@EastRenAsks@A_D_PHIL Of course it is fundamentally different. It means the residual GB£ become the property of the SCB. Redenomination means you destroy the GB£. The SCB ends up with £40 to 50 bn at the end of the exchange.
@moomintroll41@SpiritualMB@Scotophile@SeaandSand0@KeithFGordon Assuming Hinckley Point and Sizewell C actually get finished then nuclear would be about 10% of English demand. What does Scotland need with nuclear when we have renewables by the GW and just need to sort hydro pumped storage for it?
@SpiritualMB@Scotophile@SeaandSand0@KeithFGordon However Scottish goods exports are over 20% of total UK goods exports. 40% of UK food and drink exports are from Scotland. That includes e.g, Gordon's Gin and Smirnoff which come from Fife.
@EastRenAsks@A_D_PHIL There is no re-denomination. What is going to happen is all an exchange out of the GB£ and into the S£. Of course the entire public sector, plus the State Pension will all immediately convert to S£. That is around 50% of GDP.
@SpiritualMB@Scotophile@SeaandSand0@KeithFGordon rUK would not stay the same. For one thing the balance of payments would be much worse without Scottish exports. Energy will be a bigger problem too as it will be mostly imported.
@moomintroll41@NeilKing11@ScotNational You are not correct. As Professor Laurentjoye is actually staying in my house just now I think I know better than you.
@skarabrae580129@A_D_PHIL@ScotNational I have Coop Bank accounts. In December they are all being moved to Coventry Building Society. If i don't like that I need to move somewhere else before then. Same opt out system as the Report proposes, in effect.
@moomintroll41@NeilKing11@ScotNational It is voluntary. However, e.g. only an S£ cash ISA will have tax exemption. Anyone keeping a GB£ ISA will become subject to tax.
@skarabrae580129@A_D_PHIL@ScotNational The table applies to the bulk transfer of the accounts of everyone that hasn't signed an opt out application. The court order transfer is so that the bank does not need written consent for each contract/account. No different to the imminent transfer of the Coop to Coventry BS.
@skarabrae580129@ScotNational In most cases it will just be a movement within the same banking group, e.g. Natwest Bank/RBS plc. So there should be no problem for them. Some small banks may decide not to establish a Scottish subsidiary, but if necessary the SCB can intervene.
@NeilKing11@moomintroll41@ScotNational We will do a simplified version for the public. We only got the report on Tuesday so not possible to do that in a couple of days.