@tsunakamaxxing Byakuya is a top 3 character for me and none of this is true. The secret is that you can just like characters who are piece of shit losers. Its that easy!
@Blurry39819822@SNK_LRD This is definitely veering into deranged crackpot territory but I've always thought that if the no DF on raftel thing was true, an interesting way around it would be to have blackbeard steal luffy's devil fruit.
@Dread_Botlord@YaBoi_ChipsAhoy I would say that what you're describing is the climax of VADER'S arc, not Luke's. It is still a very powerful and thematically resonant moment, of course.
@Dread_Botlord@YaBoi_ChipsAhoy The climax is him choosing not to kill Vader which in the scene is presented as the same thing as him rejecting the dark side. It's very easily to extrapolate from that that the power to kill Vader is related to the dark side.
@Dread_Botlord@YaBoi_ChipsAhoy At that point you're rewriting the story to take out the climax of the protagonists character arc so no i dont think it would be the same at all actually
@Dread_Botlord@YaBoi_ChipsAhoy I wasn't planning to touch the prequels but if we want to go there then Yoda got his ass beat. Also in other canon material, even while being held back by his injuries, Vader is hunting down and killing jedi left and right.
@Dread_Botlord@YaBoi_ChipsAhoy So in short, the understanding of relative powers is why Luke's decision to forgo his immediate goal of victory in the fight, in favor of a moral victory, is meaningful
@Dread_Botlord@YaBoi_ChipsAhoy The reason the metaphor and Luke's character arc work is because we have this more traditional sense of what "strength" means and intrinsically understand why it would be tempting. It can then be contrasted with the "true" strength that is harder to understand but more valuable
@Dread_Botlord The fact that Luke can become more powerful and defeat Vader by giving in to the dark side, but chooses not to, is what gives that moment its thematic weight. How is powerscaling not relevant to that?