Can't exposed meaningful MaMa2018 vote data as Mnet is smarter now. They know that without giving actual votes of each group to results, it is not easy to find their faults.
Using JUST percentage is the smartest cheating way.
Anyway, will still be there.
"Which group do you think has most potential to become worldwide star in 2018?" https://t.co/DnIUxEq07w
As this have no value, no manipulation yet. You can see NO synchronized patterns at all, unlike #2017MAMA Same system but different waveform - the answer to MaMa fraud again.
@ellennaGrace We see a lot more. But we do not want to attack any fandom. That is why we still blur a fnadom name in chart who paid votes. We just tell them to shut up and do not accuse others cheating.
@ellennaGrace There are more than we reported here. In MCD weekly polls, MWave Music charts. We see fandoms (charting group/fanclub in China) who paid voting company to win.
And even one craziest thing is, Mnet did vote crazy to protect a group in Music Chart as rival paid to kill them.
@ellennaGrace We did not plan to expose Mama. That is why we do not have data logs for all polls. But we have all 20 polls data in last few days. We see all are the same. Repeated peaks and dips are always found in them.
We did include curves for IU, W1, tara, Seventeen in our tweets.
@JoshingTweets We also found the other polls which are not related to BTS and EXO were the same. From what we see, all 20 polls are rigged. We do not release them because there are too many polls and people will be confused.
@JoshingTweets See what we did in excel so that vote speed can be used to compare with each others. It is because you can't compared new votes in 3 mins to new votes in 1 hour. So we normalized all data to vote/min for each updates.
https://t.co/MJzoME9v6F
#2017MAMA Since vote results are updated in non-regular basis by Mnet. It can be a few min to hours. So peak values can't be compared. That is why we normalize ALL data to vote per min by:
Vote/Min = (new total votes - last total votes) / (two update interval in mins)
@JoshingTweets All votes numbers were downloaded from Mama poll web page directly with cURL (google it) in every one minute. As results were updated in few min to 1 hr. Duplicated data were removed. Final data were extracted to a text file and finally imported to Excel.
#2017MAMA These are "MWave Music Chart". Paid votes are controlled by server, once jobs done, the server will tell all connected machines to stop. So we see all paid votes will drop in one minute.
If they were from real human, no one can control people to stop at the exact time.
#2017MAMA Some one challenged us fandom can pay for votes. This was downloaded from voting company server in 2014. It was a log showing machines and no. of vote done.
What is "mwave_sup_807/812"?
mawave : MWave
sup: Super Junior
807/812: order no.
@MYUNincognito Read our tweets for what we said before. For paid votes, we said it was Mnet Music Chart! Read it again, it is "Mnet Music Chart" OK?
And Mnet Music Chart is not Mama polls! Can you understand? Your fandom are.... speechless.
@MYUNincognito Do you think we know less than you? Mnet used Amazon AWS & we need you to tell? Their servers did collect votes from different countries and the curves must be more smooth than real time curves! And tell me why BTS and other curve are smooth but not EXO curves!
#2017MAMA You may ask why people will join them? The software installed in PC will count how many they contribute and the voting company will pay them who help the polls. That tells why they can have so many members.
#2017MAMA So how many computers the voting company can use for polls? We were told by one of them that they have many ten thousands of members. And they can vote 24 hrs a day too.
#2017MAMA Works on clients side can be done automatically for easy polls. Or done by the pc owners manually for polls which need captcha. So they can have many different IPs, SNS accounts to win any polls. What is needed is money.
#2017MAMA What is voting company? Some organizations have setup a system. They have server. Any people can join and become their members by just installing their software on their PC. When the company receive orders, server will tell all connected PC to do the works.
#2017MAMA Besides Mnet rigged the polls, there are "voting companies" in China who can vote for large and lazy fandom but with money. We have proof for Mnet Music Chart polls in which one arrogant fandom paid for vote while they are always the one accusing others cheating.
@raissanaaa We've seen this kind of fraud for years in Kpop. This's nothing new. Mnet is doing it too obvious that we can tell the world with solid proofs. Some others hide votes counts and just give percentage. Those are harder to reveal anything. They are much smarter than Mnet.