@schneiderhome Late challenge for '(lack of) independent review' of year, but Ray McCann (31 years at HMRC) retains crown.
Reviewer of #McCannReview into #LoanChargeScandal.. "Plainly I am not independent".
@4x4RoadRunner01 HMRC historically banging on about individuals not adhering to the will or spirit of Parliament when it came to loan scheme participation, then ignoring and circumventing such a review finding does smack of double standards and still being hell-bent on punishment strategy.
@4x4RoadRunner01 So #LoanCharge has disproportionately affected male contractors' mental health. Perhaps their self-identity was too close to everything LC was designed to threaten (as in HMRC "Make it Real" strapline). What is left after ruined work, families, relationships, house, retirement?
@TheRising_Moon The book is a personal account of how the Loan Charge affected my wife and me. It's about the human cost of government policy, families affected, and ordinary people trying to hold powerful institutions to account.
Keir Starmer put inheritance tax on the family farm, and he is not a serious person, because of the donkey field.
In 1996 he bought seven acres of farmland behind his parents' house in Surrey for £20,000, so his mother could keep rescue donkeys on it. There were four. In 2022 he sold it for about £295,000.
So here is a man who knows from experience that a field can go up fifteenfold in value while the animals standing on it earn you nothing but manure. That is the entire predicament of the British livestock farmer, and he lived it, with donkeys.
He went several years as an MP without declaring the field. Then a tax lawyer went through the paperwork and concluded it had been arranged in a way that kept it outside his parents' estate for inheritance tax. He says there was no trust, no advantage, and every penny paid.
On his own account, then, it was simply land held in a family, used for animals, and passed between generations with inheritance tax nowhere near it.
In October 2024 his government announced that for farmers this would end: 20% on everything over £1 million. Tractors came to Westminster. He said the government just needed to keep explaining. Fourteen months later it raised the threshold to £2.5 million, having explained it to nobody.
He gave up meat years ago, as a matter of principle, for his body and the planet. He admits he misses bacon sandwiches and chicken curry. His children were not given meat until they were ten.
So the people who rear the country's beef and lamb were taxed by a man who will not eat it, wishes he could, and whose entire career in agriculture is four donkeys and a 1,375% return.
@SarahEGabbai May be it should have been implemented retrospective. Like the #LoanCharge.
The Retrospective Dilemma: Why the Loan Charge Targeted Individuals Over Promoters | Trevor Price
https://t.co/IU4cnOi7Bv
A retired former health and social care worker who has experienced suicidal feelings is disputing £26,947.81 in alleged historic contractor loans. As the #FCA imposes restrictions on Ethica Resolve. @itcontracting
https://t.co/mQ3dDMCLAo
@itcontracting Injustice on top of injustice as victims of #LoanChargeScandal face loan demands for SAME RECEIPTS which HMRC previously issued Loan Charge!
HMRC's response? - "unable to intervene"! What about changing law so loans subject to LC cannot be recalled!!
Jessica, a retired health and social care worker, is being pursued for £26,947.81.
The work ended thirteen years ago. It was wages, she says, not a loan.
The first letters arrived while she was already seriously ill. She felt depressed, anxious, and had no energy left to fight. Trethowans noted the stress on the file. The letters were not paused, and nobody offered a practical adjustment.
Under the FCA’s requirements, Ethica Resolve must tell affected people in these West 28th Street claims that they have no enforceable obligation to pay at this stage, and make no further payment demand while that stands.
She says the letters have not stopped.
https://t.co/TWP7hFsamk
Plainly I am not independent"
(Ray McCann 2019) - quite the admission from 'independent' reviewer #LoanChargeScandal#McCannReview on eve of publication of his review (into settlement terms).
The United Kingdom’s 2017 #LoanChargeScandal remains one of the most contentious measures in modern #tax history.
The Retrospective Dilemma: Why the #LoanCharge Targeted Individuals Over Promoters
https://t.co/XiyIYkRleZ