That’s a category error. Time isn’t a pre-existing container God is constrainted to—time is a measure of physical change, which began with creation.
A necessary uncaused First Cause is Pure Act with zero unactualized potential, God doesn't need a ticking clock to "transition" into creating. As an eternal Cause, God can freely will a temporal universe that begins at t=0 without needing time to do it.
@Midgard_Walker 20% of physicists from the survey you posted disagree with your statement here.
Even if I concede on the singularity, that doesn't affirm an eternal universe because of the BGV theorem obstacle.
You're merely moving the goalposts not proving a non-first cause eternal universe.
@Midgard_Walker Nice Tu quoque fallacy, where have I appealed to majority?
You're not doing very well to demonstrate a case for an eternal universe that doesn't need a first cause.
@autocorrect2_0@IMBillyGee@Alex_Ortodoxie You could still face disciplinary action even if you unintentionally do it.
I'm not out here trying to assassinate his character. I'm evaluating the evidence and cannot see how at minimum 2 of his academic works are not intentional/willful plagerism.
@autocorrect2_0@IMBillyGee@Alex_Ortodoxie Let's remove Wes from the equation and focus on my point:
Even if it's a small inconsequential assignment.
Whether intentionally or unintentionally, is taking credit for someone else's work by passing it off as your own without proper academic citations wrong?
@WKCosmo@DrCarlMortner So when you said: "Or, 2 is false" you meant to say "Or, we don't know if 2 is true"?
You should really be more careful if you aren't making assertions and then retreating when pressed to support them!
More ad hominems and now an appeal to majority fallacy!
Just because 68% of physicists believe the singularity (hot dense state) may or may not correspond to the beginning of time doesn't demonstrate your claim for an eternal universe.
In fact they're refusing to make a claim at all, since their response includes both "may or may not", you cannot take this and go "see physicists assert an eternally existing universe". You've misunderstood the data you're presenting.
I never said eternal had anything to do with space. I defined it as transcendent of time. Time begins to break down when we approach planck time with our observation of the Big Bang.
If the singularity existed for an infinite past, which you are proposing, there is still a necessary cause for it to change states. How time and laws of physics operate within the singularity is also problematic and unprovable for you.
I might be mistaken, but I always understood that the singularly has no space within the general relativity model.
What prevents theists from asserting that the singularly physicists propose is God's nature? From whom all things were made...
@autocorrect2_0@IMBillyGee@Alex_Ortodoxie Are you claiming that God would be okay with you passing off someone else's work as your own to gain academic and societal standing?
1) I never called God a "creature" so you are not quoting me.
2) Christianity does show the world was created perfectly good where free will and zero evil was the default.
Evil is not a "created thing" it is the abuse or absence of good. Just like cold is the absence of heat. This is a bit oversimplified so try not to get overly hung up on this point.
Sin is the mechanism that introduces "evil" into our world. The temporal separation our mortal bodies are confined to introduces us to suffering and the natural effects that allows for physical death.
3) You bring in a strawman argument to claim I said something I didn't.
God's nature is perfectly (or maximally) good, which makes Him the standard of good. Basically, God is the 100% grade for a test. He can never be less than 100%-pure act. Humans on the other hand can be less than 100% (potency), less than 100% in terms of good is what we call sin/evil.
That's why you're make a category error.
4) The concept of good and evil doesn't accurately represent what Christianity teaches. God is Holy and righteous, we fail those standards. Which is why we are clothed by Jesus' (God's) holiness and righteousness while we are in heaven. It's not by our will that we are perfected but God's mercy and grace through Christ that we become new perfect creations.
No. My concern has been with you downplaying plagerism as "not a real sin".
I do not recall saying anything about condemning him other than we do have enough facts that he has plagerized a portion of his work. Which he's admitted to and we ought to maintain holding him accountable to, repent from, and accept the consequences of his actions.
If I have said anything false about the evidence, his character, or our conversation please show me?
If you disagree that passing off others work as your own in academic pursuits, even unintentionally, is not equivalent to lying please show me where I am wrong?
@autocorrect2_0@IMBillyGee@Alex_Ortodoxie Yes, I understand innocent until proven guilty. But the evidence does not appear to favor him.
Are you accusing me of bearing false witness or gossip?
@shekenahglory@antitheistdad It's actually demonstrated by Satan that creatures can "sin" or rebel in eternity.
But everyone who remains in heaven does not want to sin and consistently chooses not to.
Lying is a sin, correct?
Plagiarism, whether intentional or unintentional, is presenting someone else's work as your own. That is, by definition, lying.
Would you show the same mercy and grace and defend someone who is lying about being a veteran? Your objection to stolen valor will tell you all you need to know about why plagiarism is also wrong.
Those are some quite extraordinary claims you have not made. Do you have extraordinary evidence to prove them?
The Big Bang literally says that our universe had a finite past - the beginning of time and space. Eternity transcends the existence of time; it is not "temporally infinite".
Resorting to ad hominem attacks just shows you have no real argument, just strong feelings and opinions against Christianity.
When you were arguing that pLaiGairiSm was not a sin, you were not doing what you say now.
I 100% agree that people who are looking for a pound of flesh from Wes need to be held accountable and repent as well, but that doesn't change Wes' actions as being wrong-or problematically defending his actions as "oopsie daisy".
A laugh emoji doesn't refute the logic.
You're question now is like asking asking, what’s north of the North Pole. Not to mention confusing links (contingent) with the ceiling (necessary anchor point).
Big Bang cosmology and the laws of thermodynamics show our universe is a finite chain, not an eternal ceiling. Which points directly to a necessary, transcendent first cause.
Yes, because plagiarism is defined as a false claim of authorship. Which is why I categorized it as lying/fraud. You've argued to minimize this truth and excuse his behavior rather than stand for accountability and repentance.
What other people say on twitter doesn't justify Wes' wrong actions do they?
You'll find my interaction with you has been my only comments to date on this issue.
Bringing in what "all of twitter" says and attributing it to me and what I've said isn't helpful.
You were originally arguing that what Wes did was not Biblically a sin, correct?
I hope I've challenged that thought and expressed what we as brothers and sisters in Christ ought to do in response. With Wes, we should give him gentle correction (accountability and call to repentance) and grace.
We cannot ignore the plank in Wes' eye by pointing out the spec in "all of twitters" eye, can we?