@wand3ringst4r@hairball1952 I’m snorting coke I bought from a Dominican through a twenty dollar bill in a nightclub bathroom. Hygiene isn’t a concern here friend
@xgwakex@EdLawDude@mike_frags No , I have my AI running on every federal judge now and times they have had to interpret a different states laws please don’t give in now
@xgwakex@EdLawDude@mike_frags All judges are expected to be able to, because it’s part of the job role. There is no judgeship in the US that limits its role to interpreting laws of jx in which the judge previously practiced
@xgwakex@EdLawDude@mike_frags Here’s the Texas Supreme Court applying New York State law
Exxon Mobil Corp. v. Drennen, 452 S.W.3d 319 (Tex. 2014).
Any federal judge (or state judge) that practices long enough is going to end up with a case where anothern jx’s law applies. It’s ordinary
@xgwakex@EdLawDude@mike_frags I mean here’s a Rhodes island court applying Italian law Alifax Holding SpA v. Alcor Scientific Inc., 357 F. Supp. 3d 147 (D.R.I. 2019).
Choice of forum and choice of law are distinct, and I can sign a contract enforceable in Texas that specifies Ethiopian law applies
@LoewyLawFirm But this cuts against needing a federal judge that knows a specific state law. Fed judges regularly have to interpret law from many states (and international jurisdictions) in which they have never practiced
@EdLawDude@xgwakex@mike_frags This undercuts your point but your not smart enough to realize it.
Federal judges have to interpret law of states (and intl jurisdiction) they never practiced in. All judges do this. It’s part of the job.
@SombreMagus@NimerSultany@CIJ_ICJ The talking point exists because the UN fact finding report said Israel has inflicted as much damage as it physically could in Gaza, which is crazy to even suggest
@EdLawDude A federal judge in texas may have to interpret Delaware law or Washington law or even Egyptian law. It’s part of the job and they are all expected to do it.
@long4myqueen@TomMarsLaw Yes in theory, but when you issue an illegal first order , then anything punitive that follows certainly has the appearance sanction for failure to follow that. Especially if you phrase it like the OP said (“well since I can’t make you apologize I’ll just disqualify you”)
@deenracsmany This is extraordinarily well recognized in American jurisprudence but for some reason foreign lawyers struggle with it. I wonder if it’s a civil code vs common law distinction
@deenracsmany There is no difference between “the law” and “its interpretation” by the highest court. If the court changes its interpretation, it is changing the way the law applies, in the same way that a treaty would.
@AeyalGross@AdHaque110 When courts have limited jurisdiction, their role is limited to the question in front of them. If they find no genocidal intent they should not comment further. They were not tasked with determining whether there had been atrocities or making statements for headlines