@JakeTurx Agreed.
But your phrasing sounds like you consider only the specific demographic of Yeshivish American Jews as "a Holy Nation."
It's not a Holy Nation making your claims. It's a select group within that Holy Nation.
@badgolfer99@JakeTurx שרות אזרחי
Do you know what that is?
It amazes me that all US jews who shout at the rooftops that they can't make Aliyah due to the spiritual perils of the IDF and the terrible secular government who won't accommodate them, haven't even bothered to do the most basic research.
@joenorton@ChalieStar613@JakeTurx To clarify - I don't mean to generalize.
I know not all American Jews are like this (I like to think I wasn't and I know much of my family isn't). But Jake specified the "unique needs, standards, and lifestyle" of US jews, and that's what I was responding to re the materialism.
@joenorton@ChalieStar613@JakeTurx I made Aliyah from the US and nearly all of my immediate and extended family is still there.
I'm quite familiar with the lifestyles of Orthodox Jewry in the NY/NJ area.
I don't doubt it's different in Oregon but I suspect Jake is referring to the standards of Jews in NY and NJ.
@joenorton@JakeTurx Of course it's unavoidable.
All immigrant cultures do and will trickle in and make Israel the wonderful melting pot that it is.
But we don't need to bend over backwards to accommodate a part of a culture that we find objectionable.
@DovieNeuburger My aunt was a destitute childless widow who never cried. One week, she had no money but managed to scrape together enough to buy Shabbos candles. When she lit them, a draft blew them out. With no matches, she began to cry, but then a tear hit the wick and it burst into flame.
@DovieNeuburger My brother was OTD and was an undefeated pool champion. One day, a man showed up at the pool hall and beat him at pool. Turns out it was his rebbe.
Now my brother is not only frum but a Rosh Yeshiva as well!
His yeshiva has a pool table and no one can can beat the Rosh Yeshiva.
@DovieNeuburger My aunt was a destitute childless widow who never cried. One week, she had no money but managed to scrape together enough to buy Shabbos candles. When she lit them, a draft blew them out. With no matches, she began to cry, but then a tear hit the wick and it burst into flame.
@DBashIdeas I didn't grow up with ivy league as a goal, nor did my parents spend extra on education.
Still, I relate to the overall message - we were raised to thrive, succeed and be comfortable in the wrong place.
But I do think his modox is showing, which will limit the letter's reach.
@bethanyshondark Maybe it's the demographic you know.
I'm an olah and I live in a city with a relatively small immigrant community. Most of the Olim here are came on their own, didn't come with significant wealth or savings, and they're doing just fine.