Vocês são um bando de covardes, isso sim. Uma coisa é uma música soar parecida em um ponto ou outro, outra coisa é ela ser idêntica em tudo e até mesmo no videoclipe, se tivesse acontecido isso com TOP ou GD vocês estariam em guerra, mas como é o Daesung está tudo bem.
The topic is the song, not the tool used to translate a reply.
Please get back to the actual point: why is the chorus of Lee’s song so similar to Daesung’s song?
@Seokgyu_Luvr You don’t have to agree with the criticism, but pretending the criticism is about “gatekeeping trot” is just avoiding the actual discussion.
@Seokgyu_Luvr “Limited notes,” “common patterns,” and “other trot songs sound similar” can explain why similarities happen, but they cannot be used as a blanket excuse to dismiss every case. Otherwise plagiarism would never exist in any genre.
@Seokgyu_Luvr You keep fighting against a claim nobody made. No one is trying to ban trot, own trot, or stop anyone from singing trot. The only question is whether this specific chorus is too similar.
@BurnacleZzz You’re explaining why similarities can exist, not proving why this particular similarity should be dismissed. Those are two different things. A shared musical vocabulary is normal. A highly recognizable resemblance in the most memorable part of a song is what people are debating.
@BurnacleZzz The “limited notes” argument is only valid up to a point. Every song in history uses the same 12 notes, common chords, and familiar structures, but that doesn’t mean every similarity should be ignored. The details and the expression are what matter.
@Seokgyu_Luvr When the argument runs out, the next step is usually attacking the person instead of addressing the evidence. The topic is the song, not ChatGPT.☺️
@BurnacleZzz Listing other trot songs with similar vibes doesn’t automatically answer the comparison between these two songs. Common elements can exist, but each similarity still has to be judged individually.
@BurnacleZzz And again, “it’s trot” explains why similarities can happen, but it doesn’t automatically dismiss every similarity. That’s why comparisons exist in the first place.
@BurnacleZzz “Only the chorus hook is similar” is not the defense you think it is. The chorus is literally the core identity of a song. Nobody compares songs because the background instruments are the same; they compare the parts that define the song.
@BurnacleZzz You’re treating “it’s common in trot” as if it’s a universal defense. It’s not. Genre conventions can explain some similarities, but they don’t automatically explain every similarity. That’s exactly why people are comparing these two specific choruses instead of accusing
@BurnacleZzz If you’re so confident they’re not comparable, then explain why so many people independently pointed out the similarity in this chorus instead of repeatedly bringing up completely different songs.
@BurnacleZzz You keep listing unrelated examples instead of addressing the actual comparison. “Other songs sound similar too” isn’t a rebuttal—it’s a distraction. The discussion is about this chorus, not Jennie, Rosé, or Lady Gaga. If your argument depends on changing the subject, maybe you