@bentziavtzon The חושך is greater today than it was yesterday. Time will tell that the אור won. This, of course, is *my* response to people in *my* circle of influence. It has nothing to do with the response to the immediate and future pain that yesomim will experience, etc
@bentziavtzon No, yesterday the plan was fitting to yesterday’s context. An event like this catapults one into heightened action, as it catapults other Yidden into greater responsive hisorerus.
@bentziavtzon Get off our couches and make sure many more yidden than we were planning to are reached for Mivtza Chanuka, Mivtza Tefillin, Mivtza Neshek and more.
@bentziavtzon 1. Guess we see things differently.
2. Chas v’shalom. יבכו was an instruction given by Moshe.
That there’s a question waiting for an answer stays true, and pain should not be suppressed. But there is a right response, and we know what we need to do.
@antigoyimleague@shevereshtus Assuming you accept that premise, which Torah-true Judaism doesn’t. But yes, clearly we are conversing on different premises, which is why the conversation can’t go anywhere. However, it’s still important to emphasize what Torah’s position is.
@antigoyimleague@shevereshtus Right, so you agree that the simple meaning implies geocentrism, but you’d rather twist the Torah to fit with the current scientific understanding. Thats called apologetics, which I don’t believe in. Btw, why wouldn’t stopping the sun make sense in a geocentric model?
@antigoyimleague@shevereshtus Don’t worry, most of what science accepted as fact a few hundred years ago is not supported by the overwhelming scientific evidence of today, and today’s science will be laughed at later too. The Torah’s absolute truth, including egocentrism and a static earth, will not change.
@antigoyimleague@shevereshtus See also the amazing, fundamental Talmudic statement in Bava Basra 25b about the reason the sun moves westward - it is bowing to the divine shechina which is in the west. Another source that the sun moves.
@antigoyimleague@shevereshtus As a self proclaimed expert in what “the Torah never speaks about”, how do you explain the tens of times the Torah makes reference to the sun “exiting” (יצא) and “entering” (בא), the simple meaning of which is that the sun is mobile? Also, have you read Koheles 1:4?
@AlanDersh 4. As someone who has been giving a daily Rambam class for the last five years, it’s obvious to me that @alandersh has never studied a single book of the Rambam from cover to cover, in order. If he had, he couldn’t possibly utter such words about him.
@AlanDersh 3. Rambam didn’t just not discourage debate, he created more of it. Every word of his magnum opus has been examined, debated & enlightened by rabbis in tens of thousands of super-commentaries to date. They study his books daily, finding deeper meaning and insight in every line.
@bentziavtzon @rabbitulane @jorosenfeld If you said that, ya it would be recriminatory & childish. I was thinking a more firm “I see it differently. The most important thing about a Tzaddik is not that he goes to the bathroom. Which makes me wonder how you see tzaddikim”, and a (hopefully) thoughtful convo ensues