The reason for this is because each country has millions of independent variables and shocks impacting its own economy.
There have been 0 economic papers showing that Brexit increased the UK’s gdp so we know that Brexit was not the reason for the UK’s outperformance.
A big reason is this is total gdp which the UK has pumped up through large net migration since 2016. The average estimate is also a 5% reduction to GDP because of Brexit. Over the 10 year period this would not register too dramatically on the graph because it is only a 0.49% annual difference,
@RejoinNowUK Irrespective of the net cost of rejoining, can any rejoin/remoaner explain to me - ideally with some evidence - why being back in the EU would necessarily equate to improved overall UK finances? Asking because since leaving the EU the UK’s overall GDP has outperformed Ge/Fr/It!
Why does Ai hate Brexiteers?
1. How the 1.26% EU Budget Figure WorksIt is a ceiling on the total EU budget, not a flat tax on each country: The European Commission proposed a 2028–2034 long-term budget (Multiannual Financial Framework) equivalent to 1.26% of the EU’s combined Gross National Income (GNI).
The GNI contribution is only the "top-up": The EU budget is not funded by charging every country 1.26% of its GNI. First, the EU uses its "own resources"—customs duties, a share of VAT, and new proposed levies (such as carbon border taxes and corporate contributions). The GNI-based payment is simply a balancing mechanism used to cover whatever shortfall remains, which historically sits around 0.7% to 0.9% of GNI, not 1.26%.
Gross vs. Net: Even that figure only looks at money going in. Member states receive substantial funds back through agricultural, regional, and research grants. Looking at the gross figure without subtracting receipts is the exact same accounting flaw as the famous "£350m a week" Brexit bus claim.
UK contributions would be based on a GNI of 3 trillion and a demand of 1.26% payment thereof which means 37,8Bn or 727mio a week.
However we won't be joining next year.
If the GNI grows to (eg) 3.09trillion in 2026, the gross payments will be 1.26% * Tn 3.09 = 38.9Bn or 748Bn for membership in 2028.
Worse, claims have been made claiming rejoining would add 5% to the UK GDP so let's see this massive boom in 2028. GNI becomes 3.24 Tn which means we then have to pay, in 2029, 786mio a week, gross.
You see we don't need to take inflation into consideration, we just need to look at where GNI will be. Currently it's just above 3 tn.
@StevePaul63@Callan4077@grok you calculated £25 billion in net cost. Now you take the economic benefits of £70 billion to the treasury - the net cost = £45 billion true profit.
This video is amazing. Hats off to @EdConwaySky and to @SkyNews for making it, and for doing what will have been laborious research to dig into the myths and the realities.
Please watch it. Share it.
@MichaelAArouet But the UK litterally created ai by founding Deep mind which then got bought by Google.
Europe can create but it will always leave to the USA, the main contsraint is clearly not regulation.
This is not true. Gross is a figure which we can accurately calculate. Net is NOT something that we can determine because it is in the remit of the EU to determine how much we get back - or can you point to a clear, concise mechanism to determine how much we would get back?
I should also point out here than when I made an assumption on how much we would return, you huffed off and stated I shouldn't be making assumptions.
We can determine what the EU commission is demanding - 1.26% of GNI which for UK is slightly above 3 Trillion means a Gross contribution would be north of 37bn a year.
Perhaps you can explain the formula about how we should calculate HOW much money would be returned to UK?
I'll wait.
https://t.co/9HvTlUC29j
What the heck do you think I did?
I calculated using the same mechanism which was applicable then.
It's a fact that we received £1 back for each £3 we paid in. I took the current EU demands - 1.26% x GNI of 3trillion as gross payments - 37,8Bn and reduced this by 33% means a net of between 24 and 25Bn.
But you belittled me for using an assumption....