What’s really killing this ecosystem is clearly the community’s loss of critical thinking.
It's not because you have a financial or emotional attachment to a project, that you should stop questioning it or criticism (in a constructive way) the decisions that are made.
This is both bad for the project, which gets no factual feedback, no useful comments, and no interesting analysis from its community, and so can never really take a step back to look at what's happening / what it's done.
And at the same time, it’s bad for the community itself, which will just get lost in disappointment, convince itself that the project is all bullish (without seeing that they’re actually being milked), and create false hopes.
Writing bull posts every day long to try to avoid reality and certain problems / questions that are legitimate, isn't going to pump your bag or actually improve the situation.
And this applies to all types of projects in the ecosystem.
Projects that qualify criticism/questioning of certain decisions as “fud” are the worst possible outcome.
🟣 Is Papertrade already dead?
On October 20, the @papertrade_xyz team announced several major changes to the protocol.
First, $PAPER will not be transferable for now. As a reminder, it is the token that losing traders receive, and once staked, it entitles holders to a share of the protocol’s revenue.
Next, fees are changing for positions closed very close to their entry price, within 0.06% during the most liquid hours and 0.1% outside of them.
Finally, the $PAPER emission curve is changing. Each dollar lost now mints a fixed share of the supply, about 0.1% for every million dollars lost. Over time, early holders will therefore be diluted in favor of new users.
Since this announcement, most of Papertrade’s metrics have dropped sharply:
◻️ TVL, which came close to $120 million at launch, has fallen back to $20.8 million.
◻️ Open interest, which had exceeded $4.5 billion, is now only $54.8 million.
◻️ Daily volume and staking revenue have followed the same trend.
In our view, however, this decline was to be expected, even without the rule changes, simply because PAPER farming was never meant to stay profitable for very long anyway.
Indeed, at launch, each dollar lost earned 100 PAPER as long as the pool held less than $2 million. But over time, as the LP grew, the number of PAPER minted for each dollar lost decreased.
The system therefore mainly rewarded the very first users, and each new wave of farmers collected far less PAPER than the previous one. All the more so since the total supply was capped at around 12.7 billion tokens.
On the eve of the announcement, nearly 70% of this supply was already in circulation, and a dollar lost only yielded about 11 PAPER.
You therefore had to lose nearly $91 to mine 1,000, compared to around ten at launch.
So well before October 20, farming PAPER was already yielding almost nothing.
The new rules mainly accelerated the decline in activity that was already underway, and thus pushed the last farmers to leave the protocol.
Nevertheless, the protocol remains heavily used:
◻️ New users keep arriving, with more than 15,000 sign-ups since October 20, for a total of over 38,000 users.
◻️ Since the start of the month, Papertrade has been in the top 3 perp DEXs by volume.
◻️ Over the same month, it generated $4.9 million in fees. It is the second perp DEX on this metric, behind Hyperliquid ($33.6 million) and ahead of Jupiter ($3.8 million).
In our view, what is happening today therefore looks more like a shift in the user base.
Farmers are leaving as PAPER becomes harder to accumulate, and those arriving since October 20 know full well that they will get almost none of it.
If they come anyway, it is, in our view, for the product itself.
Papertrade lets you trade BTC and ETH with up to x1000 leverage, a level of leverage found on no other perp DEX.
For many, it is simply a way to gamble on small price movements in bitcoin:native or ethereum:native , and the PAPER received in case of a loss is now just a small bonus. This is in fact what the team is trying to build, since it wants to make PAPER an equivalent of exchange rakeback.
Admittedly, the protocol’s activity is lower, but it is also much healthier. Fees now come mostly from traders looking to win, and far less from losses deliberately generated to mint PAPER.
Volume and open interest are therefore clearly less spectacular, but they reflect real demand for the product much better.
Papertrade is therefore far from dead. Even with a TVL much lower than at launch, the protocol continues to generate more fees than almost every other perp DEX available on the market.
The protocol is simply exiting its farming phase, and its current figures give a more accurate picture of its real activity.
Builder codes, which will allow other projects to integrate Papertrade, could be a way to attract new users and revive its activity in the coming months.
No matter what happens in the next few weeks, what’s going on right now is actually pretty interesting.
I really feel like not pretending to be someone that you’re not is the best move here.
This is the perfect time to put the ego aside and just learn from the situation.
Keep your spot convictions.
Keep some cash.
Observation. Learning. Patience.
Tbh man you’re going pretty hard saying the money spent on HPC actions is wasted.
The work that’s been done and the progress made is still massive compared to what was there before (aka nothing).
And btw even with the democrats coming in, the SEC and CFTC operate independently and they can barely influence how they function until the end of the current term.
On the other hand, for crypto regulation in general, with stuff like the Clarity Act etc (which Hyperliquid clearly didn’t care if it passed or not), yeah that’s clearly done
@0xLoris but real question, don’t you think running a new incentives season where, for the first time ever, US users can actually participate is more relevant to satisfy both new users and the protocol at the same time than just sending tokens to random wallets?