@invcondemnation No shout out to @IJ ? π The irony is that James Catterson represented the Town. See his constrained concurrence in 77 AD3d 434, 437 (1st dept 2010).
Sorry to critique but @IJ's Robert McNamara should've pounced in rebuttal on Texas' reference of Penn Central, which is where all takings challenges go to die. And he should've said as much. Further, this was akin to a physical take under Loretto; Penn Central is inapplicable.
I ask it every time there is oral argument on #EminentDomain: what is it about #Condemnation that is so difficult for #SCOTUS to comprehend?! Just pretend it's Freedom of Speech! *Sigh* The #TakingsClause is indeed the bastard child of the Bill of Rights.
Justice Jackson said, "We have very clear, very well-established legal principles as to what qualifies as a taking." Ummm, how is Penn Central clear, Justice Jackson?! #EminentDomain#RegulatoryTakings
Respectfully, I believe this judge got this #EminentDomain decision wrong. A de facto claim is very different from a de jure claim and this was NOT a de facto claim subject to a 3 year statute of limitations. @invcondemnation https://t.co/jiTLgqGxwD