Southern Baptist Convention cases We're Following - Update:
DOJ Investigation (NY)
Rollins v. Pressler (TX)
Roe v. Patterson (TX)
Berry v. SBC (NC)
Blue v. SBC (NC)
Caldwell v. SBC (NC)
Couch v. SBC (NC)
Dockins v. SBC (NC)
Doe v. SBC (SC)
Doe v. SBC (SC)
Duhart v. SBC (SC)
1/3
I'm thankful to have received summary judgment in my favor in the David Sills case. Others have said much about this case while it was underway; I was always confident and content to wait for the court's judgment. I am happy for the court's order to speak for itself.
@DiP11s 4/ The conundrum is that SBCEC agreed to pay for Guidepost's share, and that's not covered by our insurance. In effect, the SBCEC is Guidepost's insurance.
There's some real risk Sills settles with Guidepost for a lot. And leaves the SBC on the hook.
@DiP11s 3/ Whether Barber was in or out, Sills was always going to ask for the same big number. The remaining defendants and their insurers now have some real risk that a jury awards more money than there is insurance. That creates incentives to pay out the policy and cut the risk.
@DiP11s No, it puts the EC in a bad place. Sills gets to ask a jury for millions. Everyone left in the room has risk.
I'm sure Barber is glad, but this was likely after the ruling in Hunt. Sills hoped Barber would unlock SBC/SBCEC's $$. With this ruling, Sills didn't need him.
Court: an even closer call, but reasonable jury could find Mohler and SBTS were negligent in calling relationship "non-consensual," even if using religious definition of "sexual abuse."
"The List" was published along with a statement from Rolland Slade and Willie McLaurin. SBC EC's lawyers approved redaction decisions about "the List."
Court: a close call, but a reasonable jury could decide SBC and SBCEC knew Guidepost wasn't investigating veracity of Lyell claims, and was negligent in publishing Guidepost's report.
OUT:
All claims asserted by Mary Sills.
All claims for civil conspiracy, negligence, and intentional infliction of emotional distress.
Defamation based on the Barber Tweets.
Defamation by Guidepost based on "the List."
The unusual part is that the SBC agreed to cover Guidepost's defense, even before insurance. And it's highly unlikely that the SBC's insurance covers those fees.
So if there's large amounts of offering plate money going somewhere, it's to the defense of Guidepost.