disappointing but not unexpected, Solana users should pay attention
certain Solana "stakeholders" have the incentive to "make" money by diluting SOL holders via printing tokens
it is of course a false argument and contradicts itself:
i) the model assumes away the entire question
he fixes solana’s market cap at $100, shows that issuance transfers ownership from non-stakers to stakers and then concludes that more issuance makes stakers richer
but fixing market cap assumes that issuance has zero effect on SOL’s aggregate valuation -- the exact question being debated
you cannot prove that higher issuance maximizes wealth by assuming away its possible effect on wealth
and “non-stakers don’t lose value; they transfer it” is semantics. in his own example, their holdings fall from $40 to $38.10. a clear loss.
he later says crypto prices are driven by speculation and narrative, making the contradiction even clearer: it freezes valuation when defending issuance, then invokes variable valuation when dismissing lower issuance
“inflation declined while price declined” is not a counterfactual either. price could simply have declined even more under higher issuance.
if the arguments here were true, then the rational thing would be to put Solana at 100% inflation lol
ii) even granting every assumption, his universal conclusion is mathematically false!
using SGP-0002’s official supply paths and its 68% staking assumption --and generously assuming that the same original staked cohort captures every additional emitted SOL, that cohort ends with:
- 72.395% of supply under the current curve
- 71.659% under double disinflation
that is only a 1.03% relative ownership advantage from preserving the current curve
thus, if avoiding 18.9 million additional SOL improves Solana’s aggregate valuation by more than roughly 1.03% over six years, voting yes makes even that staked cohort wealthier!
his claim that every rational staker must vote no is therefore mathematically incoherent
a "rational" staker doesn't maximize the number of tokens but what those tokens are worth. if you disagree, feel free to move to venezuela
iii) his definition of a “rational stakeholder” is backwards and we shouldn't rake users
Solana is not secured so stake accounts can earn emissions
stake accounts are compensated so that a useful network can be secured
SOL actively used for transactions, payments, collateral, liquidity, trading inventory and protocol operations cannot simultaneously be native-staked
LSTs somewhat mitigate this trade-off, but they do not erase it: they are not universally interchangeable with native SOL and introduce additional integration and liquidity risks
these users generate the transactions, fees, MEV and demand that make SOL -- and therefore its stake -- valuable in the first place
without them, there is nothing economically valuable left to secure. so how is taking advantage of them rational?
stakers themselves also benefit from security because it protects the value of their stake. they are not external contractors providing a service exclusively to non-stakers
iv) the “no leaky bucket” section is factually wrong under current US tax rules
under current IRS guidance, cash-method US taxpayers include staking rewards in gross income at FMV when they gain dominion and control
the IRS does not subtract the portion of those rewards that merely compensates the holder for dilution
higher nominal issuance can therefore produce a larger tax liability even when much of the apparent “income” is only maintaining the staker’s ownership share
v) SGP-0003 is complementary, not an alternative
burning a new resource fee paid by users does not answer whether the protocol should also issue 18.9 million additional SOL to subsidize stakers
in fact, “increase genuine fee revenue and reduce unnecessary issuance” is precisely the coherent position
vi) SIMD-123 does not increase Solana’s network revenue lol, it allows validators to share existing block revenue with delegators, it changes the distribution of the numerator rather than increasing it
so many completely incorrect claims
vii) finally, both inflation schedules end at the exact same 1.5% terminal rate anyway!
if 1.5% inflation is ultimately insufficient to secure Solana, then the current schedule eventually reaches the exact same supposedly insufficient endpoint. the argument against SGP-0002 would therefore have to be about the transition speed, not some need to preserve higher inflation to earn more tax
some validators may rationally prefer a few more years of commission income. they are free to make that short-term argument.
but dressing a preference for extracting more value from users as economic rationality is not only unserious it is mathematically and logically incoherent
a rational staker maximizes wealth not token count. and a rational stakeholder maximizes long-term value and the activity of the network it secures not the amount to tax its users
vote yes on speeding up disinflation and let's bring Solana back
For the first time in 123 years, Argentina has achieved a sustained fiscal surplus without being in default. We are one of only 5 countries in the world in this position.
LONG LIVE FREEDOM, DAMN IT...!!!
Trump correctly pointed out that our nation was its richest in the 1880s and 1890s, but he is incorrect to attribute that wealth to tariffs. The reason we were so rich back then is that government was so tiny that we could afford to pay for it with tariffs. Back then, total federal spending was only about 2% of GDP. Today it’s over 23%.
I'm with the president: let's eliminate 90% of the Federal Government, so we could pay for what's left with tariffs. Let's also eliminate the the Federal Reserve and go back to a gold standard, just like the 1890s. Let's get rid of income and Social Security taxes. Let's eliminate all the government departments created since 1890, like Commerce, Labor, Health, Education, Housing, Transportation, Energy, and Education.
Let's get rid of the government agencies that didn't exist back then, like the SEC, FDIC, NCUA, CFTC, CFPB, FCC, EPA, OSHA, PBGC, FBI, CIA, TSA, and FEMA. If we repeal Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, ACA, Unemployment Insurance, SNAP, Welfare, Student loans, FHA/VA loans, SBA programs, and farm supports, to name a few.
We should also repeal almost every federal law that has been passed since 1900. If we do all of that, then we can have tariffs and be rich again like we were in the 1880s and 1890s.