@CartesianDemons@cremieuxrecueil@jackvirolainen Every politician has speechwriters, hundreds of them are young and have "winning smiles"- few manage to propel themselves from a landslide senate victory to the presidency in less than a decade.
@intentionalisms@atlanticesque Generally run on sentences are necessary for dialogue to feel natural, even if it can be a somewhat harder to read.. people do not ordinarily constrain themselves to sentence structures when actually talking or communicating casually
Genuinely reprehensible that we are not actively making contact with these people. Imagine if there was a post-scarcity utopia on Mars that could end all of Earth's struggles but instead just observed us as animals for the sake of cultural preservation.
@geologisms Though this is already being done to ensure isolation.. my main issue is that it only takes one dangerously permissive government to destroy these communities because they literally do not even know they are at risk- making contact and protecting them as they develop will allow-
@AdrianAdriasola@neincubed I'll admit I am not extremely familiar, but how would this be an argument against free will more than an argument for how broad it must be? Some elementary research informs me that he is not even a determinist
@AdrianAdriasola@neincubed It's an appeal to experts, not common opinion- just as appealing to Conway is.
Regardless, I don't see how viewing free will as independent is absurd from a religious perspective. If you grant the pig of course it can have a tail.
@AdrianAdriasola@neincubed I am actually not certain I believe in "souls", I am only 55-45 on free will and of course that's harder to knock, but the argument without them is just the same as my other reply- when you have a being that can do anything that is not self contradictory.. it can do anything!
@AdrianAdriasola@neincubed The common argument here is that the "soul" is independent from the body, but exercises its material will through it, forcing someone into unconsciousness would not alter the soul but the soul's expression in the physical realm.
@AdrianAdriasola@neincubed God's influence would be selective here. I also do not entirely understand exporting thinking to people like Conway while operating under the assumption that nearly every major religious scholar that has ever existed in any pro free will sect (most of them) was just wrong.
@AdrianAdriasola@neincubed You are better off arguing from an evidence perspective surrounding things like belief being impacted by magnetic stimulation than philosophy, I doubt it's satisfying but religion is a philosophical cockroach because it need not obey anything we understand.
@AdrianAdriasola@neincubed Is consciousness linked to human existence or our physical form? Why would that necessarily make it impossible for a being that transcends physicality to impose an incomprehensible capability from their realm?
@Paul_Melman Also a few select members of the tribe should not speak for all eternally. An elder chief has no right to deprive knowledge or modern access from her people, a mother has no right to deprive that from her child, should any individual want to seek it.
@Paul_Melman If a tentacle monster suddenly appeared in your room holding a gun, you might flee, but that doesn't mean you don't want to be hit by the alien's "cure all diseases and bless with eternal happiness" ray