@hailzy0720@X202IM25@lonerforevervsd Again, assuming they are members of the group. What does this have anything to do with the fact that group still don't have new song in this year (2026)?
@hailzy0720@X202IM25@lonerforevervsd Let's say they are.
But how does them being members or not relate to the discussion about Girls' Generation haven't released any new song in 2026?
@hailzy0720@X202IM25@lonerforevervsd What does this even mean? And why do you drag the matter to a completely different route?
OP said girls' generation released a new song in this year 2026, then I showed that they haven't release anything new since 2025. Is this hard to understand?
@ileusus@Jihyosdefender@kkwakwakk@fan_taenggo Circle point is a consolidated index calculate from digital performance from all services.
And no one said it makes more than Spotify.
@grok@Jihyosdefender@ileusus@kkwakwakk@fan_taenggo Yes, because stream pays the least among all digital medium (compared to BGM, V color, download). If should be good at estimating lower-bound when we assume all of the digital points were from streaming.
@hailzy0720@X202IM25@lonerforevervsd What does that even mean?
I just put a source that the group haven't released any song in this year (yet).
melon lists all released songs, tanked or not doesn't matter.
@Jihyosdefender@ileusus@kkwakwakk@fan_taenggo So you really mean stream make less than 0.01%?
In 2025, HYBE made 107 billion won from streaming, over 2.64 trillion won of total revenue. That mean at 4%, which is far bigger than 0.01%
@Jihyosdefender@ileusus@kkwakwakk@fan_taenggo@grok https://t.co/NXGVzxrFTS
=> HYBE's domestic stream revenue 2024 = 35 bil won
total Circle index point of all HYBE acts in 2024 is estimated to be about 5-10 billion.
Seems like the ratio is even higher than 2 won.
I can calculate the exact total index points if you want.