My posts address phonics, reading instruction and skills needed to read. Our website has resources, many free, and essays on various reading instruction topics.
Exciting news! The OnTrack Reading Phonics Program has been updated inside and out for a smoother teaching experience, with the same proven curriculum at its core.
And due to popular request, we've also added a licensed digital PDF. Lots more to come!
https://t.co/SkbNGb3LJf
@skipz Did a search of the article for the word "vision." Zero results.
OnTrack Reading's Position (as a provider of excellent phonics instruction):
Struggling readers who have had sufficient phonics instruction should have their vision skills evaluated by a developmental optometrist.
@plthomasEdD What I find weird about the study's findings is the claim that lockable pouches only reduced cell phone usage at school by 20%. What, did they give each kid a key? I don't get it. Maybe someone has an explanation?
And, if you learn WHY 7x8=56, you will also learn via the same explanation that 8x7 also = 56, and that the order doesn't matter (a 7x8 grid is also an 8x7 grid).
Yet, you will later learn that 4/5 is not the same as 5/4.
So, yes, the why, the understanding, is important. But the remembering part is the key to efficiency.
Teacher-led, explicit instruction of content-rich, cohesive curriculum is the most effective model for educating students. A true education also involves the formation of the whole person. This is why I am such a strong a proponent of classical education.
While the modern education establishment bounces around from one fad to another (often doing everything except what works) classical schools persist in the tried and true method of education.
The old saying “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” comes to mind.
@D_ovasabiTeacha And wouldn't it be nice if public schools had a place for such people? A place where their expertise could be both utilized and rewarded while letting them continue to work with their talents.
@CCguerilla@kovatutoring Some facts are indeed little baubles. Others are hard-earned, required deep thinking. Having done that deep thinking, it's useful to be able to instantly recall the conclusion. Doing so enables even deeper thinking.
I'm not sure why this is even debatable, to be honest.
Kane, the point is that it's important to memorize many things so that they can then be used efficiently in other tasks. Once you know what a 3/4/5 right triangle relationship is, looking a a triangle with sides 9 and 12 yields an immediate answer for the length of the hypotenuse.
A student might be able to derive the relationship a-squared plus b-squared equals c-squared and go from there, but that would be a horribly inefficient way to get the answer 15.
Additional learning builds on past learning. Isn't that obvious? And learning IS memorization.
Trauma creates memory for a reason. Our minds subconsciously "learn" so as to protect us the next time the situation arises.
@TheCharlesIsidi Smoke = S-m-o-k-magic-e
*sigh* Yet another unforeseen consequence of a silly method for teaching the split digraphs a-e, e-e, i-e, o-e, and u-e.
Imagine now, what would change about that picture if teacher pay was based on actual, measurable, results.
Imagine you could tell that new hire that they could be making the top of the salary scale in a few years if they proved to be one of the best teachers on staff, and that they would probably be looking for a job elsewhere if they proved to be ineffective at teaching.
Imagine you could tell them that if they proved able and willing to handle larger classes or tougher students efficiently that they would get significant pay bonuses.
Imagine you could tell them that their pay raises would no longer depend on picking up additional on-line college credits offering them little more than pabulum.
Would schools be better? Would teachers be happier? Would they want to work together more?
Back in the late 60's Playboy magazine printed a list of Top-Ten Party Colleges*. The U of Wisconsin-Madison wasn't listed.
At the bottom was another asterisk that explained: "This was an amateur ranking so the U of Wis wasn't included. Any school that serves beer in the student union is in the professional class."
(At that time, the drinking age in beer-only bars in Wisconsin was 18.)
Once the conversation changes from "what works" to "what values," it's a free-for-all. You'll never get agreement because values are all over the place. Look at the people who have put Luigi Mangione on a pedestal, an outright murderer, as an example.
If DI best prepares a child for higher-level math than inquiry/discovery methods, that's important to know, and to acknowledge, without obscuring it with "values."
I'm a lot more worried that kids' minds are being permanently altered by constant attention to their phones and their associated algorithms than I am that the way we teach them math or reading is going to permanently damage their psyches in some yet-to-be-determined way.
I can shed some light on this from personal experience, Ene. In grade school I was always ahead in math. In fifth grade, my teacher would drop a single sheet with several math challenges on it on my desk. It was from some outside source and she had no clue how to do the math on them.
The problem was that they were TOO challenging. I'd work at them, but wasn't able to solve them. I got nothing out of them as a result and didn't spend much time on them eventually.
But had they been at the right level, where I could figure out the challenge, I'd have done them all day long.
And application is also key. In eighth grade, my teacher just told me to move ahead in math. I was done with the book, a full year's course by Christmas. Back then, algebra, geometry, etc., were delayed until high school, so it was mostly fractions, decimals, and percentages (pretty easy stuff).
But we had a baseball nut in the class. He would calculate the batting average of every kid who played ball at recess. Batting averages are just converting hits and times at the plate into fractions and then turning those into three digit percentages. But there were exceptions, like a sacrifice fly not counting as an at-bat attempt.
I didn't know the exceptions, but he knew all of them. In a sense, he was ahead of me in math because he knew what I had learned, but he was using it. And he had probably been using it since well before Christmas, possibly even well before 8th grade. So, application and relevance really matters too.
@liweimao Looking at the math scores of the "Education" and "English Language & Literature" categories, those would appear to be the last people we should seek guidance from on math curricula.
@Brian_Peotter We've been telling kids in school since the 1980's that the world is going to end soon due to global warming. Maybe that explains the upswing in people waiting longer to get married? Anyway, it's pretty dramatic after falling slightly for a hundred years.
@matthew_a_bell@preshtalwalkar Nice answer, but with an unneeded step. Put down the 3L container after step 6, fill the 7 liter full and pour two of it into the 20 liter to fill it up. Leaves 5 liters.