Here's the explanation of our judge call. To have full context you kinda have to watch the first hour of Sam's vod where Evan explains his experience. I was already aware of that context at the time of the judge call.
Vod:
https://t.co/ppp2oz38YN
While harsh I literally do not care about this and I don't think Riot should give it significant weight either
The #1 priority of the Riftbound team should be creating GOOD GAMEPLAY. This banlist is a big positive step in that direction. If you don't like that, leave!!!
Templar finally getting DQ’d in round 10 is bittersweet. I’m glad something was finally done but it sucks that 8 people, myself included, had to lose to him before that happened.
Losing to him round 1, knowing he was intentionally slow playing, asking him to play faster and having a judge sit there and watch him continue to take 2-4 min turns without doing anything felt like watching someone rob me in broad daylight while the people who were supposed to stop it just stood there.
I put so much time and effort into preparing for this event. It was supposed to be one of the most exciting tournaments of the year and instead I just feel robbed of that experience and don’t have good memories of this event. I feel stolen from. I’m glad he got DQ’d, but that doesn’t give any of us our matches back.
I just hope this leads to some changes because no one should have to go through this. Especially at this level of competition. #RCStuttgart
Sadly lost in quarter final, i think i have done some missplays but don’t think i could have win with those hands, my opponent played really well.
I will win worlds 🫡
As someone at Stuttgart who day 2ed with a record of 4-2, anyone who didnt is actually a skill issue. I won dice 4 times and if they couldn't that just means they didnt want it enough.
Sorry guys but Alan prismat rosum squirtle they're all washed.
I broke my phone celebrating top8 but i finally found a way.
Can’t describe the émotions I’m feeling Thanks everyone who cheer for me, world was a dream that is now real, job’s not done yet, tomorrow kennen cook those broken blade #RCStuttgart
First time i finish day one undeafeated, sad i had to play vs friend and team mate last round, i'm playing well, kennen is good, nocturne is a cool guy and my opponents were also, ton of fun despite the riven meta
This is frankly a ridiculous set of outcomes and I hope for the sake of the competitors this gets better. Selfishly I really want this to be fixed before Vegas tbh
This is a very long post and vent about #RCStuttgart.
Tournament starts, I’m nervous but also excited. Though I do wish I had played Jayce for event. Anyway, round one I get paired against Jayce and I’m on kaisa. During game one, I feel like my opponent is taking a really long time on his turns. I start watching the clock and confirm he’s taking around 2 to 4 minutes per turn. I ask him to please play faster.
Another 3 or so minutes go by and nothing changes, so I call a judge over and ask if he can watch the pace of play. He says he can.
I’m still watching the clock during my opponent’s turns and he’s continuing to take 2 to 4 minutes. I look over at the judge and make a hand gesture like “what’s going on?” He assures me he’s watching and then walks around the table and sits beside my opponent.
During game one, the judge tells my opponent on two separate occasions to make a play. I assume these are warnings.
Eventually my opponent gets to 5 points and has the Garbage Grabber recycle Dragons setup. I concede with around 5 minutes left on the clock to try and get another game in. We also have about a 13 minute time extension.
Game two starts and my opponent is still playing slowly. The judge tells him to make a play, and he tanks for another minute before finally doing so.
Another 10 minutes go by and our extra time is almost up. The judge tells my opponent to make a play for the FOURTH time.
At this point I’m getting really upset because I’m having to play my own turns in 30 seconds to a minute just to have a chance at finishing the game.
I see a red shirt judge (head judge) and ask if I can speak with him away from the table. The blue shirt judge follows us.
I explain what’s been happening and even confirm with the blue shirt judge that my opponent has been taking 2 to 4 minute turns and has been told to make a play four different times.
I ask the head judge, isn’t this a PRO REL event? Aren’t the rules for this supposed to be more strict?
He confirms that it is and explains that a third warning for the same infraction results in a game loss.
Then the blue shirt judge says he hasn’t actually issued my opponent any warnings. He’s just been telling him to play faster.
I’m genuinely upset at this point because I feel like I’m being robbed of my tournament.
I ask how someone can take 2 to 4 minutes per turn, be told to make a play FOUR separate times, and somehow not receive a single warning?
They tell me they’ll discuss it and ask me to return to the table.
I go back, and the blue shirt judge eventually comes over and issues my opponent a warning.
We end up going to turns and I lose the match, even though I’ve banished two of his Dragons and feel like I’m very likely to win that game if we have enough time.
I’m honestly just sad and upset. I explain to the head judge how I feel like I’ve been robbed of a match at the biggest event of the year.
To his credit, the head judge was great. He listened to my frustration, understood where I was coming from, and explained that there wasn’t really anything he could do at that point but he would talk to other judges about this.
He let me take a walk to try and cool off and gave me a time extension for my next round.
Unfortunately, even after walking around, I’m still pretty upset. I play poorly in round two and lose.
Whatever. On to round three.
Round three is a super close match, but a great one.
Then round four comes around and I’m playing against Riven.
My opponent wins game one. Game two comes down to him needing to ready with Astral Heron at base to win.
I cast Piercing Light, dealing 4 damage to my own unit and 4 to his Heron. It resolves.
I then cast Decree of Rage to deal another 4 damage to Heron. He responds with Decree of Focus to give it +4 Might.
I cast Thousand Tailed Watcher and point at his Heron.
He tells me it survives at 1.
Now, this part is my fault. For whatever reason, I thought green Decree gave +5 Might like blue Decree/Punch. 1/3
This is as much for myself as it is for everyone else playing today. This is the biggest event I’ve ever played in when it comes to how much money is on the line. I know a lot of us have put a ton of hours into prepping for this event. You’re playing against some of the best players in the world, yourself included. We all earned our spot, be proud of that.
Try not to tie your self worth to your results. I know that’s easier said than done. Sometimes you’ll get bad hands, bad matchups, or maybe it’s just not your day. That’s a part of TCGs.
Just play the best you can with what you’re given.
Good luck today ❤️
#RCStuttgart
Ok team long Riven lost because not enough Riven posting
Many people ask me why I am so critical of specifically the current meta even if other metas have had similarly or more egregious decks based on event winrates.
The stand out reason I hate the current format so much is that Riven simply does not play the game.
Irelia on Abandoned Hall or Leblanc on Hillock or whatever other broken combinations can get really absurd might totals, but they are still fundamentally contesting a battlefield. They do it far too well in many scenarios compared to the average deck, but you are still playing the game.
Riven on Star Spring and Dais literally just does not play the game. There are two fields that allow Riven to end every single turn with a double conquer and every unit in base. It is actually pathetic that we can see top 8 games at a Showdown end with legitimately ZERO combats.
Here's the ban text for Reavers Row:
"The first is Reaver’s Row, which promotes a noninteractive pattern (especially if both players bring it in the same game) - rather than have meaningful showdowns and interactions between players or situations where a player tries to hold, players will just retreat."
I am flabbergasted that Riven is being allowed to exist as is with Dais and ESPECIALLY Star Spring. Every justification for banning Reavers applies to Star Spring. Star Spring also enabled 8-0 games from Faefolk decks this weekend, absurd Leblanc shenanigans, and the master yi first mate classic where he auto wins turn 2.
Not emergency banning Star Spring before Stuttgart is extremely silly because it will almost certainly be banned afterwards. The Vegas meta will be entirely different, but have the same worlds qualification!
The fact Riven never has to actually care about holding enables EXTREMELY auto pilot gameplay. Im not exaggerating when I say I believe it is the easiest deck in the game to competitive results on by FAR. there is almost zero concept of balancing board development and combat tricks. Almost every other deck in the game has to worry about the fundamental balancing of board development and spells. Riven just shits out units, sends them all to base, draws 10 cards, and automatically beats 90% of decks in the game.
At this point Stuttgart is a lost cause. The tournament will feature a plethora of Kennen and Riven matches with close to zero combats per game and extensive cost cheating from Rhasa/Nocturne and Heron. Whoever plays solitaire better wins. Amazing!
I'm begging Riot to do the right thing and be liberal with bans post Stuttgart. Riftbound should be about CONTESTING BATTLEFIELDS. Get rid of the absurd cards that prevent this and/or enable decks that ignore this.
Going forward, don't be scared to make the right changes for the game. Making game play not miserable to play and watch should be the top priority. Just rip bans and adjust instead of holding yourselves to silly standards just because you tweeted you would
THANK YOU!
Akali was Tier D before winning an RQ.
Ezreal won one while Draven was “broken.”
Ornn won one during the Kennen “ban this” era.
Heron decks are insanely strong, sure. But maybe try solving the meta before asking Riot to solve it for you.
I wrote an article on a topic that's been in the back of my mind for a while now: deckbuilding fallacies in Magic.
Gameplay fallacies get talked about a lot, but these are equally important. Link in replies!