My preseason priors for the NESCAC were pretty close in our first chance to see them play non-conference #d3fb opponents. Both scores had errors well within the normal range.
But all three NESCACs are underdogs next week:
Wesleyan +3.8
Trinity +18.3
Amherst +27.1 (!)
@acampbellsports I'm not defending the old framework.
Other sports don't have the same scheduling constraints football has:
β’ fewer contests
β’ higher share of contests played in conference
β’ higher share of non-conference games played within your own geographic region
I'm not going to publicly "out" anybody on here, but whenever I point out the flaws of NPI, it's not just coaches from the WIAC liking the tweets or sending me DMs expressing frustration.
Coaches and staffs at all levels of the division know NPI is the wrong solution for #d3fb.
Coach McElroy has the same perspective I have regarding the current #d3fb playoff selection process - it's creating misaligned incentives and opportunities for bad actors to game the system.
It's not hard to create decent ratings for #d3fb. As Mr. Burke notes below, this is basically a solved problem. DIII has constraints that make it more difficult than FBS/NFL, but you have to *go out of your way* to make a model as bad as NPI.
Coach McElroy has the same perspective I have regarding the current #d3fb playoff selection process - it's creating misaligned incentives and opportunities for bad actors to game the system.
"What do we want to incentivize? Do we want big games ... or do we want people to game the system?"
π @McElroy26 discusses @BethelRoyalsFB's #d3fb playoff "snub" and what Division III should reward:
https://t.co/Ds0phZPWSo
@NCCClassof88 The *NCAA* wants a uniform process - they get that with NPI. The decision makers that put NPI in place don't want to hear "football is different", even if it's true.
The FAQ sheets from the NCAA when NPI was being implemented also supply some interesting insights.
And they still have a heavyweight waiting for his football season to wrap up before he gets added to these rankings.
I'm guessing he'll do alright... He beat the current #1 at 285 in their dual against Loras last season.
πππ
Wartburg holds the No. 1 spot in the @nwcawrestling Division III Tournament rankings, backed by eight Knights ranked in the top 10 of their respective weight classes.
#GoKnights x @wartburgwrestle
πππ
Wartburg holds the No. 1 spot in the @nwcawrestling Division III Tournament rankings, backed by eight Knights ranked in the top 10 of their respective weight classes.
#GoKnights x @wartburgwrestle