Would the Erie County, NY County Attorney in this video have time stamped or even accepted the FOIL request if the person hadn’t been recording?
I doubt it. It's obvious that he didn't want to accept it.
On Jan. 17, 2023, First Amendment auditor Daniel Warmus entered the Erie County Attorney’s Office in Buffalo, New York while recording to submit an in-person FOIL request.
He wanted to ask who pays for security at Buffalo Bills games involving the Erie County Sheriff’s Office.
After writing the request on paper provided by staff, he asked for a timestamped copy as proof of receipt.
County Attorney Jeremy C. Toth refused, saying: “We can’t give you a copy… because it’s our copy machine… we don’t make copies here for members of the public,” and later “We’re not Kinko’s.”
Toth then asked him to leave and called security.
Warmus left without the receipt.
Under NY FOIL, agencies must accept written requests and respond within five business days.
A stamped copy of the submission is routine elsewhere to document the request and date.
❓Is Jeremy Toth paid to serve the public or to protect the copy machine from the public?
❓When Toth said “I’m done having this conversation” does mean the County Attorney is above answering questions?
❓What does “we don’t make copies for people walking off the street” say about his view of the public?
@A75retired@CommonlyStellar@pitboxer_crafts People getting their law degree on X by watching auditor videos seem to learn more about constitutional rights than police do in the academy. At least that’s how it looks to me.
❓Should a police officer order a citizen to take their hands out of their pockets and draw his gun on them when they say no, when there is no reasonable suspicion of a crime?
In November 2024, at a Walmart parking lot in Anderson, South Carolina, a man waiting for his sister-in-law (who works at the store) approached a parked Anderson Police Department vehicle (unit 2036) while recording to note the car number.
He had a hand in his pocket and identified as a First Amendment auditor.
Officer Owens ordered him to remove his hand from his pocket for “officer safety.”
The man refused, stating he was not detained and had broken no law.
Owens then drew his firearm, cursed at him, accused him of trying to provoke/“pick a fight” with police, and detained him for a frisk.
Backup arrived, including Officer N. Veneziano.
The man repeatedly asserted there is no law against having a hand in a pocket absent Reasonable Articulable Suspicion of a crime and demanded a supervisor.
He was threatened but not arrested.
❓What is the difference between a lawful order during a detention and an unlawful demand during a consensual encounter?
❓Is it a consensual encounter when the officer exits his vehicle and immediately draws his gun on you?
Watch this bodycam, do you think Officer Tabisz intentionally threw the handcuffed man to the ground or was it an accident he immediately tried to cover with an awkward “why did you fall”?
or did he do it intentionally and then be a smart-aleck?
Waukegan, IL – December 14, 2023 - Bodycam shows Waukegan Police Officer Richard Tabisz leading a handcuffed suspect to his squad car.
The man stops walking.
Tabisz then yanks him backward onto the paved driveway. The suspect’s head hits the ground; he is heard groaning in pain and later treated at a hospital.
Tabisz is recorded saying: “Oh, you fell, dude. Why’d you fall? Why’d you fall? Get up.”
Lake County prosecutors said the situation was already under control (multiple officers on scene, suspect in custody for several minutes, cooperative).
Tabisz was not the arresting officer; he had arrived only as the transport officer.
Outcome:
▪️Charged January 2024 with two felony counts of official misconduct and two misdemeanor counts of battery.
▪️Fired from the Waukegan Police Department in March 2024.
▪️May 2026 bench trial: Found guilty of misdemeanor reckless conduct; acquitted of the felony official misconduct and misdemeanor battery charges.
Prosecutors disagreed with the acquittals and called him a “rogue” officer.
The victim did not testify.
🔹Sentenced to 18 months probation, 180 days in jail (stayed pending compliance), and 100 hours of public service.
🔹Related civil lawsuit settled in 2025 for an undisclosed amount.
❓Several officers walked past or were nearby and witnessed it. Why didn't any of them intervene or even acknowledge what just happened?
❓After seeing the full sequence — the throw, the moan, the “why did you fall?”, and the officers walking past — what is the single strongest takeaway for you?
@A75retired@CommonlyStellar@pitboxer_crafts Find other crimes' — meaning ignore protected rights and keep digging until you find something you can arrest for?
That isn’t enforcement. That’s fishing for a charge.
I really hope that’s not what you meant.
@SenatorRicketts You're not trying to protect children. You're USING children as an excuse to attack the hemp industry and legal adult users nationwide on behalf of the alcohol industry. You're not fooling anybody.
Alabama officer tells man recording the police station from the parking lot - "THIS IS PRIVATE PROPERTY!"
Hit the road!
On March 13, 2021, a First Amendment auditor from the News Now Alabama channel was filming in the parking lot of the Birmingham Police Department East Precinct (600 Red Lane Road, Birmingham, AL) when confronted by officers.
Officer Mason (badge 3546) approached and said the man was “walking around our parking lot filming everything.”
When the auditor declined to give his full name, Mason ordered him off the property, calling it “our property” and private.
The auditor refused, stated it was public City of Birmingham property, requested a supervisor, and continued asserting his right to film.
A supervisor arrived and also directed him to leave the lot and film from across the street instead.
The auditor refused to leave, maintained the area was public property open to filming, and the encounter stayed verbal.
No arrest occurred.
Officers eventually disengaged while the auditor remained and continued documenting.
Core issues:
▪️Officers treated the open precinct parking lot as restricted private property and demanded the auditor leave and identify himself;
▪️the auditor treated it as public space where filming government facilities and officers is protected activity.
Alabama’s stop-and-identify statute (§ 15-5-30) requires reasonable suspicion of a crime before an officer can demand name/address/explanation of actions; filming alone is not a crime.
❓What do you think—should open parking lots at police stations be treated as off-limits to public filming?
❓What do you think when you hear a police officer say things like "our property" - "my streets" - "my highway" - "my town"?
❓Why are police so disturbed by someone recording or taking photos of their stations or cars?
A cannabis dispensary calls the sheriffs and tells them someone is outside recording patients in the drive-thru and violating HIPPA laws.
Cannabis dispensaries aren't even HIPAA-covered entities because cannabis is not billed through insurance.
A sheriff's deputy responds and spouts the same nonsense because that's what the workers said when they called and he thinks they know what they're talking about - they were all wrong.
In 2022 at All Greens Dispensary (10032 W Bell Rd, Sun City, AZ — Maricopa County), a citizen stood on public property near the drive-thru/parking area and recorded the exterior.
All Greens staff called the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office, claiming the filming violated HIPAA because some customers were medical patients.
Deputy Simonson (MCSO) responded and told the man the issue was that “some of these people are medical patients. So, it’s a HIPAA violation for you to be filming them as they’re getting their medication.”
He asked him to move along and stop filming customers, while acknowledging the man was on public property and had not entered the business or private property.
The man largely remained silent and continued recording.
After this short video ends the auditor gave him pushback on the legal claim, Deputy Simonson left then returned and walked the HIPPA claim back.
The deputy essentially got educated on the spot that the HIPAA argument did not apply.
Outcome:
No arrest. No citation. No further enforcement.
The interaction ended with the deputy conceding the point.
Key takeaways:
HIPAA primarily binds covered entities (health plans, certain providers, etc.) regarding protected health information.
A private citizen recording people in a public area outside a dispensary is not a HIPAA violation.
Recording from a public sidewalk or right-of-way is protected First Amendment activity.
This is a clear example of a business and initially a deputy incorrectly invoking HIPAA to try to stop public recording.
❓Did you know cannabis dispensaries are not yet even HIPAA-covered entities?
❓What’s the most common misunderstanding people have about filming in public?
❓What’s your biggest pet peeve when watching these audit videos?
What's REALLY going on for an officer to say someone is under arrest for failure to ID and then later change to say they were only detained - for investigative purposes?
January 20, 2021 — Jersey Village, Texas
Two men walking on a public sidewalk were confronted by Jersey Village Police Officer Mark Zatzkin after an anonymous tip claimed they were “looking into vehicles.”
The men were Earl David Worden (“David”) of News Now Community / News Now Houston and his companion Patrick.
They were recording the encounter.
Zatzkin approached, stated they were “suspicious persons,” and demanded identification.
The men declined. They cited Texas Penal Code §38.02, which makes it an offense to intentionally refuse to give your name, address, or date of birth only after a lawful arrest — not during a mere detention or investigative stop.
Texas is not a stop-and-identify state.
Zatzkin did not accept that distinction.
He handcuffed David, reached into his pocket, removed his wallet, and took out his driver’s license (described by the officer in relation to a Terry frisk).
He then stated they were under arrest for failure to identify, a Class C misdemeanor under §38.02. At least one of the men was placed in a patrol car.
A supervisor arrived on scene and contacted the district attorney’s office.
Both men were then released with no charges.
Jersey Village PD later indicated it does not make arrests based on anonymous tips of that nature.
The officer subsequently characterized the stop as a detention rather than an arrest.
Outcomes:
▪️The two men were released on scene the same day with no charges filed.
▪️Officer Mark Zatzkin resigned from the Jersey Village Police Department the following day (January 21, 2021) while complaints related to the incident and prior issues were under review.
🔹He was later hired as a deputy by the Waller County Sheriff’s Office.
❓Did Officer Zatzkin really not know the law, or did he just not care?
❓If the law is clear that ID is only required after a lawful arrest, why do so many officers still demand it on the street?
Watch this bodycam, do you think Officer Tabisz intentionally threw the handcuffed man to the ground or was it an accident he immediately tried to cover with an awkward “why did you fall”?
or did he do it intentionally and then be a smart-aleck?
Waukegan, IL – December 14, 2023 - Bodycam shows Waukegan Police Officer Richard Tabisz leading a handcuffed suspect to his squad car.
The man stops walking.
Tabisz then yanks him backward onto the paved driveway. The suspect’s head hits the ground; he is heard groaning in pain and later treated at a hospital.
Tabisz is recorded saying: “Oh, you fell, dude. Why’d you fall? Why’d you fall? Get up.”
Lake County prosecutors said the situation was already under control (multiple officers on scene, suspect in custody for several minutes, cooperative).
Tabisz was not the arresting officer; he had arrived only as the transport officer.
Outcome:
▪️Charged January 2024 with two felony counts of official misconduct and two misdemeanor counts of battery.
▪️Fired from the Waukegan Police Department in March 2024.
▪️May 2026 bench trial: Found guilty of misdemeanor reckless conduct; acquitted of the felony official misconduct and misdemeanor battery charges.
Prosecutors disagreed with the acquittals and called him a “rogue” officer.
The victim did not testify.
🔹Sentenced to 18 months probation, 180 days in jail (stayed pending compliance), and 100 hours of public service.
🔹Related civil lawsuit settled in 2025 for an undisclosed amount.
❓Several officers walked past or were nearby and witnessed it. Why didn't any of them intervene or even acknowledge what just happened?
❓After seeing the full sequence — the throw, the moan, the “why did you fall?”, and the officers walking past — what is the single strongest takeaway for you?
@MarijuanaMoment I will not support any candidate who is anti-hemp or anti-cannabis.
I live in Mississippi and I didn't vote for Cindy Hyde-Smith because of her opposition to cannabis and hemp products. I cast no vote in that race at all.
I refuse to vote against my own interest ever again.
New York’s FOIL (Freedom of Information Law) is the state’s open-records law; the federal FOIA (Freedom of Information Act) is the U.S. law that applies only to federal executive-branch agencies.
They share the same basic goal of public access to government records, but they cover different entities, follow different procedures, and are interpreted under different case law.
Would the Erie County, NY County Attorney in this video have time stamped or even accepted the FOIL request if the person hadn’t been recording?
I doubt it. It's obvious that he didn't want to accept it.
On Jan. 17, 2023, First Amendment auditor Daniel Warmus entered the Erie County Attorney’s Office in Buffalo, New York while recording to submit an in-person FOIL request.
He wanted to ask who pays for security at Buffalo Bills games involving the Erie County Sheriff’s Office.
After writing the request on paper provided by staff, he asked for a timestamped copy as proof of receipt.
County Attorney Jeremy C. Toth refused, saying: “We can’t give you a copy… because it’s our copy machine… we don’t make copies here for members of the public,” and later “We’re not Kinko’s.”
Toth then asked him to leave and called security.
Warmus left without the receipt.
Under NY FOIL, agencies must accept written requests and respond within five business days.
A stamped copy of the submission is routine elsewhere to document the request and date.
❓Is Jeremy Toth paid to serve the public or to protect the copy machine from the public?
❓When Toth said “I’m done having this conversation” does mean the County Attorney is above answering questions?
❓What does “we don’t make copies for people walking off the street” say about his view of the public?
🚒Detroit FD Engine 54 Refused To Respond to a Cardiac Arrest Call Two Blocks Away From Their Station Because Their Tablet Was Down — The Man Died
Listen to the recording of the dispatcher calling the FD shift captain to relay her concerns.
On August 4, 2026, George Walter Willis suffered a cardiac arrest at his home on the 17000 block of Pierson Street in Detroit.
His wife Madeline found him unresponsive in the bathroom and began CPR.
Their son Walter called 911 at 11:34 a.m.
Detroit Fire Department Engine 54 — stationed roughly two blocks away at 16825 Trinity St. — was the closest unit.
Dispatch contacted them and asked them to respond.
The crew refused, stating they were out of service for medical calls because their electronic patient care reporting tablet was not working.
They told dispatch they could not respond without the tablet.
Dispatchers pushed back, noting the call was a cardiac arrest only a short distance away and asking if the crew could at least go and start CPR until other units arrived.
Engine 54 still declined.
Other units (including Engine 59) that had already been dispatched arrived on scene approximately 8 minutes and 29 seconds after the initial 911 call.
CPR was continued by responders for about 20 minutes, but George Walter Willis died.
Detroit Fire Department later stated the crew was following existing protocol at the time regarding the out-of-service tablet.
The department said it has since updated policies so dispatch is immediately notified of non-functioning tablets, with paper backup procedures also in place.
❓Do you think this would have been handled differently in your city?
❓How would you respond had this happened to your loved one?
❓Is this an isolated incident or a sign of a bigger problem in Detroit Fire Department?
A few weeks ago in Mississippi the police did my buddy this way and worse.
This is what he told me;
He had just left a Bass Pro Shop and pulled into an empty parking lot nearby to examine something he'd bought.
In less than a minute he was confronted by a cop who called for more.
Seven in all.
They made him get out, provide ID, searched him and searched his truck.
He's a cancer survivor who recently took a medical retirement from the fire department due to an on duty injury.
He's no drug abuser.
He said the "interdiction" officer that arrived kept bragging, "I'm good at what I do" and asking questions about whether he used meth or cocaine.
All they found was three nicotine vapes in his console and they confiscated those.
He said he was detained for almost an hour before they let him leave.
🛑Never park in the parking lot of a business after hours.
I see multiple videos daily showing police detaining, identifying and even searching people for no reason other than "being suspicious" by being parked in an empty lot.
In West Chester Township, Ohio, Road Patrol Lt. Douglas Farris of the West Chester Police Department approached a man parked in a lot near UPS drop-off boxes.
Footage published in January 2026 shows Farris (badge 187) claiming “reasonable suspicion” of a potential crime and demanding the man’s name, address, and date of birth.
He stated that refusal itself was a crime under Ohio law and at one point told the man he was “arrested for failing to identify” and that providing his name would end the encounter.
The man refused, noted the lack of no-parking or private-property signs, and asked for the officers’ names and badges.
A second officer was present.
After the man continued to refuse, Farris (or the other officer) ran the vehicle’s license plate.
Farris then stated that his suspicion was resolved, he could no longer detain the man, and left.
No arrest, citation, booking, or subsequent charges have been reported from the stop.
❓Does parking in a vacant lot after the business closes ever justify a full ID demand on its own?
❓Is "reasonable suspicion" in law-speak simply being suspicious of someone and believing it to be reasonable? - If not, why do so many police officers think it is?
@SenTedBuddNC Adults don't need protecting from hemp, Senator.
All you are doing by banning hemp is causing people to purchase illegal marijuana on the black market.
Remember the Texas vote.
Hopefully you'll be next.
🛑Never park in the parking lot of a business after hours.
I see multiple videos daily showing police detaining, identifying and even searching people for no reason other than "being suspicious" by being parked in an empty lot.
In West Chester Township, Ohio, Road Patrol Lt. Douglas Farris of the West Chester Police Department approached a man parked in a lot near UPS drop-off boxes.
Footage published in January 2026 shows Farris (badge 187) claiming “reasonable suspicion” of a potential crime and demanding the man’s name, address, and date of birth.
He stated that refusal itself was a crime under Ohio law and at one point told the man he was “arrested for failing to identify” and that providing his name would end the encounter.
The man refused, noted the lack of no-parking or private-property signs, and asked for the officers’ names and badges.
A second officer was present.
After the man continued to refuse, Farris (or the other officer) ran the vehicle’s license plate.
Farris then stated that his suspicion was resolved, he could no longer detain the man, and left.
No arrest, citation, booking, or subsequent charges have been reported from the stop.
❓Does parking in a vacant lot after the business closes ever justify a full ID demand on its own?
❓Is "reasonable suspicion" in law-speak simply being suspicious of someone and believing it to be reasonable? - If not, why do so many police officers think it is?