Quando isso ficar barato ao ponto de qqer um poder fazer suas versões de episódios inteiros das suas séries favoritas vai ser foda demais … isso aqui ficou 10/10
The audacity to say "the Quran never mentions the Bible even once" lying about a fundamental core and necessity of your false book is insane, you live in a pedophile death cult, touch grass.
Again your claims are historically verifiably false, just because you claim something does not make it true this is where you keep apealing to authority (its true because I say so without & contrary to evidence)
Not that heretical sources matter but yes the Gospel is the criteria :
Tafsir al-Tabari (Jami' al-Bayan fi Ta'wil al-Qur'an), under the commentary for Surah Al-Baqarah, Ayah 53. "Al-Furqan is the comprehensive name for the Torah, the Gospel, the Psalms, and the Criterion"
Let's play a little game, a thought experiment shall we, what is the 5 books of Moses?... The Torah! Who wrote it? Moses but authored by God correct? I assume you'd make the same claim falsely about the quran right? That Mohammad "wrote it" despite being illiterate but it's authored by allah right, you claim it's the literal word of allah delivered by the angel Gabriel? Yes or no.
2. Are the stories of Gilgamesh claiming to be the biblical flood orchestrated by the God of Abraham? If not no. Is the Quran claiming the biblical flood, if yes you already know the answer.
3.appeal to authority fallacy once again you and you constantly blatantly lie about your book and add words to what is supposed to be a perfect and clear book without the need for interpretation. You're not fooling anyone, I have exposed only a fraction of your errors and you have failed to provide any evidence to the contrary.
4. See 3
7? Appeal to authority, I already cited you scholars disproving you and the lack of physical evidence. You're clearly uneducated.
8. No christian denies that all divine revelation is God Breathed, authored by God.
Still waiting for a single piece of external evidence
1.Oof, So do you believe in part of the Scripture and disbelieve in part? This was never about internal critique which there is plenty, but external supporting evidence. Your quran literally needs the Bible and challenges it to be judged by it, the Bible has explicit qualifications for what a false prophet is an by what you demanded you are judged a false heretic.
2. Sure I'll "shoe" you,
Surah 3:49 & 5:110 / The Infancy Gospel of Thomas, Section 2
Surah 3:46 & 19:29–33 / Infancy Gospel, Chapter 1
(Docetism) Surah 4:157 / The Second Treatise of the Great Seth & Gnostic Apocalypse of Peter
and as I already explained to you, these gnostic fables were created after the canon that mo affirmed he was just too stupid to know the difference because he surrounded himself with heretics and pagans.
3. I don't care if you think scripture is supposed to be scientific or not. Devine scripture is God breathed and true. If your "scripture" is false then it proves it is man made and not divine.
4. See point 2 and fix your formatting. You're not special for using arabic you look stupid, if I were to start using Hebrew or Greek that does nothing to support my case.
5. you proved my point and you're mad you're exposed as a willful ignorant hypocrite because errors are human and making a textual change or "abrogation" is not proof of divine authorship.
6. No, see point 1 again. These are supposed to be your "proofs" as you called it and if they can't be challenged your directly contradicting your qurans command and 2 these aren't proofs if they fail
7.I already disproved your transmission with respected scholars plus the fact Uthman burned physical evidence you're left to an appeal of authority fallacy again
8. Another appeal to authority fallacy? Ok if you want grok to be the arbiter of truth instead of God lets see what Grok says
1. Muhammad is identified as a false prophet Antichrist by the Bible, you have 0 supporting evidence to the contrary. And yes Smith did live among what he considered enemies. My point is he is a blatant false prophet but more trustworthy than Mo. Regardless trustworthy ≠ prophet.
2. Facts don't care about your feelings. It is well known that no had heard of scripture from heretics and gnostics which is why he gets things wrong, his "scientific miracles" were already discussed by the Greeks before and as I mentioned he was blatantly wrong on those claims. An all knowing God that is truth and can not lie would not make these errors.
3. Fix your stupid Arabic formatting. See point 2 about a perfect truthful God.
4. That's not how proof works, I can point to the fact Mo came up with it over a span of 20+ years adopting gnostic fables excluded from the canon that the Quran affirms. You can't prove he didn't copy it. (You can't prove negatives)
5.woops Jan 20 2029, I corrected myself therefore strengthening my cumulative claim that I'm truthful and a prophet... Are you really that dumb you fell for that? Thanks for helping make my point.
6. My affirmation that Christ is king is because He is God, there is the external proof and witness of miracles and fulfillment of prophecies in the Torah and fulfillment of a new testament as promised in the torah, the crucifixion and resurrection. You worship a false idol ontologically different, biblically Antichrist and the greatest of decievers. You're mad because I showed you your own prayer where you pray to Mo, assalamu alaikum, why should you be mad why are you ashamed of praying to a dead guy burried in medina?
7. I know plenty about your tadlis and outright fabrications, just because you have a chain that does not automatically mean the text originated with the claimed source. Ignác Goldziher and Joseph Schacht have already shown that your sources don't lead to mohammed but to 8th century persons with no In betweens. Hadiths are centuries after Mo. Unlike the Christian apostolic succession where we have multiple verified chains from Peter and the physical documents to verify.
8. Mu died like a dog describing it exactly how he said he would as a false prophet killed by lamb, very ironic, some would say.... Poetic? I don't know if you know this they say the Quran and hadiths are written so beautifully there's nothing like it 😭
You
Are not
Proving
Anything
Infact you're proving my point, Arabic is stupid, fix your unreadable formatting.
1. Yes it does, I can tell you're a prideful heretic. Likewise people know everything about Joseph Smith and he identifies as a prophet so it must be true by your logic.
2. You should, the Torah is written in Hebrew the New Testament in Greek. Mohammad plagiarized both by hearing it from gnostic heretics and then sprinkled in some of his tribes pagan rituals and idolatry, it is not special.
3. no it doesn't, do you understand what "proof" is? It's not even evidence of divine authorship or inspiration, it's the opposite because you're claiming your gods word changes because it made a mistake.
4. See point 2, Mo was a misinformed plagerist and pagan polytheist. You're also literally arguing that Mo "came up with it"
5. In two years Jan 6 my country will have a new leader - proof I'm a prophet... Should I point out all of his lies such as sperm coming from the spine, mountains on pegs, moon splitting, suns setting etc. There's way more not even counting errors of specific peoples and genealogy.
6. He was a polygomos incestous psycho warlord that elevated himself above the Lord Jesus Christ, broke every commandment, demanded tribute including jizya, and taught muslims to literally pray to him 5x a day "P̶e̶a̶c̶e̶ ̶b̶e̶ ̶u̶p̶o̶n̶ ̶y̶o̶u̶,̶ ̶O̶ ̶P̶r̶o̶p̶h̶e̶t̶,̶ ̶a̶n̶d̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶m̶e̶r̶c̶y̶ ̶o̶f̶ ̶A̶l̶l̶a̶h̶ ̶a̶n̶d̶ ̶H̶i̶s̶ ̶b̶l̶e̶s̶s̶i̶n̶g̶s̶" I don't care what he claimed, I care about what he did because his actions are contrary to all your claims.
7. I already disproved that with your own sources and the fact that Uthman burned all other codexes destroyed what little chance you had of preserving the original herecies because regardless of you attempting to preserve something or not it is still judged false by the Bible, apostolic succession and physical proof with the dead sea scrolls, codexes and thousands of manuscripts.
8. Literally nothing you said supports that he was a prophet, infact this is funny from his own mouth,
surrah69:44–46
And if he [Muhammad] had made up concerning Us some [false] sayings, We would have seized him by the right hand; then We would have cut from him the aorta.
Sahih al-Bukhari 4428
O 'Aisha! I still feel the pain caused by the food I ate at Khaibar, and at this time, I feel as if my aorta is being cut from that poison.
1. You're known as @RealMonotheist even by your enemies. That does not make it true or devinely inspired.
2.Arabic is ugly and subjective aesthetic. What constitutes "a surah like it" (Surah 2:23) is undefined, making the challenge untestable and unfalsifiable. Subjective composition does not prove divine authorship otherwise Homer, Shakespeare, or pre-Islamic Arabic poets like Imru' al-Qais would also claim divine status.
3.Self-correction alone does not prove the source is external or divine.
4.his circumstances were not unique, a majority of the 7th century were unable to read or write, Genghis Khan was illiterate and founded the Mongol empire, this was not a sign of devine endorsement.
5.Vague Post-Hoc Predictions about conflicts many of which you start are not prophecies just like I can predict Palestine or Iran getting wiped off the map. Biblical prophecies foretold specific names, lineage, locations, and events centuries in advance without relying on immediate geopolitical guesses.
6. Being rejected for being a false prophet is not persecution and he literally did abandon his message because after rejection he moved towards genocide Jews and Christians "I will expel the Jews and Christians from the Arab peninsula". Being proven wrong and doubling down is not proof of being a prophet it's proof of being a crybaby maniac.
7.oh yes he was, Aisha even is quoted that she thinks he makes stuff up for his own desire and wishes. Then there's the Al-Mu'allafatu Qulubuhum where Muhammad bribed converts with war spoils and virgins in this life or the next, it was either a bribe or a sword.
8.A text can be preserved accurately while still being human in origin. Ibn Mas'ud and Ubayy ibn Ka'b, had textual differences with more and less surahs and there's hadiths of goats eating chapters, memorizers scrambling to find surahs because they hadn't memorized them and Muhammad forgetting his own message. The fact that uthman burned the Quran and rewrote it is not proof of devine preservation.
9.political expansion and empire-building are not evidence of divine approval. The Roman, Mongol, and Alexander the Great's empires grew rapidly without claiming prophetic authority. Scripture warns against measuring spiritual truth by worldly success, numbers, or imperial conquest. True divine validation rests on alignment with God's revealed word, character, and salvation plan through Jesus Christ.
All you've layed out are feelings, none of it even comes close to or even attempts to PROVE islam
Are you unfamiliar with what "the burden of proof falls on you" means? You are the one making a claim, If someone claims that something does exist, did happen, or is true, they must provide the evidence to substantiate it.
Simply saying "I have a cumulative case" and "your books are corrupted" are unsubstantiated claims, it is not providing any evidence, this whole time you've been operating under circular and appeal to authority fallacies. Until you provide any external supporting evidence you're the one that is "typing unneeded stuff"
@RealMonotheist@grok@nick_matau Yikes. Also I never even said dilemma until you brought it up, "Islamic dilemma" really gave you PTSD. You then failed to debunk anything and instead argue that you have a position but you just can't defend or present it. The burden of proof is on you.
@RealMonotheist@grok@nick_matau So Islam in general is a circular reasoning fallacy but you personally are only making an appeal to authority fallacy right now because you have presented no evidence for your argument.