Ockham Razor

Law of Parsimony: When presented with competing hypothetical answers to a problem, one should select the one that makes the fewest assumptions.

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@justinbieber

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@Askwhyisit You gotta pay the troll toll to get into the boy's soul!

[Brother Rachid الأخ رشيد @BrotherRasheed]

Muhammad created a god that satisfies his desires, Aisha said to him “your lord hastens to satisfy your desire”, was Aisha saying the truth or was she lying?

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@JazimDev @ExMuslimMemes @harrysteve73431 Why are you assuming that? Is it written in the Hadith? Even then, how is such a nasty beating justified? If she is right and he has recently developed erectile dysfunction, isn't she stuck in a sexless, childless marriage now?

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@Alphonso_Edward @Assimalhakeem Okay, and if she is right (penile dysfunction after kids) she is stuck with this guy. No sex, no kids.

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@Alphonso_Edward @Assimalhakeem Muhammad didn't deduce, assume, state that she cheated in 'any' form. Why are you doing that? Do you know more than him?

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@Alphonso_Edward @Assimalhakeem 3 reasons are possible.She wanted kids. She wanted sex. (Both of which Abdur can't provide if he is impotent) Abdur is also clearly very violent. So, she may have realised Rifaa isn't all that bad compared to Abdur.

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@TateTheTalisman @DrLoupis Are you sure?

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@Alphonso_Edward @Assimalhakeem You are assuming things & considering them as facts.Wife becomes a cheater based on such assumed facts. Not otherwise.
Again, since cheating is such a big deal,it should have been mentioned in Hadith. How come such important detail was missed?

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@Alphonso_Edward @Assimalhakeem There is no proof that she spoke with Rifaa. Don't assume anything.
Since it is such a big deal and frowned upon, the husband would have mentioned that to further incriminate her. It would have helped his case.

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@Alphonso_Edward @Assimalhakeem I'm not supporting anyone . I'm just stating possibilities. I'm actually taking husband's side here. What's an affair according to you?

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@Alphonso_Edward @Assimalhakeem Affair doesn't meant fornication according to you? What do you think an affair is?

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@Alphonso_Edward @Assimalhakeem The other wife had kids. She may not want more kids, and not have high libido. She could be afraid to speak up since he is a wife beater.

I repeat. He could have been okay when he had kids,and could have later developed penile dysfunction. Isn't that possible? Dont u get that?

[Brother Rachid الأخ رشيد @BrotherRasheed]

Straw man fallacy, Islam is funny because if you don’t wake up Satan urinated in your ear.
How many times Satan urinated in your ear? Can you count? Basically according to this Hadith your ear is a toilet for Satan. You ignored this main point and changed it to something else. Nice try 🤣🤣

[Brother Rachid الأخ رشيد @BrotherRasheed]

Breastfeeding an adult is something unheard of in any religion, but in Islam it’s a law from Allah.
For example: Salem was a slave owned by Abi Hudhayfa, Abu Hudhayfa freed him and adopted him. But Islam came and made adoption Haram.
Salem became a grown man, he was at home with Abu Hudhayfa’s wife « Sahla », Abu Hudhayfa started feeling uneasy about that. Sahla went to Muhammad and complained to him. Muhammad suggested that Sahla gives Salem her breast to suckle it ten times and that’s it, he will be considered her son. At first she said « but he is an adult » but Muhammad smiled and insisted! She went and did that. Abu Hudhayfa stopped been worried about Salem been at home with his wife after that!
Breastfeeding an adult by a lady makes him her son, and that way he can be around without a problem. This was a verse on the Quran, it used to be 10 suckles then it became just five, five times are the requirement for the breastfeeding to be accepted. These verses don’t exist in the Quran today, but the rule still valid among Muslim scholars.

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@Alphonso_Edward @Assimalhakeem If she did have an affair, like you say, why didn't Muhammad punish her for that? Why did he allow her to go back to her old husband (after having sex with her current husband followed by divorce)?

[Ockham Razor @OckhamRazor1]

@Alphonso_Edward @Assimalhakeem Also, if he is lying and does have a penile dysfunction, how would he have sex with her as per Muhammad's instructions? How will she get a divorce? Wouldn't she stay stuck in a sexless marriage with no possibility of having more kids? Isn't this an illogical ruling?