@TheMetsX Their best prospects are in the majors. The draft was only a week ago and there hasn’t been a trade deadline yet to replenish. System producing 3 quality major leaguers this year is a good sign for the system. If Benge, Ewing, and McLean were still in AAA it would look different
@draftniks Just 157 at bats and he’s had 2 serious injuries this year. Including a hamate injury which is murder for hitters in the short term.
I would bank on this year being the outlier first instead of hastily selling low.
@MarkDiLullo@MetsMuse Take the defensive wear and tear off of him and move him off short before considering dealing him. Many good SS age gracefully at 2nd or 3rd base as they get older.
Simien almost won an MVP doing that.
@MarkDiLullo@MetsMuse Lindor’s OPS by year as a Met until this year, where he has been hurt all year:
100
125
121
137
128
This is not a declining player and has improved offensively as he’s aged. Trading him now is selling low on one of the 5 best position players in franchise history
@MarkDiLullo@MetsMuse No he hasn’t. He’s been great for 5 straight years and broke a hamate bone in spring training, which hurts everyone’s offense (look at Alonso his hamate year).
The solution to Lindor is to maybe move him off short as he ages to preserve his legs.
@timoshinjo 5 of their top 6 guys coming into the year were either traded, or are in the majors. The draft was 3 days ago and there hasn’t been a trade deadline yet to replenish.
3 of 4 best players on the team were prospects coming into the year, so that’s a good sign for the system
@TheMetsX The solution is to eventually move him off short, not trade him. He had a hamate injury in spring training which effects everyone, this would be insanely short-sighted.
@TheMetsX@Senga2Alvarez There also hasn’t been a draft or trade deadline to replenish. Ewing, Benge, McLean (and Scott though he wasn’t considered a prospect anymore) being quality major leaguers is a good sign for the team’s developmental dept.
@BaldPanarin This one is harder than the forwards other than Pitt clearly last. Top 3 is all interchangeable to me… Rangers probably have the highest floor, Devils have the highest ceiling and Caps probably the best combo of floor/ceiling
@iHatejeffwilpon@acoustic567 And my point is just because they’re in the majors doesn’t really not make them not prospects anymore. They’re highly valuable, tradeable, controllable talent until they hit arbitration (2/2).
@iHatejeffwilpon@acoustic567 If Benge, McLean & Ewing were still in the minors and not in the majors, the perception of the system would be substantially different. We also traded Sproat and Jett to acquire talent. Thats the point of prospects - getting them to the majors and acquiring talent (1/2)
@iHatejeffwilpon@acoustic567 Last point:
Farm systems don’t operate like balance sheets as a pure snapshot in time. I personally hate system rankings, I think they should include all major leaguers under who aren’t arb eligible. NHL rankings operate that way and it’s a better picture of your development.
@iHatejeffwilpon@acoustic567 Also, based on your tweets, I assume you’re about 17. I’ve forgotten more baseball in my 30+ years than you currently know. Don’t insult me.
@iHatejeffwilpon@acoustic567 You’re talking to the wrong person. It’s reasonable to take a step back when your team promotes its best prospects. They haven’t even had a draft yet. Context always matters.