@pogrdog@bryanculbertson@kimmaicutler Gross receipts tax was proposed after the council flat out said they’d run against a payroll tax, which is the actual best version of this (and the most popular among individual voters.)
@rsomething@brezina@ClaraJeffery BART 100% should focus on the core by investing new capital and expanding access in San Francisco. And BART over-extended lines without adding core metro lines. That said, simply chopping off service outside the core isn’t the path to financial stability.
@bradgessler@brezina@ClaraJeffery These are not responses grounded in the reality of public services. “Reboot” is not what happens—BART losing funding will suck short term & impacts will grow long term. You can automate away every driver & still face 90-95% of the op deficit BART has — plus the big capital costs.
@brezina It’s clear you don’t rely on BART daily & can afford to have service stop or radically reduce. Cutting funds has never worked as a method for improving service. Sales tax is a dumb way to fund it, but stakes are real. YES to RTM *and* to increase core investment & better funding.
@Vox_Adversum@MaxSchengen@Tetris_Official Tetris has sued many knockoffs, including most famously Mino. This one is particularly high profile. Are you an IP lawyer?
@SFMTA_Muni Waited over 20 min for the next one. Packed like sardines. Driver trying to skip stops. People turned away along Duboce for lack of space. Why did this happen?
@SFMTA_Muni I’m confused. The driver just unloaded an entire packed downtown-bound N Judah train at Hillway with no further explanation. What is going on? 47th is nowhere near here?
@Onargiix@brezina@schneider As i've explained, transit agencies don't really automate for labor cost. Automation of taxis makes sense because labor costs are high per passenger. But a train can carry thousands of people. Automation would save only 10% of BART's budget & cost 50 years worth of labor build.
@Onargiix@brezina@schneider Paris could not push the # of trains through the tunnel they needed to without automating them. It was a strategic investment in capacity.
BART should automate for many reasons, incl throughput, but it won't get us anywhere w/ budget today—and BART would need a lot MORE capital
@Onargiix@brezina@schneider Cost savings are NOT the primary reason transit systems automate. BART drivers are roughly 10% of BART budget, or ~ $90-100 mil. At $5 bil capital cost, that's 50 yrs of labor! And where does that money come from today?
Automation is normally about throughput (eg more trains).
@brezina@schneider The problem with BART isn't that its labor costs are extraordinary, it's that it over-relied on peak commute trips to fund its service. Unique ridership is *UP* vs pre-pandemic, but each rider takes it 2-3 days/wk vs 5 days/wk. Decreasing service in response would drop ridership.
@brezina@schneider Sure, but their labor costs are not particularly high. I realize everyone is trying to reduce labor costs & BART can as well, but unlike smaller transportation like cabs or even buses, per passenger-mile labor costs on BART is orders of magnitude lower.
@NoCyclopathTO@Waymo BART has an op budget of $883 million/yr.
Waymo's is somewhere ~ $2-6 billion/yr.
BART is "FAILING" w/ 2.5 million riders.
Waymo has "HUGE RIDERSHIP" w/ 876,000 riders.
🤔