@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics Our differing economic views relate to our opinion on the human condition- yours is far more pessimistic than mine. There is also no such thing as a free market (I’m assuming you don’t think children should work 12 hours a day in mines). The unregulated market is coercion.
@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics I obviously see it the other way around. You have a utopian vision regarding marketisation - although you do accept inequality. In fact, you believe in it. I see it as unnecessary (and also harmful to economic growth). There is also Mother Nature - which I don’t think you see.
@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics None. I’m trying to work out my own tbh. But it doesn’t involve allowing markets to run society. Markets and private property would be the majority - I believe in Ostrom’s work re the commons. I’d like to see areas of the economy shared (natural monopolies basically).
@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics Not at all, it’s the exact opposite. The funny thing is, we both want to achieve the same thing - freedom. Austrian school treat the market like an all-powerful God. It isn’t. It’s basically the same as a state - it’s a political construct that needs to be very well regulated.
@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics Your economic ideology is based upon your view of human nature. No doubt that you see competition > cooperation and your view is that human’s are naturally selfish and need a strict hierarchy to suppress that selfish instinct. You have to think that - you’re Hayekian.
@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics On the other side of the coin, it also created the greatest 30 years in capitalist history. Chile was completely ruined by Austrian influenced capitalism. We’ve had hundreds of years without Gov really doing any welfare programs, the result was slow growth and widespread poverty.
@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics Both those examples worked out terribly. We are living in the Hayekian age of economics - obviously it doesn’t work (not even in theory) and it relies on massive state intervention. There is no such thing as a free market and Gov austerity doesn’t work. We can agree to disagree.
@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics Markets rely on functioning states. If we continue with Austrian inspired neoliberalism, then there won’t be any functioning states left by 2100. Your conception of economic growth is also flawed - growth for whom? Growth for what purpose? We need that big thing we live on.
@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics Billionaire businessman are not really competing, they’re more colluding. BlackRock pretty much fund everything. A result of deregulation in the 80s.
@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics Your take is mental. It’s already costing billions. We live inside the earth’s biosphere, this is another example of how HayekIan theory falls apart. Negative externalities are real!
@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics Are you referring to 1 billionaire? How about the other few thousand who have bought our politicians? The market is a political construct.
@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics Something needed to change, but neoliberalism was the wrong type of change. The public and private sectors are symbiotic- the public is a platform for the private. Privatisation and financialisation have created the very conditions you wish to prevent - a small ruling elite.
@ecurrnomics@aClassicLiberal US dominance has been toppled and the trend is clear. Leaving society to “the market” has ironically created a version of corporate communism. Markets should be servants, not masters. As a liberal, what is your answer to the climate emergency? Can the market correct it?
@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics Who made a neoliberal turn in the 80s. Why mention China? You neoliberals constantly straw man arguments (and their better use of the state has outgunned the US economy anyhow). Hayek took over from Keynes in the late 70s and the Golden Age was destroyed. You’ve been winning.
@aClassicLiberal@ecurrnomics You neoliberals have no idea about how to govern a society. Governments are all in trouble bc they’ve handed over power to the market. Privatisation and financialisation cost a fortune, neoliberalism doesn’t make the state smaller - it makes it bigger! Corporate communism.