@Msuddgu@ShtLnd_ They're only debatable when you want to defend Luxembourg, because she doesn't come out looking good.
Like bro, she was a communist. Vanguardist (yes, look it up). Anti-democratic by definition.
@Msuddgu@ShtLnd_ What do you mean "She wasn’t specifically anti democratic strictly". She attempted a coup against the democratically elected government, buddy. Just because she didn't like the results.
@Sarsath21@ShtLnd_ With communist popularity being what it was, they wouldn't last a year before someone else couped them in turn. Don't kid yourself.
Also there is no world in which USSR thrives. Planned economy just straight up doesn't work, and Bolsheviks would never give up on that.
@gerald126089@SrcstgsmThought So you refuse to acknowledge what was not spelled out word for word (if it's inconvenient) and you have your own private definitions of commonly understood concepts that you insist others to play by?
Welcome back, Dr. Jordan Peterson. You can fuck right off.
@lngenius_@LinkofSunshine I'm saying that "it compiles" is not good enough proof that the proof is indeed correct. There might be some exploit. Small chance, but not 0.
See, in Maths all is either 1 or 0. Even 99.999% is not good enough. But since 250k pages is unreadable, we probably won't ever know.
@lngenius_@LinkofSunshine I don't dispute that it runs. Hell, I don't even dispute the formalism really is the RH.
I dispute that you still don't know whether it is an exploit (AIs sometimes do those). If there is 1% chance that it's an exploit, it's not good enough proof. That's how math works.
@anonmchik@ZachWeiner No idea what academic tradition you're from, but in the one that I know, trustworthy academics don't advertise generational breakthroughs in a "trust me bro" blogposts.
@LinkofSunshine That still falls under "wrote a blog post". Until he publishes.
The concern is ofc that even if there is a lean proof, does it actually correspond to Riemann hypothesis? There is some controversy about that for the Navier Stokes, and AFAIK the jury is still out on that one.
@gerald126089@SrcstgsmThought No idea what you're trying to do here.
I'm saying that Gorbachev did what he did by trying to salvage a terrible economic situation (so mostly peoples history), while OP says USSR was doing fine (which, lol) and Gorbachev personally fucked it up for no reason (so 100% Great Men)
@brainiac3397@przidnt1 Do you genuinely think he did Perestroika just for shits and giggles?
Lol no, USSR was in economic free fall, so he tried a hail Mary. Ofc it didn't work, since the real solution was always "don't plan the economy". But USSR giving that up was as likely as Nazis being ok w/ Jews