“Look at the stats” - If you think the evidence supports a conclusion, make that case.
If your argument is that other men have done it, so these men probably did too, you’ve made my point. You’ve judged them on someone else’s conduct and the percentage likelihood it happened rather than this case alone.
1/2 - I don’t know what happened in that room at the Pullman. You reading this don’t know what happened. Neither of us could see a bloody thing from our couches.
But remember how flooded your feed was in the days after the accusation? Mine was wall to wall Pullman Five. Pretty bloody quiet today, isn’t it? Where are the apologies? Where are the people who were so sure of themselves saying, maybe I got that wrong?
Instead you have people like Kate McCarthy who were happy slating these names in public going MIA on the day the innocent verdict is handed out, convenient hey? She’s happy to dish it out but bolts when she cops it in return.
The Swans stood five players down for breaking club standards. Fair enough. Four players were investigated over allegations of sexual assault. Victoria Police said there was insufficient evidence to lay charges. So how did people get from a sex worker says this happened to these blokes must have done it, they’re terrible people, and everyone should know their names? Being footballers didn’t give them a free pass. Being men didn’t give you the right to make an assumption and ruin their life.
That’s what guilty until proven innocent looks like in 2026. You take the ugliest possible version of an allegation and blow it up until it’s the first thing people associate with someone’s name.
You can tarnish a bloke’s reputation for the rest of his life before you even know if it happened. And for what? To feed your hatred of men?
An accusation fills your feed. A guilty verdict would fill it again. When someone is cleared, that’s often the quietest day of the whole story. In this case, the police outcome establishes neither guilt nor a deliberate lie. But there’s one thing the people who declared those men guilty can answer for without knowing what happened in that room. You gave thousands of people a reason to remember the accusation. How many have you bothered to tell about the outcome today?
@TommyDrowning Agreed. If the Dons truly believed they got low balled last year, then you’d be looking at getting the same offer this period with one less year on his deal. Makes no sense accepting this much less otherwise.
All that big talk from Welsh about “standing firm as a club” just to roll over on DAY ONE of the next trade period and accept 500 points less in total draft capital before you even factor in one of those picks now lands in a compromised Tassie draft.
Meanwhile, Merrett stayed and just won ANOTHER Best & Fairest in a team that finished dead last.
What a masterclass. Well played, Dons. 👏😂
#AFL #AFLTrades #Essendon #Hawthorn #HFC #HawthornFC
Josh Treacy missing from the goal square trying to torp it 80m into the grandstand, then Wharfie Time being played only to fire Brisbane up into 2 goals from their next 6 touches…
That will go down as one of the most haunting sequences in Grand Final history.
Brisbane have gotten away with murder in back to back weeks.
#AFL #Brisbane #Fremantle #AFLGF
@Chris84205549 Point of the post is pick your stance on adjudicating rules. Is there a written rule that states players are suspended for Sicily’s and Barrass’ actions?
There is for Neale’s.
Good on the umpire for having the guts to make those calls on Lewis and Impey! The rules don't change just because it's a big moment in a Prelim Final. Well done!
The same AFL fans and media begging - You can't suspend Lachie Neale! He is a two time Brownlow medalist and it's a Grand Final!
So do the rules matter in big moments or not? 9 other blokes have been suspended for similar or lesser actions this year.
Pick a lane.
You too Jonathon Brown. As if your ridiculously bias coverage on Saturday night wasn’t enough.
#AFL #AFLGF #Hawthorn #Brisbane
😡 "Not one ounce of sympathy for Lachie Neale whatsoever."
🗣️ "This is a weak case … show me where he punches Ginnivan!"
Should the Brisbane superstar be banned from the Grand Final? Gerard and Garry do NOT agree... #AFL360
💛🤎 Thank you North Melbourne. You are the gift that keeps on giving 😂
Passed on Watson for Duursma, watched Watson become a generational superstar, then tried to make up for it by drafting his reject clone Lachie Dovaston who’s too busy egging people 💀
#AFL#HFC#HawthornFC
@jackster_007 Maybe take a look at the draft again mate. There were 3 picks above that. One was North again (lol), the other was Harley Reid (a huge tick) and the 3rd was an academy pick so the Suns couldn’t have picked Watson. Try again.
@JyeTristianLFC That’s just not what happened. Hawthorn have said they rated Watson as high as Reid in the draft and may even have taken him first if they had the #1 pick.
@magicmoments000 I’m picking Noorgard regardless if he is a loop or not this week good chance he doesn’t play.
SC has him listed as injured but the quotes were not fit to start so be wary
Watching a team actively play for a draw just to scrape into a wildcard round, in a league where more than half the teams now make finals was genuinely one of the most sickening watches 😂
#AFL#AFLBluesDogs#Carlton#WesternBulldogs
Agreed, for the most part with anyone writing him off already.
My biggest concerns with Josh Weddle is his work over the ball and his tackling. Those are areas that don’t necessarily just improve with age and experience.
He’s been naturally gifted with one of the best builds on our list, yet his ability to stick tackles and consistently put his body over the footy is currently among the weakest in the side. I don’t understand how weak in the tackle he is with a rig like his.
His endurance, speed and marking ability will always be eye catching, but some of the basic football fundamentals still look off. He’s going to be a fascinating case study in the debate around drafting elite athleticism versus pure footballing ability.