Responses received after concerns were raised through NALC feedback linked to MHCLG consultations.
Leigh Ingham MP & Sir Gavin Williamson MP.
Both letters acknowledge concerns around publicly accessible infrastructure being left in private arrangements. #unadoptedestates
Never buy a leasehold property!
This was our apartment block where we bought our first property. Shortly after moving in we were told building works were needed to replace a supporting wall. The bill was to be covered by all of the leaseholders.
Each property owner was billed £15,000 each.
No way out. No hiding from it. Pay now or debt recovery would start. That's what the management company told us. We got legal advice and they said to pay it...you cant win.
We borrowed money from parents to pay..which we are still paying back monthly.
Never again! Just don't do it.
@FloEshalomi congratulations for being given a ministerial role on the MHCLG team. It would be wonderful if the portfolio for unadopted estates was assigned to you by @AngelaRayner and @andyburnham.
We feel you understand our issues well.
As @andyburnham is keen to implement the devolution strategy, this will go down well with our supporters as it would give a strong signal that our new Prime Minister @10DowningStreet is going to tackle unadopted estates properly. It will also separate us from #leasehold issues which we would appreciate greatly.
https://t.co/IjzWwX2YQG
#StopTheRotAdoptTheLot @alistrathern@charliedewhirst@CHinchliffMP@paulwaugh@PeterKLamb@JonathanBrash@NeilDotObrien@GoAndrCoop
Jonathan Brash MP -
"Estates do need to be managed, but we should go back to how they were managed: by local authorities. That is the way to truly fix the system: ensure that every estate is adopted by every council and drive these estate management companies into the dust where they belong."
Thank you for your strong message @JonathanBrash We need more MP's to support #RetrospectiveUniversalAdoption
#StopTheRotAdoptTheLot #EndUnadoptedEstates #TurnOffTheTap
@PeterKLamb@GoAndrCoop@andyburnham@mtpennycook@FloEshalomi
@TiceRichard And you've failed to pay your tax. I'll take great pleasure in showing these documents to the world as soon as I receive them.
https://t.co/tkJJDJ2use
Interesting.
So let’s mark this from 2024 onwards.
Labour came into government promising planning reform, more housebuilding and action on the growing problems associated with #fleecehold#Fakefreeholds#unadoptedestates … private estate management.
The problem is that much of the political obsession with housing numbers is driven by growth targets and GDP figures, while many of the long-term consequences are pushed aside.
At the same time, serious questions remain about flooding, public facing infrastructure and accountability.
When will Schedule 3 of the Flood and Water Management Act 2010 finally be implemented? And what about the countless developments already built under the current system?
More and more public infrastructure, including SuDS, public open spaces and other assets required by planning permissions, is ending up under private management arrangements rather than public ownership.
Residents are paying council tax, yet increasingly find themselves paying again through “estate charges”.
If Labour is going to push large-scale developments through while dismissing concerns as coming from “blockers”, then Labour should also accept responsibility for the consequences.
That means roads that cannot cope, pressure on schools and GP services, flood risk and the continued use of private management arrangements where councils choose not to adopt public facing infrastructure and residents are left paying private companies indefinitely.
People are told they are buying freehold homes, then discover they are funding public open spaces, drainage systems (SuDS), play areas and other infrastructure through estate charges on top of council tax.
The local authorities get paid.
The developers get paid.
The management companies get paid.
…
But it’s the residents get the bill.
Labour promised change.
Residents will judge them on whether they deliver it.
You cannot keep approving thousands of homes, leave public facing infrastructure in private hands and then dismiss legitimate concerns when people start asking who benefits from it all.
From where many of us are standing, it looks like Government is bending over for developers, investors and growth targets while expecting residents to just put up and shut up.
#fleecehold #fakefreeholds #unadoptedestates #section106
https://t.co/SrV76PVJ8b
🚨NEW: Peter Mandelson's lobbying company worked for Water UK, the body representing the private water industry.
At the same time, Labour's review of the water industry refused to even consider public ownership as an option.
In our open letter to Steve Reed MP, we ask: who has been controlling the water industry, and to what purpose? https://t.co/HQVIoYjAGf
Unbelievable rip off
Our water is a natural monopoly but it's been sold off and handed out to shareholders around the world
We are a guaranteed revenue stream
Any government that cares about sewage and cost of living should be taking EVERY water company into special administration and PERMANENT PUBLIC OWNERSHIP whenever they fail to fulfil their statutory duties (which they do often)
😡😡😡”The analysis done by private firms was sometimes so poor that NHS radiologists had to read scans again, raising questions about the benefit of outsourcing.”
The government promised “the biggest wave of insourcing in a generation”. They must deliver it now.
That’s the contradiction with these so-called “private estates”.
They are not private in reality.
The roads, parks, drainage and public open spaces are publicly accessible and often required through planning permission for the wider community benefit.
Yet the long-term maintenance, wear, damage and liability gets dumped onto estate residents through management charges while everyone else can still use the spaces for free.
Section 106 and CIL are also not “developer gifts”.
Those costs are built into viability calculations, land values and ultimately house prices.
The anticipated homeowners pay for it.
Then local authorities can take money generated from the development and spend it on projects elsewhere, sometimes on their own flagship assets, while refusing to adopt the actual infrastructure on the estate itself.
Residents end up paying through the house price, council tax and ongoing estate charges, while older areas remain publicly maintained through general taxation.
It’s a broken and unfair system created by failures in both central and local government.
For Stafford Borough it seems they pushed this model back onto their residents and developers.
We would also urge greater attention to the growing issue of “fleecehold” housing estates, where residents on new-build developments pay full council tax whilst also being charged “private estate management fees” for roads, paths drainage (SuDS), play parks, public open spaces and other public-facing infrastructure as part of the planning process for everyone to benefit from the development being agreed.
More councils and developers have moved towards “private management/maintenance” arrangements instead of public adoption.
In practice this leaves many residents paying twice for infrastructure that serves the wider public, but without the same accountability, protections or democratic oversight people would normally expect.
This #fleecehold model needs to end, including retrospective action where possible.
Residents should not be paying full council tax whilst also paying private estate charges for roads, drainage, parks and open spaces that were required through planning and are used by the wider public.
There needs to be stronger consumer protection and proper public adoption or accountable long-term management of public infrastructure and open space.
#fleecehold #fakefreeholds #PublicLandPublicGood #unadoptedestates #estatecharges #housing #planning #localgovernment #newbuilds
#conditionalfreehold
#StopTheRotAdoptTheLot
#section106 #flooding
@AndyBurnhamGM
🔥Public OWNERSHIP of our public services is popular with all voter groups
It’s good that Andy Burnham is speaking out against 40 years of privatisation, since Thatcher
But the solution is NOT just public control - it’s public ownership
Sign our letter to Andy Burnham: https://t.co/4Ku1grcl7G
We would also urge greater attention to the growing issue of “fleecehold” housing estates, where residents on new-build developments pay full council tax whilst also being charged “private estate management fees” for roads, paths drainage (SuDS), play parks, public open spaces and other public-facing infrastructure as part of the planning process for everyone to benefit from the development being agreed.
More councils and developers have moved towards “private management/maintenance” arrangements instead of public adoption.
In practice this leaves many residents paying twice for infrastructure that serves the wider public, but without the same accountability, protections or democratic oversight people would normally expect.
This #fleecehold model needs to end, including retrospective action where possible.
Residents should not be paying full council tax whilst also paying private estate charges for roads, drainage, parks and open spaces that were required through planning and are used by the wider public.
There needs to be stronger consumer protection and proper public adoption or accountable long-term management of public infrastructure and open space.
#fleecehold #fakefreeholds #PublicLandPublicGood #unadoptedestates #estatecharges #housing #planning #localgovernment #newbuilds
#conditionalfreehold
#StopTheRotAdoptTheLot
#section106 #flooding
Taylor Wimpey has just pulled out of building more apartments in London because of weak demand. Not planning related.
That is people boycotting leasehold flats because they are a terrible buy. Last year, 60% of all London properties sold were leasehold flats, but they made up 90% of all losses. Wake up!
SW1 silence, including from groups who claim to push for radical growth opportunities and represent young people being screwed, is deeply suspect.