@Jonathan_K_Cook Well said. The principle should be simple: British Jews are not Israel.
Sanctioning Israeli settlers is not sanctioning British Jews. Criticising Israel is not attacking British Jews.
Real antisemitism is holding a Jew in Britain responsible for the actions of Israel.
Stop the conflation @chiefrabbi.
Richard, this is exactly the conflation we are warning against.
Why should sanctions against Israeli settlers give anyone a “licence” to attack British Jews?
British Jews are not Israeli settlers and are not responsible for Israel.
Antisemites are responsible for antisemitism — not the British Government for treating Israel like any other foreign state.
Stop linking British Jews to the actions of Israel. That conflation is itself dangerous.
Exactly. And there is an even bigger point:
No Rabbi, organisation or foreign state should claim one political position on behalf of “British Jews.”
We are not a political bloc.
Disagreement with Israel is not disagreement with Jews. Sanctions against Israelis are not sanctions against British Jews.
Stop conflating Jewish identity with Israeli politics.
P.S. I love listening to you on @lbc. Many in the Jewish community are opposing the political view of the @chiefrabbi; many observant Jews and their daily used synagogues are NOT under the Board of Deputies and the Chief Rabbi and are against the state of Israel at all.
Please STOP doing this “for BRITISH JEWS.”
This vigil was for ISRAEL — a foreign state — not British Jews.
British Jews are NOT Israel, NOT its government and NOT its settlers.
Want to keep British Jews safe? Stop conflating us with the actions of a foreign state.
THAT CONFLATION IS DANGEROUS.
This is real antisemitism:
BLAMING OR TARGETING BRITISH JEWS FOR ISRAEL’S ACTIONS.
British Jews are NOT the Israeli government, NOT Israeli settlers, and NOT responsible for a foreign state.
CRITICISE ISRAEL! DON’T BLAME JEWS.
#RealAntiSemitism#BritishJews#Israel
With respect, this is NOT “the position of the mainstream Jewish community.”
British Jews hold many different views on Israel and its settlements.
Sanctions against Israeli settlers are not sanctions against British Jews — and opposing Israeli government policy is not antisemitism.
WHAT IS DANGEROUS IS CONTINUALLY CONFLATING BRITISH JEWS WITH ISRAEL AND ITS POLITICAL AGENDA.
Fight REAL antisemitism. Don’t turn every political action against Israel into a Jewish issue.
QUESTIONS FOR THE @chiefrabbi:
1) Why was yesterday a “dark day for British Jews”?
2) What exactly became darker or more dangerous for British Jews yesterday?
3) Why frame sanctions against Israeli settlers as an issue for British Jews?
4) Do you support the settlement movement in Judea and Samaria?
5) Do you believe a Jew living in London was genuinely less safe yesterday than the week before?
6) Why should British Jews be associated with the actions of settlers thousands of miles away?
7) Are British Jews responsible for the policies or actions of the State of Israel?
8) Does linking British Jews to Israeli settlers risk reinforcing the antisemitic idea that Jews are collectively responsible for Israel?
British Jews are British citizens, not representatives of a foreign state!!
When everything involving Israel is labelled a threat to British Jews, does that weaken the fight against REAL antisemitism!!
@DailyMail
British Jews are NOT Israeli settlers.
Sanctioning Israeli settlers is NOT antisemitism.
What puts British Jews in danger is conflating Jews in Britain with a foreign state and its political movements.
Stop making British Jews responsible for Israel.
Stop playing politics with AntiSemitism!!
No Jew should ever face consequences for the actions of a FOREIGN STATE simply because they are Jewish. Equally, no FOREIGN STATE should claim to speak on behalf of citizens of another country simply because they share a religion or heritage.
British Jews are British citizens — Israel speaks for Israel, not for all Jews.
Labour’s desperate bid to win back hard-left and Islamist voters is putting Britain’s Jews at risk with these wrong-headed sanctions.
Miliband’s refusal to answer my question, instead smearing me, simply proves he knows I am right.
British Jews are less safe, our US security relationship is damaged & serious sanctions from Israel are likely.
Labour’s desperate bid to win back hard-left and Islamist voters is putting Britain’s Jews at risk with these wrong-headed sanctions.
Miliband’s refusal to answer my question, instead smearing me, simply proves he knows I am right.
British Jews are less safe, our US security relationship is damaged & serious sanctions from Israel are likely.
Sir Ephraim Mirvis called today “a dark day for British Jews.”
We say: This is truly a dark day for Zionists.
You speak for your friend Bibi and for the state of Zionism, not for UK Jews.
Making such a disastrous statement and conflating Jews and Judaism with Israel is false and dangerous.
You don’t speak for us.
.@NickFerrariLBC With all due respect!
When criticising the Zionist government or even opposing their existence, you are NOT an Anti-Semite at all!
BUT when confusing Anti-Zionism with Anti-Semitism, then YOU are an Anti-Semite, and you are endangering Jews worldwide!
Read more on our website: https://t.co/NNuJBLjZ8B
Nick and @LBC team, please follow and interview our Rabbi, @yaakov_shapiro. Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro is an Orthodox rabbi, Torah scholar, author and lecturer whose work examines Jewish identity and the ideological distinction between Judaism and Zionism. He is best known for The Empty Wagon: Zionism's Journey from Identity Crisis to Identity Theft, an extensive study arguing that the traditional Torah conception of the Jewish people should not be conflated with modern political nationalism or the State of Israel. His lectures and writings are particularly relevant to contemporary debates about Jewish identity, Zionism, Israel and antisemitism.
@JewishChron A Dark Day for Israel–UK Relations — But Why a Dark Day for British Jews?
https://t.co/RvWDQCljYB respectfully disagrees with the Chief Rabbi: British Jews should never be made synonymous with the policies of the Israeli Government.
A Dark Day for Israel–UK Relations — But Why a Dark Day for British Jews?
https://t.co/SsLdSpDvZc respectfully disagrees with the Chief Rabbi: British Jews should never be made synonymous with the policies of the Israeli Government.
@Ed_Miliband@APPGAA#BritishJews#ChiefRabbi #AntiSemitism ##EdMiliband #IsraelSettlement
@chiefrabbi A Dark Day for Israel–UK Relations — But Why a Dark Day for British Jews?
https://t.co/RvWDQCljYB respectfully disagrees with the Chief Rabbi: British Jews should never be made synonymous with the policies of the Israeli Government.
https://t.co/TwFnm40S5g