Peak DDP was 98 To 99.
He was still over in 00/01 but not as over as he was.
The real issue was the stalker gimmick/story. A lot of fans assumed it was going to be Sting, which made zero sense to Stings character. Much like it made zero sense for DDP.
I think had it been revealed to be Scott Steiner wanting to make Takers wife one of his Freaks. It could've worked.
Even Flair would've made more sense than DDP.