@silverocean03@JS_StrngstSldr Yeah….zero evidence he ever did that. Try again. Pretty embarrassing to speak so confidently about a topic you are clearly ignorant of.
@70x7again@dttpeople I guess you just don’t know what a mission call is. It’s not a prophecy. Calling this a prophecy is absurd but critics of our faith usually use bad-faith tactics so what’s new.
This is still a mission call. “Thus saith the Lord” does not turn every instruction into a date-stamped forecast. The text says it is wisdom that he settle his affairs so he may serve next spring. He was shot and killed first.
God does not cancel human agency to keep a timetable. We’ve already established the standard: God can speak, then events change, and that is not a failed prophecy. You used that for Isaiah, Samuel, Micah, and Ahab. Same rule here.
@70x7again@dttpeople Try again. This wasn’t a prophecy, this is a mission call. I’ve had one of these and if I died before a began my service it wouldn’t make it a failed prophecy. Laughable.
So the point stands. A word can be spoken and not happen as first stated, and the speaker is still a prophet. You just explained every example that way: God revised it, God changed the pronouncement, people repented.
That is not a black-and-white Deut 18 interpretation you have given. You admitted the nuance.
Now apply the same rule. Tell me, under that standard, how Joseph is a false prophet.
To be clear:
I took your black-and-white reading of Deut 18 and showed from the Bible that it is not that simple. You don’t get to call a man a false prophet just because a spoken word did not happen as first stated.
I’m happy to give more examples. You will add conditions and explanations. Fine. Whatever standard you use for those prophets, you have to allow for Joseph Smith. If you don’t, you’re a hypocrite.
Examples:
Isa 38:1–5 — Hezekiah told he will die and not live. Then 15 years added.
1 Sam 2:30 — “Your house would walk before me forever.” Then: “Be it far from me.”
Micah 3:12 + Jer 26:18–19 — Micah said Zion would be plowed as a field. Later Scripture says Hezekiah feared the Lord and “the Lord relented of the disaster that he had pronounced against them.” Did not happen as spoken.
1 Kgs 21:21–29 — Disaster announced on Ahab in his days. Then delayed because he humbled himself.
All of these show that a prophesy is given and yet doesn’t come to pass because of the behavior of the people. This can also work both ways. You can prophesy good things to happen but because of the wickedness of the people it doesn’t happen. You have to treat all prophesy in this way.
I’m literally just engaging with what the text says. You have not given an explanation other than contradict Deut 18 with Jeremiah 18. You showed that prophecy is conditional even when the prophet does not state the condition.
So therefore Deut 18 is not black and white if a prophecy doesn’t happen as stated you kill the prophet. Apparently there’s much more nuance there that you were not taking into account
You are proving my entire point.
You just used Jeremiah 18 it to admit judgment oracles are conditional even when the preacher does not say “if.”
Then you cannot run Deut 18:22 as “it didn’t happen, therefore false prophet.” Jonah’s word did not happen as stated. He was still a prophet. You cited the reason.
Pick one test. You don’t get a standing condition in Jeremiah and a zero-condition death statute in Deuteronomy
Of course not.
I’m not saying you need to believe just as the ancient Israelites did.
What you wouldn’t do is take scriptures like your example of the dome over the earth and say it actually didn’t mean that and it was actually teaching something different that fits your presuppositions.
You just have to be honest about what these ancient texts are saying and you shouldn’t twist them to change their meaning
@70x7again@dttpeople Show me where in Jonah’s prophesy he gave any conditionality
4 And Jonah began to enter into the city a day’s journey, and he cried, and said, Yet forty days, and Nineveh shall be overthrown.
No but it mattered if you want to read the scriptures in their proper context and meaning.
I quoted above many scholars including Michael Heiser who you seem to like that agrees with my understanding of what these passages meant.
Go read actual scholarship on these Isaiah chapters and try and remove your bias.
@70x7again@dttpeople No kidding, I’m aware.
He prophesied they will be destroyed in 40 days and it didn’t happen. And in the next chapter he was upset it didn’t happen.
According to the Bible his prophecy was false