MULTI-REGIONALISM THREAD
I will start with basic explanation of my views on the origins of modern humans, I will come back and branch out with more evidence and detail later.
writing it all out in short tweets with no plan will be a challenge, give me time!
Very exciting news, I have a 4th molar on my upper left side, it is smaller than my wisdom tooth but erupted properly with 4 cusps.
I am an outlier!!!
I am tempted to go to the dentist and get a scan and see what other traits I have, if I can afford it
@Phillip05166897 https://t.co/axG81yqhqa
In this I had denisovans as stronger shovelling than erectus grade. Interesting that erectus didn't get the 3 root first molar making them "less" sinodont than denisovans.
I'm back home from work and have a bit of energy to make a thread I was working on, I believe East Asia has four discrete dental groups between 500 and 80kya. Whilst largely being of the sinodont lineage they can be broken down more
Ok so firstly, hear me out!
The problems that the Reich paper was trying to solve are very complex and trying to solve them creates other problems, it builds on the earlier paper regarding the 80/20 population A/B split in modern human genetics
Guys I am having a moment of inspiration, a complete bastardisation of Reich's new work is coming to my mind. A way to incorporate his findings with what I already believe! Give me a few minutes to put it together, my flights tomorrow so I need to hurry and get to bed
@Phillip05166897 Some denisovan fossils have shovelling more extreme than Neanderthals, Xujiayao comes to mind.
In general though it looks like that supports a macro split of Africa and Eurasian like we talked about recently
@HighlyCitedX It's not like OOA broke from all Africans at the same time, significant substructure would have already existed in Africa where Dinka and san as examples were already themselves diverged from east Africans. (Keep in mind I think OOA is rubbish, just being generous to them here)
@HighlyCitedX I think there's a fair explanation for OOA people for this. If Eurasians, (represented by french in this example) split from Africa through an east African population and not Dinka or San, then the divergence from Dinka or San would have to be higher than OOA dates
@Phillip05166897 Even with clinal variation in afrodonts it's still a lot of changes away from sinodonts though! My mind is starting to give up on me honestly
@Phillip05166897 For the modern human discussion this is too old, but what I have wondered is how it relates to the other older fossils in East Asia, like how developed sinodonty was in yunxian, lantian and yuanmou. Whether this afrodont to sinodont process happened once or more often??
@Phillip05166897 I might have said this before, but if population A and B are afrodonts then it has the same issue that normal OOA does, just with extra steps.
@Phillip05166897 It's why anything OOA within 300kya is a non starter for me, it's not enough time to converge and we see no transitional fossils I am aware of towards sinodonts. Majority admixture is the other option but that isn't monogenesis anymore which no one else will agree with but me lol
@Phillip05166897 By transitional to Eurasian dental complexes do you mean sinodonts? Or are you talking about west Eurasians who are more clearly descended from afrodonts. Because a plausible afrodonts to sinodont explanation is all I am looking for here in a bigger picture
@Phillip05166897 I've already said this is the only version of the population A and B discourse I would accept, otherwise I'd ignore the whole discussion because it just can't explain modern sinodonts. If 1 isn't true I'm not interested in population A, 2 is my opinion more
This is the only interpretation of the Reich paper I am willing to accept, it at the very least could be compatible with the dental evidence. No magic needed to produce sinodonts, sundadonts, or jomondonts. It explains how population A could have come from the Eurasian side