The Misery of Job and the Mercy of God - by @JohnPiper. Illustration by @chriskoelle
"Oh, God, I cling with feeble fingers to the ledge of Your great grace."
Your entire argument hinges on you saying:
"The Bible states life begins at first breath"
Which is false.
The Bible never says that image-bearers in the womb are without human life before birth, or that their biological life starts only when they take their first breath of oxygen after being born.
"Where did I claim Elihu was teaching Job when life begins?"
In your response to me:
"when Elihu says "The breath of the Almighty gives me life”, he is not referring to or pinpointing when human life begins" - Me
"Your interpretation doesnt invalidate mine. Biblical passages can have multiple interpretations." - You
@yo_zaba_daba@fakedangill@ScottAaron2@JoshuaBarzon So, according to you, Elihu is telling JOB the point at which we become living humans?
What would be the reason for this in the context of their argument?
In Job 33:4, when Elihu says "The breath of the Almighty gives me life”, he is not referring to or pinpointing when human life begins, he is declaring his faith in God's majesty and sovereignty and acknowledging that God is the source of his existence. He is stating the only reason he is alive is because of God's grace and strength.
https://t.co/ZmmWCT0RKy
Elihu states that "the breath of the Almighty" provides him with the knowledge, insight, and understanding necessary to speak and correct Job, who is his elder. This can be seen in Job 32:8 when Elihu tells Job, "The breath of the Almighty that makes for understanding"
https://t.co/BGxiOFwEuX
The debate that Elihu had with Job, Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar had nothing to do with the biological requirements of how humans are formed in the womb, nor does it set a biological line of demarcation for people to claim that humans in the womb are not alive.
Job 32 - 33 (in full for context)
https://t.co/Ccve67rpJp
@CantBeSilenced8@BB4MAGA@LifeNewsHQ@taylorswift13 The Sotah Ritual had nothing to do with abortion.
Abortifacients, forced miscarriage, or the targeted death of a mamzer fetus were not included in this ritual.
In Job 33:4, when Elihu says "The breath of the Almighty gives me life”, he is not referring to or pinpointing when human life begins, he is declaring his faith in God's majesty and sovereignty and acknowledging that God is the source of his existence. He is stating the only reason he is alive is because of God's grace and strength.
https://t.co/ZmmWCT0RKy
Elihu states that "the breath of the Almighty" provides him with the knowledge, insight, and understanding necessary to speak and correct Job, who is his elder. This can be seen in Job 32:8 when Elihu tells Job, "The breath of the Almighty that makes for understanding"
https://t.co/BGxiOFwEuX
The debate that Elihu had with Job, Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar had nothing to do with the biological requirements of how humans are formed in the womb, nor does it set a biological line of demarcation for people to claim that humans in the womb are not alive.
Job 32 - 33 (in full for context)
https://t.co/Ccve67rpJp
Sanhedrin 57b.5, the death penalty is explicitly applied to Gentiles for the slaying of a fetus, with this judgment presented as an unchallenged view in the Talmud, lacking any documented dissent.
"A descendant of Noah is executed for killing fetuses… It is derived from that which is written: ‘One who sheds the blood of a person, by a person his blood shall be shed’ (Genesis 9:6). What is a person that is in a person? You must say: This is a fetus that is in its mother’s womb” - Sanhedrin 57b.5
https://t.co/NO8BIZvgJV
According to Sanhedrin 57b, the method of execution prescribed for a Noachide convicted of killing of a fetus is death by strangulation.
“In a person, his blood shall be shed.” In what manner is a person’s blood shed while it is still inside the person’s body, without visible external bleeding? You must say that this is strangulation. It is therefore derived that the execution of a descendant of Noah is by strangulation. - Sanhedrin 57b:6
https://t.co/Akm8AjOqt0
Also, First Century Jewish Law states that a woman who aborts her child is a “Murderer of her child, by destroying a living creature”
https://t.co/ui1lV71Khc
"Exod 21:22–23: Miscarriage = fine; mother’s death = "life for life.""
Exodus 21:22-25 addresses unintentional but reckless harm, not premeditated murder.
Therefore, even in the case of the mother’s injury or death, lex talionis converts to proportional monetary compensation for each level of unintended injury, rather than exact duplicate physical harm, execution, or exile.
So a financial penalty applies whether the death is of the mother or of her child.
According to the Sanhedrin in Jewish Law, the concept of “life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot, burn for burn, bruise for bruise, wound for wound” is interpreted as requiring proportional monetary compensation for each level of unintended injury.
Mosaic Law never imposed the death penalty for unintentional acts that resulted in death.
"Ezek 37:9–10: "Formed bodies have no life until breath enters.""
Ezekiel 37:5-9 doesn’t address when our human lives begin. It is a prophecy in which God instructs the prophet Ezekiel to prophesy to a valley of dried human bones, symbolizing the restoration of the nation of Israel.
“Thus says the Lord God to these bones: I will cause breath to enter you, and you shall live. I will lay sinews on you, and will cause flesh to come upon you, and cover you with skin, and put breath in you, and you shall live; and you shall know that I am the Lord.” - Ezekiel 37:5-6
Full Chapter
https://t.co/znp7RDplET