Final Detailed refutation to pseudo-Islamic scholar(Dr. Ruchika Sharam).
@tishasaroyan Both Mernissi and Ahmed lack credible achievements in accurately quoting historical facts. Their writings are riddled with inaccuracies, fabricated narratives, and Islamophobic rhetoric.
My last words on this (until I want to tweet about it again, sometime in the future)
1) I'm most glad to see there's zero academic peer review that counters Fatima Mernissi and Leila Ahmed's brilliant historical inquisition into the classist and sexist origins of the hijab. May more Muslim women become scholars 🙏🏻
2) My piece (https://t.co/Ffie64UA8n) is largely based on Ahmed and Mernissi's work and is pro choice. It is against the essentialization of hijab as women's bodies are strictly their own.
3) For 3 days many faith-ers wanted me to accept their view of their faith. This happens a lot on my TL and I feel very special that my validation matters so much to you. Cute!!
4) But I'm a historian, and history academia is what I hold in high regard. My interest in the history of religions will continue and I will be exploring so much more of it on my channel and Twitter etc, as I have been doing so far.
5) Your faith can stand against history academia but expertise is expertise and for a good reason. Let's all be glad people's faiths don't decide history/medicine academia, India is already seeing the horrible side of it in *both* fields.
6) A few women were of the opinion that history acads interpretation of the primary source is incorrect. I'd like to remind them that at least history academia allows women to interpret primary sources, meanwhile I do not know of any female mujtahids ever. Academia-1, Faiths-0
7) Lastly, I'm deeply indebted to all the slut shamers on my TL, who argued pro choice while judging my attire. Lol, you've just proved my point about the essentialization of hijab, bhaisaab. Shukriya! 👍🏻
8) That'll be all! Do continue the rant, my TL sees it on the daily. Meh!
@SerenityJaded@Nasreen_007 Jeet better not talk about the reputation, the world despises you, come out of the shit hole. F...ing animals are your religion and culture. You were slaves, are and will be slaves only. You better introspect your subhuman mindset.
@Oumywoo I am not sending anyone to Jannah or Hell; it is individual deeds. Instead of focusing on doing good deeds, you started playing the victim game.
@SerenityJaded@Nasreen_007 People, you celebrate the genocide in Gaza, lecturing us? Who massacred every single community 1984, sikhs, Muslims every day, Christians in Manipur and everywhere. Go and take bath Jeet.
@NecroCircuit@CaptainBozoX If you are not Muslim, go away; don't waste my time. You are speaking nonsense about my religion if you call yourself Muslim. Control your emotions; stop talking trash about Islam first. Get your sense back, then comment here.
@NecroCircuit@CaptainBozoX But still they are fewer men in hell than women, which means most Muslim men do lots of good deeds afterwards, which wipe out the bad deeds. Quran ch 11 verse 114. You better do more good deeds instead of blaming others.
@NecroCircuit@CaptainBozoX How do you know my religious friends watch? Do you have any evidence? I spoke about those women; what is apparent, not based on assumptions like yours, which contradict the Quran, chapter 49, verse 12. If I find they watch, I tell them. In Shaa Allah.
@NecroCircuit@CaptainBozoX If you lack a basic understanding, don't blame me; the women will be the majority in hell and the minority in jannah because of their bad and good deeds, not because of what I shared. Read Quran ch. 6, verse 164.
Hadith does relate to the post for those who understand good.
@NecroCircuit@CaptainBozoX Stop lying about me; I didn't say that! I just shared a Hadith; you got triggered- why? You better look at yourself.
If you insist so much, I take you as one of my relatives; do you have any worth? Check with Netanyahu and let me know.
The Misuse of Da‘eef Hadith: Refuting the False Authentication of Prophetic Predictions Through Apparent Fulfilment.
Your ignorance will take you to Hell. Read this now.
Read this ya medical doctor
ppl mix up 2 separate questions. is the chain sound? thats for hadith criteria. did the event happen? thats for reality. a weak grading only answers the first one. if smth happens in front of ur eyes, a grading from 1,200 yrs ago cant undo it.
if it rains the ground gets wet. but if the ground is wet, did it have to be rain? no. same here. fulfillment doesnt prove a report is from the Prophet ﷺ, authenticity has its own rules. but it does prove the prophecy wasnt a random guess.
weak doesnt mean fake. Ibn al-Ṣalāḥ said when scholars call a hadith "not ṣaḥīḥ" it doesnt mean its a lie in reality, just that the chain didnt meet their conditions. ḍaʿīf and mawḍūʿ are 2 different categories.
we're not building dīn on these or saying the Prophet ﷺ 100% said them. we cite whats in the book and watch. he ﷺ gave the same stance for unverified reports from the People of the Book: dont believe them, dont deny them (Bukhārī 4485). live ur life, keep ur eyes open, and if it happens, accept it. al-Qurṭubī in al-Tadhkirah, Ibn Kathīr in al-Nihāyah and al-Suyūṭī in al-ʿArf al-Wardī all quote Nuʿaym's Kitāb al-Fitan constantly. if thats bidʿah then all 3 of them are innovators.
the real test is how specific it is. smth generic like "ppl will disrespect their parents" proves nothing, anyone could guess that. im talking abt super specific reports written down centuries before the event. Nuʿaym died in 228 AH, so his book was already circulating way before any of this happened. nobody can say it was written after the fact.
but it only counts if 2 things are true:
the wording matches the event on its plain meaning, no ta’wil
the text is in a copy dated before the event
if both check out, "a liar made it up" doesnt work anymore, bc a liar cant make up knowledge of the unseen.
and sometimes ppl push the prophecy into happening themselves. Third Temple activists raising red heifers, Christian Zionists backing Israel to bring the Second Coming, Mahdist movements building politics around the Return. whether a sign happens on its own or someone forces it, its still on the map. ignoring it bc of a grading on paper is the real mistake in method.
this isnt some fringe method either. al-Ḥāfiẓ al-ʿIrāqī said: "As for hadiths in matters other than rulings and creeds, they permitted leniency in their chains of transmission, if it is not concerning rulings and creeds, if it is in encouragement, intimidation, and admonition."
Phrasing of Weakness (Ṣīghat al-Tamrīḍ): When a narration is weak (ḍaʿīf), scholars avoid attributing it directly to the Prophet ﷺ so they do not accidentally ascribe false words to him. Instead, they use passive or indirect phrases like "It is narrated..." (Yurwā), "It is reported..." (Ruwiya), or "It is mentioned..." (Yudhkaru).
Because the chains of transmission in al-ʿUzlah and al-Zuhd are weak, saying "The Prophet ﷺ is reported to have said" is the proper, ethical way to share the text while signaling that its attribution is unverified.
@vanillamuffn Your post is against the fundamentals of Islam. Allaah, the Almighty, is above His throne[Quran 7:54], not in Jannah, and Jannah is for those who are born, tested and succeed in this world(Qur'an ch 67 verse 2). If you were never born, never enter Jannah.