@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 I see that it’s hard for you to come outright and say — because deep down you know it’s false…
The text doesn’t say that a person looses their free will and are made to desire Christ. There are many Scriptures that speak against this including Matt 22:1-14.
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 Everyone is perishing prior to hearing the gospel. Therefore it does convert those who are perishing as long as they accept it. For those who reject the gospel, it becomes a power that exposes, judges, and hardens (John 3:19-21, Isaiah 6:9-10/Matt 13:14-15, John 12:47-48).
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 The gospel is the POWER — it’s the instrument that GOD utilizes to build faith in a person and cause them to believe (Rom 10:17). GOD uses the message of the cross as the necessary instrument to spark and build that belief and then we are born again by the Word (1 Peter 1:23).
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 Exactly! The Word of Truth is the gospel. And the gospel is the power of GOD for salvation for all who would BELIEVE (Rom 1:16).
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 A seed is not just a witness to a plant's birth, the seed causes the birth. Peter explicitly states we are born again through the Word. If regeneration happened independently or prior to the Word's effect, Peter would have said we are born again by the Spirit alongside the Word.
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 You seem to treat the gospel like a coincidence. But Scripture speaks of it very differently.
1 Peter 1:23: "Since you have been born again, not of perishable seed but of imperishable, through the living and abiding word of God."
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 The primary way GOD draws people to Him through the gospel (Rom 10:13-17). We see that faith comes by hearing the word of Christ (gospel), not regeneration. We see this all throughout Scripture. Including John 6:44-45. When Jesus say “everyone who has heard and learned….”
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 John 7:37-38: "If anyone thirsts, let him come to me and drink. Whoever believes in me... Out of his heart will flow rivers of living water." The living water (the Holy Spirit/regeneration) follows the coming and believing.
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 This belief is contradictory to John’s other writings. John 3:36: "Whoever believes in the Son has eternal life; whoever does not obey the Son shall not see life..." If a person must be regenerated to believe, they would technically "have life" before they actually believed.
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 John says; look at anyone who truly believes Jesus is the Messiah. That faith proves they are a genuine child of GOD. If they don't believe that, they aren't born of GOD. The focus is on identifying who is saved, not charting the chronological order of how it happened.
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 John is writing to a church dealing with false teachers who claimed to be born of GOD but denied that Jesus was the Christ. John uses 1 John 5:1 to draw a line in the sand.
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 I understand this is your position but I don’t agree that is what the text says. It’s not an order of salvation rather it describes a current state that matches a past reality. If someone has faith then you know they have been born of GOD.
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 I agree but I don’t agree that John’s purpose is to provide the order of salvation, rather he is providing the evidence that one is saved. Based on the grammar — If being Born of GOD causes Righteousness (in 2:29), then being Born of GOD must cause faith (in 5:1).
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 Again, if you use the grammar of 1 John 5:1 to say regeneration causes faith, you must apply that same structural rule to the parallel verses. Doing so creates theological contradictions.
@ymmotrojam@jerry_duck48985@Soteriology101 Exactly, John did not write a systematic theology chart on how to get saved. He wrote these epistles to help believers know if they are saved. Therefore John is not giving us the order of how to be saved, rather the evidence that one is saved.