he/him. George Michael stan & Shitposting account for good Faith discussions. Politically independent; Neither of the major political parties fits my views.
@KatieInBoston1 In the specific conversation you replied to, the person I was talking to said that sex was defined as "person with a uterus" (among other things). I was bringing up MRKH because it was directly relevant to what the other person said.
@KatieInBoston1 I'm really not doing that at all. What I'm pointing out is that reproductive organs, or missing some reproductive organs, does not invalidate someone's sex. As someone with MRKH, I'm sure you'll at least agree with me that you're still no less of a woman.
@KatieInBoston1 What can be said within the Twitter character limits causes nuance to be left out. If you'll allow me to clarify, I completely agree with what you're saying. You're right. I was referring to egg production, not ovaries, which effects a small percentage of people with MRKH.
@SianHerfield @9924sept @phillipminestri@SaintFinnbarr@davematt88@grover_lou You've probably met over 100,000 people in your life. That's the number of people who fit in a large football stadium, so unless you're a complete shut-in you've probably encountered them before. And you sound like a bully if you do that, but I'm guessing you only do it online.
@SianHerfield @9924sept @phillipminestri@SaintFinnbarr@davematt88@grover_lou Complete androgen insensitivity syndrome is the condition. Not everyone with the condition would always consider themselves to be female, but that is fairly common. But by your definition, they would have to always be male.
@SianHerfield @9924sept @phillipminestri@SaintFinnbarr@davematt88@grover_lou I never said intersex people are "both sexes" as you seem to be implying from this question. There are intersex people born with testes, and no ovaries and no uterus, but who are definitely female, and if you were to meet them in public you would agree they are female.
@9924sept @SianHerfield@phillipminestri@SaintFinnbarr@davematt88@grover_lou I specifically said that was not what I said, multiple times. How can I make that more clear? I literally agreed with you and said you were 100% correct. I don't know how I can be less vague than "you are correct"
@SianHerfield@phillipminestri@SaintFinnbarr@davematt88@grover_lou But as you said, now (today, not the past) we have the ability to do scans so in your words we don't get it wrong anymore. So again, why would we wait until a child is old enough to consent if we can no longer get it wrong?
@SianHerfield@phillipminestri@SaintFinnbarr@davematt88@grover_lou Ok, I think I see where the misunderstanding here is. Do you know why surgery is no longer performed until the child is old enough to consent? That's kind of important, as it directly relates to the point I'm making.
@SianHerfield @9924sept @phillipminestri@SaintFinnbarr@davematt88@grover_lou Yep, all of that is 100% correct. It also doesn't strictly contradict anything I said. I simply said they are born without reproductive organs. I did not say they were born without *all* reproductive organs, which I should have been more clear on but twitter character limits...
@SianHerfield@phillipminestri@SaintFinnbarr@davematt88@grover_lou What I'm trying to explain but am apparently doing a bad job of is that gametes, chromosomes, and reproductive organs are not 100% reliable ways to determine someone's sex. There are a long list of conditions that make all of those things ambiguous in different ways.
@SianHerfield@phillipminestri@SaintFinnbarr@davematt88@grover_lou You specifically said sex is defined by gametes. Now you're saying it's defined by reproductive organs. But there are also people born without reproductive organs (MRKH syndrome) so what sex would they be?