Absolute codswollop! There have been no long terms follow studies and the figure you quote is pure fiction. 26% of my adult gender dysphoria patients over a 10 year period were regretters and none of them had been followed up. None of the UK gender clinics followed up any patients so please stop gaslighting the public with fake made up statistics. I work as a specialist in the field you do not and are just a non-clinical activist ✋🏼🚫‼️
NHS SPENT 11 MILLION POUNDS TRYING TO PROVE ONE CARDIOLOGIST WAS WRONG
Dr Raj Mattu flagged 5 patients crammed into 4 bed cardiac bays at Walsgrave Hospital in 2001. A 35 year old died because staff could not reach him in time.
He told @BBC. The trust suspended him, reportedly hired private investigators, and sent over 200 complaints about him to @gmcuk. All 200 were rejected.
At the 2016 remedy hearing the trust's barrister called him greedy for wanting the compensation he was already owed, then suggested he retrain as a school teacher on 30,000 pounds a year.
He won. Around 1.22 million pounds, up to 2.5 million once tax was added. The legal fight cost the trust over 11 million in public money.
Patients died. He spoke up. The system spent a decade trying to prove him wrong instead of fixing the ward.
Sources: @BBC@Telegraph@itvnews@guardian
He's right, and I've been warning doctors about this.
If you don't get your sh*t together, there will be one hourly-wage doctor supervising an LLM that's treating a thousand patients, and a lot of doctors looking for work.
The AI got 83.2% right on 304 New England Journal of Medicine cases. Generalist doctors got 36.1% right.
https://t.co/PoepRDeCwl
Regardless of personal opinions about Russell Brand, on the exact same day he received a prison sentence of ten years and six months, an Afghan national appeared in court for three counts of rape and penetration of a child under 13, but received a two-year suspended sentence.
🤬😡🤬😡🤬😡
In each photo, one children's writer and one author of a book about teaching. One set were called child abusers and drummed out of publishing. The others were feted and given millions of pounds. Which is which? @RooneyRach
@bloody_scandal@LilithGMarshell I was mental when my folate dipped very low. I think shortages of several b vitamins cause mental health issues. Particularly B1, B6, B9 and B12