I’ll let AI handle this:
“30 times more likely” claim - FALSE
Based on FBI data, In 2019, there were 566 Black-on-white homicides and 246 white-on-Black homicides . The actual ratio is 2.3:1, not 30:1. This is nowhere near “30 times more likely.”
“560 white people killed by blacks, 240 black people killed by whites” - APPROXIMATELY CORRECT
The actual FBI figures: 566 and 246. He’s close on the raw numbers but wildly wrong on the interpretation.
“560,000 violent interracial incidents, 85% black on white” - NEEDS CONTEXT
This appears to reference NCVS (victimization survey) data, not FBI arrest data. These surveys have known issues with racial identification and reporting biases.
CRITICAL CONTEXT WALSH IGNORES:
1. Most violence is INTRARACIAL
White-on-white homicides: 2,594; Black-on-Black homicides: 2,574
- 81% of white victims are killed by white people
- 91% of Black victims are killed by Black people
2. White people kill more white people than Black people kill anyone
The 2,594 white-on-white murders exceed the total of ALL homicides committed by Black offenders against ALL races combined.
3. The “most dangerous demographic” claim is inflammatory and misleading
- It ignores that violence correlates with poverty, not race
- It ignores systemic factors like segregation and disinvestment
- When controlling for socioeconomic factors, racial disparities in crime diminish significantly
4. Cherry-picking violent crime while ignoring:
- White Americans commit 82% of DUIs
- White Americans commit the majority of mass shootings
- White collar crime costs society far more than street crime
The Bottom Line: Walsh uses real numbers but strips them of context to paint Black Americans as uniquely dangerous. This is textbook manipulation of statistics to serve a racist narrative. The data actually shows that Americans of all races are overwhelmingly more likely to be harmed by someone of their own race, and that crime is driven by poverty and social conditions, not skin color.
America was founded to be the true successor of Ancient Rome.
But most don't know how deep the parallels run: from its grid plans to its constitution.
Here's why we still live in Rome — and why it won't collapse this time… (thread) 🧵