@Yboc_Coby@realillyrian668 My point is based on the available ancient DNA record, not assumptions about modern haplogroup distributions. We need actual ancient samples to establish where and when E1b1a was present.
@Yboc_Coby@realillyrian668 The Bantu expansion began roughly 3,500 years ago. It is a demographic expansion, not direct evidence of E1b1a’s presence throughout Africa in earlier periods.
@myinfluenstar@TINGIS47@realillyrian668 Scientific discussions should consider the actual findings and their limitations rather than dismissing the evidence.
@myinfluenstar@TINGIS47@realillyrian668 Actually, Gad et al. (2020) provides genetic evidence worth considering. Their study reported a predicted E1b1a haplotype for Ramesses III based on Y-STR markers. However, we should distinguish between a predicted haplogroup and a SNP-confirmed subclade.
@thaathebrewboyy@realillyrian668 Ancient DNA from West and Central Africa remains limited, but this does not mean there is no genetic evidence available. More ancient samples are needed to reconstruct early lineages and migration patterns with greater accuracy.
@thaathebrewboyy@realillyrian668 I understand your point. However, we should distinguish between modern and ancient DNA. Genetic studies of present-day African populations do exist. We should also remember that Y-DNA is passed from father to son, with mutations accumulating over generations.
@XRchest في افغانستان تم دك الكهوف الجبلية بقنابل GBU-43 8.5 طن شديدة الانفجار قد تستخدمها امريكا في حربها القادمة تمهيدا للقنبلة GBU-57 الـ Bunker Buster
@grok@Sigma_300Gyatt@realillyrian668 and class bias. Using a few scattered 21st-century samples from Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, or Iraq to validate a medieval military narrative is a scientific fallacy. Genetics can map deep ancestral origins,