@NorthlightEins@DerPilot123@MehmalS_ North, I appreciate your clarification. I think I misunderstood the distinction you were making. You're right that institutions of higher education and universities, in the strict historical sense, are not necessarily the same thing. I apologise for the misunderstanding...
@DerPilot123@MehmalS_ We should distinguish between the history of higher education and the history of the European university as a particular institutional model. Both are important, but they are not the same historical question.
@DerPilot123@MehmalS_ George Makdisi himself discussed this distinction. My argument is not that both institutions were identical, but that the Islamic world had an advanced and organised system of higher education centuries before modern universities.
@DerPilot123@MehmalS_ I understand your distinction, and I agree that medieval Islamic madrasas were not identical to medieval European universities in their institutional and corporate structure.
@DerPilot123@MehmalS_ Bro
Times are different
Mediveil hospitals are not the same as todays one but in their times they were hospitals where people were treated...
@DerPilot123@MehmalS_ Nobody needs to claim that medieval madrasas were identical to European corporate universities. But your own cited passage explicitly acknowledges that the madrasa was an institution of higher learning and that serious scholars have referred to it as a university.
@DerPilot123@MehmalS_ Your claim is nothing but historical ignorance. You can debate definitions all you want, but pretending an entire civilisation had no higher education for centuries just exposes how poorly you've researched the subject. Do some reading before embarrassing yourself again
Goodluck