Get to know me thread. 1) I’m a proud radical feminist. I can’t sit by any more and watch the erasure of women’s biology, spaces, or rights to speak about women’s-only issues, without speaking up.
@harlequinpub@DrJessTaylor@Jgicriminolg@EvaPoen It’s great that you’re interested in critically evaluating research,as we all should be! but I have never seen this level of debate around other research. We should question why that is.If you’re interested to learn more there are great free courses on research methods online! BW
@harlequinpub@DrJessTaylor@Jgicriminolg@EvaPoen I think the authors are exhausted from being subjected to a level of scrutiny that is unheard of for most research. As a researcher, I understand their intense frustration. I’ve used my free time to try & explain some research basics - free time not everyone has.
@harlequinpub@DrJessTaylor@Jgicriminolg@EvaPoen Are you levelling the same criticism at all research presented to the public (usually just through media press release)? Usually authors just give a short press release & do nothing to follow up concerns. No one gets to ask questions or assesses methods in such detail.
@harlequinpub@DrJessTaylor@Jgicriminolg@EvaPoen The authors are presenting the study and findings in an accessible way, which is amazing - it’s not meant to be an accessible course on research methods. I understand there might be questions & misconceptions, but they’ve gone above & beyond to address these.
@harlequinpub@DrJessTaylor@Jgicriminolg@EvaPoen There’s no dishonesty or hiding here. These are recognised and common limitations. It might seem that way to ppl who aren’t researchers, but this is standard practice. There’s of course room for improvement, but do we scrap all psych research ever bc of these limitations?
@harlequinpub@DrJessTaylor@Jgicriminolg@EvaPoen The answer to this is clear on the site. This applies to most if not all psych studies. Study adverts inherently invite ppts with a vested interest bc most use convenience sampling which relies on individual motivation. So these results are comparable to previous work
@harlequinpub@DrJessTaylor@Jgicriminolg@EvaPoen Absolutely no psych research ever is fully representative of the U.K. gen pop / all women. Again this possible limitation applies to all psych studies. It doesn’t invalidate the study results.
@harlequinpub@DrJessTaylor@Jgicriminolg@EvaPoen In research results are phrased this way all the time. The %s are necessarily derived from the sample, so eg “51% of the respondents” is implicit in all reporting. But if you have concerns anyway, fair - but this applies to the way ALL research & surveys are reported.
@harlequinpub@DrJessTaylor@Jgicriminolg@EvaPoen Because it’s just summary data? How does this indicate that data & its presentation don’t matter? What’s your actual question - I’m not clear from your tweets so far?
All the research, psych & sampling “experts” have suddenly come out of the woodwork in response to @Victim_Focus ’s new report!! I’m all for critically evaluating research, but some of the criticisms being levelled at this study apply to every single piece of psych research ever.
Eg sample not being generalisable - again no papers address this bc it’s assumed that researchers are aware this is the case. Studies are always done on very specific constrained groups. All researchers should be talking about this, it’s not one researchers job to address the…
@DrJessTaylor All the critiques I’ve seen read like first year psych students essays (which I have marked A LOT of) - “the findings aren’t generalisable to the gen pop” lol - SURPRISE, no research study data is!! 😂 let’s level up the critical thinking pls
Misogyny for you. 22k women report their experiences of violence and suddenly everyone is arguing about epistemology and research methods to discredit their responses. YAWN.
@punapeura @JeanHatchet They did get a good spread, & the demographic %s were broadly representative of the U.K. pop. I think we should be cautious of critiquing in too much detail before the full data is released anyway, we’ve only seen summary data so far. It’s important to be accurate
@punapeura @JeanHatchet So this criticism applies to basically all psych research. Also most samples are less than 100 & made up of undergrad students. So it’s a fair criticism but it doesn’t only apply to this study specifically.
@punapeura @JeanHatchet No psych research data can be fully generalised. None. Because it’s all necessarily gathered from samples much smaller than the U.K. gen pop. Convenience sampling might not be the “best” but as I said, it’s absolutely the standard in psych.